Quarterback Showdown: Will Rookie Tyler Shough Rise Above Saints’ Competition in Post-Derek Carr Era?

New Orleans, Louisiana — The New Orleans Saints have officially turned the page on the Derek Carr era, signaling a new dawn as they prepare for a quarterback competition to determine their starter for the upcoming season. With the departure of Carr, the team is evaluating three contenders: rookie Tyler Shough, Jake Haener, and Spencer Rattler.

Head Coach Kellen Moore addressed the media on Saturday, emphasizing that all three quarterbacks will have the opportunity to prove themselves during the upcoming preseason. “We’re going to let all three of these guys roll,” Moore stated, noting that each of them has earned the opportunity to compete for the starting role. The Saints’ head coach is optimistic that one of them will distinguish themselves once the games begin.

A critical aspect of the evaluation process will be how each candidate executes the offensive game plan and interacts with teammates. Moore underscored the importance of leadership in the quarterback position. “It’s really important to see these guys take ownership,” he explained. “That leadership role comes alive during training camp and preseason games, where we can get a true glimpse of their capabilities.”

During rookie minicamp, Shough showcased his skills in competitive seven-on-seven drills, impressing Moore in his initial performance at the NFL level. The rookie will soon join the veterans as part of the ongoing offseason activities, allowing him more opportunities to acclimate to the team’s dynamics.

When asked about the possibility of acquiring a veteran quarterback, Moore mentioned that the organization remains vigilant for potential opportunities to strengthen their roster. The Saints aim to construct a well-rounded team as they prepare for the demands of a new season.

Haener, a fourth-round draft selection in 2023, made appearances in eight games last season and has experience under his belt. He passed for 226 yards, with one touchdown and one interception during his brief time on the field. Rattler, a fifth-round pick in 2024, showed promise in seven games, completing 130 passes for 1,317 yards, along with four touchdown passes.

Shough, who was selected with the 40th pick in the 2025 draft, has the potential to quickly transition into a viable starter, a scenario Coach Moore has seen before. Reflecting on his own experience in Dallas, he recalled how Dak Prescott, a fourth-round pick, excelled as a rookie after stepping in for an injured Tony Romo.

As Training Camp approaches, the Saints are poised for a dynamic quarterback battle. Each candidate brings unique skills and experience to the field, setting the stage for an exciting competition that could shape the team’s season ahead. As the coaching staff assesses their options, the quest for a new leader under center is just beginning.