Man finds out he’s not the father of girlfriend’s daughter and shoots her in the head

GRAND HAVEN, MI – Vaughn Smith faced a Michigan courtroom on Friday, nearly a year after a domestic dispute that resulted in him shooting his girlfriend over conflict regarding the paternity of one of their children concluded in a substantial prison sentence.

Smith, who was 35 at the time of the incident, wept through the sentencing as he admitted guilt to charges of assault with intent to commit murder and firearms violations. Despite a plea from his girlfriend for a more lenient sentence, the court ultimately upheld a stern verdict.

The events leading to the tragic night were marked by escalating arguments centered on revelations about the paternity of one of the children. According to available details, on May 23, 2024, the dispute turned violent when Smith shot his girlfriend twice in the head and leg. Her 16-year-old son intervened, subduing Smith by stabbing him in protection of his mother, while a neighbor called emergency services upon witnessing the chaos.

After hospitalization, where she recovered from her injuries, the girlfriend recounted to police how Smith had threatened her life prior to the attack. Meanwhile, Smith was detained and held in the Ottawa County Jail as legal proceedings ensued.

When Smith stood in court on April 18, his emotions were raw as he expressed remorse, acknowledging the irreversible burden of his actions upon learning the child he thought was his was not. “I made a terrible decision that day,” Smith stated. He pleaded with the judge for understanding, citing emotional turmoil over unresolved relationship issues.

Smith’s girlfriend, despite being the victim, asked the court to consider his efforts towards self-improvement, painting a picture of a man striving to be both a better parent and community member.

Judge Jon H. Hulsing, weighing Smith’s remorse against the severity of the crime, recognized his genuine contrition but emphasized the need for accountability. Hulsing handed down a sentence of nearly 30 years, which could extend to a maximum of 75 years. The ruling included credit for time already served.

As Smith starts his sentence, the case underscores the complicated interplay of personal emotions and legal consequences in the wake of violent acts. The profound impact on all those involved serves as a solemn reminder of the potential tragic outcomes rooted in unresolved personal conflicts.