One defendant has been sentenced, while Michael Wallace is due in court Dec. 8 after admitting to first-degree murder.
DECATUR, Ill. — Fifteen years after 17-year-old Caleb Witty was shot and killed while protecting his younger sister during an attempted robbery, the criminal case that remained unsolved for more than a decade has reached convictions against both men arrested in his death. Michael Wallace pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in October and is awaiting sentencing, while co-defendant Bobby Gipson has pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received an eight-year prison term.
The two outcomes bring the long-running case closer to its final court milestone while also showing the different roles prosecutors assigned to the defendants. Wallace, 36, entered his plea Oct. 19 on the morning his jury trial was scheduled to begin. His agreement removed a firearm sentencing enhancement and capped his prison term at 40 years. Gipson, 37, pleaded guilty three days later to second-degree murder. A judge sentenced him Nov. 5 to eight years in prison followed by one year of probation. Wallace is scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 8.
Wallace’s plea ended preparations for a trial that prosecutors and defense lawyers had said they were ready to begin. Court records cited by local television station WAND showed that more than 20 people had been subpoenaed, including current and former Decatur police officers and detectives. Wallace had been charged with multiple counts of first-degree murder after his June 2024 arrest. He ultimately pleaded guilty to a count of murder committed during another forcible felony. The remaining counts were dismissed under the agreement. Prosecutors said the firearm enhancement also was removed, limiting the sentence a judge may impose to no more than 40 years.
Gipson’s case took a different course. He had also been arrested on first-degree murder charges in 2024, but prosecutors said he did not fire the gun and played a secondary role in the crime. He pleaded guilty Oct. 22 to second-degree murder, and the original first-degree murder counts against him were dismissed as part of the disposition. The Macon County State’s Attorney’s Office said Gipson would testify that Wallace was the person who shot Witty. At Gipson’s sentencing two weeks later, the judge imposed eight years in prison and a year of probation.
The crime at the center of the cases happened late on Aug. 4, 2011, after Witty and his then-14-year-old sister attended the Decatur Celebration, a large street festival. Police said the siblings were walking home on the city’s east side at about 11:30 p.m. when two men approached them in the 2200 block of East Johns Avenue and demanded money. Accounts released by police said Witty put himself between the men and his sister, allowing her to get away. He was shot and died from his injuries. His sister survived.
Early accounts from investigators and later court reporting described the confrontation in slightly different levels of detail, but the central sequence has remained consistent: an attempted robbery, Witty’s effort to protect his sister and the fatal shooting that followed. Police said one of the men struck Witty with a gun during the confrontation. His sister told investigators that she ran and then heard a gunshot. Police later said Witty had been shot multiple times. The department has consistently described his actions as an attempt to shield his younger sister during the robbery.
For years, however, no one was charged. Family members and friends continued to remember Witty publicly, including through candlelight vigils around the time of the annual Decatur Celebration. Local reporting documented the family’s repeated appeals for information as anniversaries passed without an arrest. Police said the investigation never formally disappeared, even as the case grew older. The major break came in 2024, when investigators said additional cooperation from people with information helped move the case forward. Authorities have not publicly provided a complete account of every piece of evidence that led to the charges.
Police arrested Wallace in Decatur in June 2024 and announced that Gipson had been arrested in Tennessee, where he was living at the time. Gipson was later returned to Illinois. Both men initially faced first-degree murder charges. Then-Decatur Police Chief Shane Brandel said after the arrests that progress in the investigation followed years of work involving local officers, the Macon County State’s Attorney’s Office, other agencies and members of the community. He compared the breakthrough to one domino falling and leading investigators to the next step.
The years between Witty’s death and the arrests were also central to statements made after the convictions. Macon County State’s Attorney Diane Couri credited the Decatur Police Department and specifically recognized investigators who continued working the case. Her office also credited witnesses who eventually came forward. The prosecution said that cooperation, combined with the work of law enforcement and Witty’s family, made it possible to hold the defendants responsible more than 15 years after the killing.
The human cost of that delay was especially visible at Gipson’s Nov. 5 sentencing. Witty’s father, Richard Kelsey, addressed the court and spoke about the difficulty of forgiving the man convicted of taking part in the crime. Witty’s brother Nicholas Kelsey described the lasting absence created by Caleb’s death. Another sibling, Elizabeth Kelsey, who was not yet born when Caleb was killed, entered the courtroom carrying his photograph and spoke about growing up knowing her brother through stories told by relatives. The statements showed how a case measured in years by police and courts was experienced differently inside Witty’s family.
Those family statements came after years of similar public memories. Witty’s aunt spoke to WAND the day after the 2011 shooting about the shock of seeing him after the attack. His mother, Jennifer Kirby, told the station years later that she still missed the sound of her son’s laugh. Friends and relatives kept his name in public view through vigils as the investigation remained open. When police finally announced arrests in 2024, the department described Witty as a teenager who had been trying to enjoy an evening at the festival with his sister before the robbery turned deadly.
The convictions do not erase the long period when the case had no public answer, and the two defendants did not receive identical outcomes. Prosecutors distinguished Gipson’s role from Wallace’s, saying Gipson was not the shooter. Gipson’s second-degree murder conviction and eight-year sentence resolved his criminal case at the trial-court level. Wallace’s first-degree murder conviction carries a substantially different sentencing exposure, although his plea agreement prevents the judge from imposing more than 40 years. The precise sentence has not yet been decided.
Wallace is due back in Macon County court Dec. 8 for sentencing. Until the judge imposes that sentence, the final punishment in the case remains unresolved. What has changed since the years when Witty’s killing was described as an unsolved homicide is that both men arrested in 2024 have now entered guilty pleas, and one has already been sentenced. The remaining scheduled proceeding is Wallace’s sentencing, the last confirmed major court step in a case that began with a walk home from a summer festival in August 2011.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more