58-year-old Indiana man shot and burned alive in rental car

Randal Moon Jr. was the first of five defendants convicted in the case involving a burning rental car in rural Delaware County.

MUNCIE, Ind. — An Indianapolis man was sentenced to 86 years in prison after a Delaware County jury convicted him of five felonies in the killing of Michael D. Greer, a 58-year-old Shelbyville man who authorities said had been beaten and shot before he was found inside a burning rental car. Delaware Circuit Court No. 1 Judge Judi L. Calhoun imposed the sentence on Randal Moon Jr., 41, on Oct. 13, nearly a month after jurors returned guilty verdicts on murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice.

Moon’s sentencing marked the first completed prosecution among five people charged in connection with Greer’s death and gave prosecutors their first final judgment in a case that began with what initially appeared to be a vehicle fire on a rural stretch of Delaware County road. The investigation ultimately reached from the field where Greer’s rental car burned back to Indianapolis, where prosecutors said violence against Greer occurred before he was taken from the city. Moon maintained at trial that he did not know Greer was inside the vehicle or that two co-defendants planned to set it on fire. Jurors rejected that defense after hearing several days of evidence about Moon’s movements, communications and actions before and after the fire.

The case began in the early morning hours of Dec. 14, 2025. At about 3:45 a.m., Delaware County sheriff’s deputies were sent to a report of a vehicle burning in a rural area. The car was off the roadway along County Road 500 South, west of Indiana 3. After firefighters and deputies were able to examine the vehicle, investigators discovered human remains in the trunk. The remains were later identified through DNA testing as Greer, who lived in Shelbyville. Authorities said the vehicle was a rental car associated with Greer. What deputies found during the investigation quickly changed the case from a fire inquiry into a homicide investigation involving multiple suspects and two counties.

Forensic findings became a central part of the case. Investigators said Greer had suffered a beating and a gunshot wound before the vehicle reached Delaware County. An autopsy found soot in his lungs and trachea, evidence that authorities said showed Greer was still breathing when the car was set on fire. Prosecutors did not need to rely only on what happened at the rural field. Evidence presented during Moon’s trial was used to place events in a broader sequence, beginning at an Indianapolis home and continuing through the drive northeast to Delaware County. Reports on the case said Greer had been wrapped in material before he was transported from Indianapolis.

Moon acknowledged an important part of that sequence himself. In statements to investigators and later during his testimony, he admitted driving a separate vehicle while accompanying co-defendants Amy Singhas and Ameariss Aponte from Indianapolis to Delaware County early Dec. 14. After Greer’s rental car was set on fire, Singhas and Aponte got into Moon’s pickup truck and returned with him to Indianapolis, according to trial reporting. Moon did not deny making that trip. Instead, his defense focused on what he said he did not know: He testified that he was unaware Greer was in the trunk and did not know the other defendants intended to burn the vehicle.

Prosecutors argued that Moon’s role went well beyond being an unwitting driver. Cellphone location evidence presented at trial placed him at the Indianapolis residence at the time prosecutors said Greer was being beaten, according to reporting on the proceedings. Deputy Prosecutor Maricel Driscoll told jurors the evidence showed Moon was an active participant throughout the events. The prosecution also presented evidence that Moon had photographed Greer’s credit card on the morning of Greer’s death and later tried to use the card for a purchase. Prosecutors further said Moon returned with Singhas and Aponte to Greer’s Shelbyville home two days after the homicide. Those details were used to challenge Moon’s assertion that he had unknowingly become involved.

Investigators also examined Moon’s conduct after news of the burned vehicle became public. Prosecutors told jurors that cellphone data showed he had already viewed and photographed news coverage of the homicide even though he later told investigators he had not known the car fire resulted in a death. Earlier court proceedings had disclosed other evidence collected during the investigation, including surveillance video showing Moon interacting with Singhas and Aponte before the fire and communications that investigators believed concerned disposing of a body. A judge cited evidence from the investigation in March when denying Moon’s request for bond. Those allegations were later tested at trial, where Moon had the opportunity to testify and contest the state’s interpretation of the evidence.

Jurors began hearing the case Sept. 14. After a weeklong trial and several hours of deliberations, they returned guilty verdicts Sept. 18. The convictions covered both the killing and conduct surrounding it: murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Delaware County Prosecuting Attorney Eric Hoffman said after the verdict that justice had been served and praised the prosecutors, investigators and sheriff’s personnel who worked on the case. Moon’s sentencing followed on Oct. 13 before Calhoun, who ordered the 86-year prison term. The sentence was substantially longer than the maximum term available for murder standing alone because Moon was convicted of multiple offenses arising from the case.

Moon was one of five Indianapolis-area defendants arrested as investigators worked to reconstruct Greer’s final hours. Singhas, Aponte, Megan Sloan and Tallis McCoy were also charged in connection with the killing. Reports from the investigation said Singhas told authorities she drove Greer in the rental car to the rural Delaware County location. Authorities alleged that Aponte later took the driver’s seat and drove the vehicle off the roadway before it was set on fire. Those allegations concern separate criminal cases and are not resolved by Moon’s conviction. The remaining defendants are entitled to the presumption of innocence unless they are convicted or enter guilty pleas.

The investigation unfolded over several weeks rather than ending with the discovery of the vehicle. Aponte, Singhas and Moon were among the first people arrested around the time of Christmas 2025. Sloan and McCoy were charged later as investigators reviewed interviews, digital records and other evidence. By January, Sheriff Jeff Stanley announced that Indiana State Police DNA testing had formally identified the remains as Greer. The sheriff said investigators had spent extensive time conducting interviews and reviewing evidence with the Delaware County Coroner’s Office and county prosecutors. Earlier reporting also said Sloan had at one point been found incompetent to stand trial, leaving her procedural status different from Moon’s.

Greer’s death also left one significant question publicly unanswered: why he was killed. Authorities and prosecutors have described the alleged movements of the defendants and presented evidence about what happened before and after the fire, but no verified public account reviewed for this report establishes a motive. Greer’s family told Indianapolis television station WTHR that he and Singhas had been in a relationship. His obituary remembered him for his devotion to relatives and friends, his generosity and his ability to make people laugh. Those descriptions provide a picture of Greer beyond the evidence that became the focus of Moon’s criminal trial.

Moon’s 86-year sentence resolves his trial-level case but does not end the broader prosecution arising from Greer’s death. At the time of Moon’s sentencing, public court reporting listed separate proceedings for Aponte, Singhas, Sloan and McCoy, including a Dec. 14 jury trial date for McCoy in one of the latest reports. Some proceedings for other defendants had been scheduled for dates that have since passed, and reliable public reporting reviewed as of Nov. 20 did not establish a final outcome for each of those cases. Moon remains the first defendant in the group publicly confirmed to have been convicted and sentenced in Greer’s killing.

Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.