Chicago, IL — The selection of Robert Francis Prevost, now known as Pope Leo XIV, has sent ripples through the landscape of U.S. politics, particularly among conservative circles. His ascension as the first American pontiff comes at a time when Catholicism wields considerable influence in political discussions, especially under the Trump administration, which has embraced faith-driven agendas.

Supporters of Donald Trump were quick to express disappointment as they perceived that Pope Leo XIV might not align with the “America first” doctrine that has characterized the former president’s rhetoric. Initial impressions suggest that the new pope’s social and political views may lean more toward progressive stances, in line with those of his predecessor, Pope Francis. Leo has openly discussed concerns regarding poverty and immigration, issues that are often at odds with the current U.S. administration’s policies.

Key figures in the MAGA movement have voiced their skepticism about the new pope’s potential impact on U.S. politics. Steve Bannon, a prominent strategist for Trump, remarked that Leo’s history of criticizing American politicians could lead to significant friction between the Vatican and the White House. He stated that Leo’s electoral journey serves as a stark contrast to Trump’s agenda, emphasizing possible tensions ahead.

Bannon’s concerns extend beyond mere political rivalry. He hinted at a larger ideological split within the American Catholic community. As the new pope faces pressures to address contentious issues such as immigration reform, critics believe he may challenge Trump’s hardline policies.

Family members of Pope Leo XIV have also weighed in, with his brother, John Prevost, asserting that the pope is unlikely to remain silent on issues that conflict with his values. John highlighted that Leo is particularly concerned about the ongoing immigration crisis, a stance that could complicate relationships with some U.S. politicians.

While roughly 20% of Americans identify as Catholic, a Pew Research Center survey reveals that a significant portion align with Republican ideals, though many hold differing opinions on key issues. Historical precedents exist, as illustrated by former Catholic presidents John F. Kennedy and Joe Biden, both Democrats with policy views that diverged from mainstream Republican doctrine.

In Chicago, reactions among local Catholics reflect a mix of disappointment and cautious optimism regarding the new pope’s direction. Some hope that Leo will continue the more inclusive agenda of Pope Francis. Rick Stevens, a deacon from New Jersey, expressed his desire for Leo to follow Francis’s path, advocating for unity and compassion.

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops welcomed Leo’s election, noting that his leadership can bridge gaps between Catholics and broader society. They pointed to his messages about peace and community as promising signs for his papacy.

Although supporters of Trump represent a small segment of the Catholic demographic, their influence on conservative media platforms cannot be understated. Voices on platforms like Bannon’s War Room have echoed concerns about the pope’s alignment with progressive ideals, raising questions about his priorities.

Social media activity attributed to Leo, along with his historical advocacy, has intensified scrutiny of his political leanings. Posts dating back to 2015 reveal his criticisms of the Trump administration’s stances on immigration and gun control, raising the eyebrows of conservative commentators.

As debate continues within both the Catholic Church and American politics, many await further developments concerning Leo’s papacy. His relationship with the Trump administration may serve as a touchstone for larger discussions around faith and policy in the U.S., potentially reshaping the bonds between religion and politics in the years to come.