Jeffrey Lee Devorah must serve 30 years before parole eligibility after a jury convicted him of killing Tiffany Garza.
JOURDANTON, Texas — A Texas man has been sentenced to life in prison for the 2019 murder of his girlfriend, closing the trial phase of a case that began with a missing-person report and later centered on blood evidence, witness information and human bone fragments recovered from a backyard burn site.
Jeffrey Lee Devorah, 47, was convicted Aug. 13 by an Atascosa County jury of murdering Tiffany Lynette Garza, who was 37 when she disappeared. After Devorah chose to have a judge decide punishment, Judge Russell Wilson imposed a life sentence in late September. Devorah must serve 30 years before he can be considered for parole. The sentence marked the most significant legal resolution in a case that remained unresolved for years after Garza was last seen near Poteet, south of San Antonio.
Garza was last seen March 25, 2019. Her mother, Lilly Morua, reported her missing to the Atascosa County Sheriff’s Office on April 26 after Garza had been dropped off at a Dollar General store. Investigators later said they believed Garza was killed sometime between March 28 and April 4. At the time, Garza had been living at a home on Bocawood Drive in the Shalimar subdivision north of Poteet, the same property that would become the focus of a detailed search months later.
The investigation changed course in July 2019, when authorities received information pointing them to the Bocawood Drive property. According to prosecutors and earlier sheriff’s office accounts, investigators connected with a witness who said the person had seen Garza’s killing and helped burn her body in Devorah’s backyard. The Atascosa County Sheriff’s Office and Texas Rangers searched the property for three days. Inside the residence, investigators reported finding significant blood evidence. Outside, teams spent two days sifting through material from a burn pit behind the home.
Forensic specialists recovered 14 human bone fragments from the burn pile. Experts with Texas State University’s Forensic Anthropology Center determined that the remains were from a female between 22 and 56 years old, an age range that included Garza. The burned fragments themselves did not yield a usable DNA identification in the early forensic work described by investigators. That distinction became important because the strongest DNA evidence tying Garza to the property came from blood recovered inside the house, not from the fragments collected outdoors.
The blood evidence was tested by the Bexar County Crime Lab. Earlier reporting based on statements from the sheriff’s office said one blood sample was consistent with Garza’s family line, while another belonged to Devorah. Prosecutors later described the DNA evidence as matching Garza. Investigators combined that testing with the forensic assessment of the bone fragments, the witness account and other evidence gathered during the property search. Authorities have not publicly released a cause of death in the material reviewed for this report, and the precise manner in which Garza was killed has not been detailed in the sentencing coverage.
Devorah was interviewed by investigators in 2019 after an unrelated arrest. He acknowledged that Garza had been living at the Bocawood Drive residence but said he did not know what had happened to her. The case did not result in an immediate murder charge. Prosecutors later said Devorah made admissions to a former girlfriend that were consistent with physical evidence and witness statements. Those alleged admissions became another part of the case authorities said linked him to Garza’s death.
Nearly four years passed between Garza’s disappearance and Devorah’s murder arrest. San Antonio police arrested him on March 15, 2023, and he was later booked in Atascosa County. At the time, his bond was set at $500,000. Court records show the murder case was filed in June 2023 under docket number 23-06-0162-CRA. The case remained on Atascosa County trial calendars through 2024, 2025 and 2026 before reaching a jury in August 2026.
The county’s court docket confirms that Devorah’s case was set for trial in August 2026. The jury returned a guilty verdict on Aug. 13, according to the district attorney’s office and local news reports. Devorah then elected to have the judge, rather than the jury, determine punishment. A Sept. 29 court docket listed his case for sentencing, and the life term was announced after that hearing. The punishment means Devorah faces decades in state custody before he can even become eligible for parole review; eligibility does not itself guarantee release.
Garza’s relatives and close friends attended the sentencing. District Attorney Audrey Gossett Louis said afterward that the sentence could not restore what Garza’s family had lost, but that the case required sustained work to establish what happened and hold the person responsible accountable. The district attorney’s office credited investigators, forensic experts, prosecutors and jurors for carrying the case from a missing-person investigation through a murder conviction years later. The public statement also emphasized that Garza should be remembered as a person, not only as the victim at the center of a criminal case.
Garza’s family has described the long gap between her disappearance and the final court judgment as a period shaped by uncertainty, grief and missed milestones. In an October interview with KSAT after the sentencing, relatives remembered her as funny, energetic and deeply involved in family life. They spoke about ordinary memories such as cooking, joking, singing, sleepovers and teaching children to ride bikes. Those recollections offered a different frame for the case than the forensic details that dominated the investigation, focusing instead on the relationships that continued after Garza was gone.
Her family also has pointed to the future moments she never got to share. Natalie Garza said she had been pregnant when she last saw Tiffany Garza and that Tiffany had been excited about becoming a grandmother. By the time of the sentencing, that child was 7 years old. Other relatives said the life sentence brought accountability but did not resolve every emotional question. Patricia Jaime, Garza’s former partner and the mother of a son they shared, said the family still thinks about the fact that much of Garza’s remains were never recovered.
The case illustrates how the investigation depended on several kinds of evidence that did different jobs. The witness information directed authorities to the property. The search produced blood evidence and burned human remains. Forensic anthropology helped establish that the fragments came from a woman in Garza’s age range, while DNA testing of blood inside the house linked Garza to the scene. Prosecutors said Devorah’s later statements to another person were consistent with that evidence. None of those details alone explains the entire case, but together they formed the evidentiary picture presented before the conviction.
The record also shows why the sentencing date mattered beyond the announcement itself. Devorah’s case had appeared repeatedly on county dockets before reaching trial, including earlier settings that did not produce a final resolution. By late September, however, the jury had already returned its verdict and only punishment remained for the trial court to decide. That sequence distinguishes the sentence from the conviction: the jury determined criminal responsibility in August, while the judge determined the length and structure of confinement the following month after Devorah chose judicial sentencing.
With the sentencing complete, the case now rests on a jury’s murder conviction and a life term that keeps Devorah from parole consideration for three decades. The judgment closes the trial phase of a prosecution that took years to reach a courtroom, leaving Garza’s family with a legal resolution after a long investigation that began when she was reported missing in 2019.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more