Cheating Indianapolis man kills wife after she kicks him out

Cecil Mains pleaded guilty after fatally shooting Jeri Mains as their four children were home in December 2025.

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — An Indianapolis man has been sentenced to 45 years in prison for fatally shooting his wife in a case that began with four children calling 911 and drew renewed attention to a protective-order petition the woman had filed three days before her death. Cecil Mains also received five years of probation after pleading guilty to murder in the killing of Jeri Mains, 44.

The Oct. 5 sentence closes the criminal case more than nine months after the Dec. 28, 2025, shooting at the family’s home on Indianapolis’ southeast side. Prosecutors said Mains shot his wife during an argument while their four children, ranging in age from 10 to 19, were at the residence. He pleaded guilty to murder Aug. 26, avoiding a trial in which the children’s emergency calls, witness accounts and physical evidence could have played a central role. Court records reported by Law&Crime also show that a no-contact order involving the children was imposed as part of the sentence.

The punishment amounts to a 50-year sentence, with 45 years to be served in the Indiana Department of Correction and the remaining five years on probation, according to reporting based on the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office announcement. Marion County Prosecutor Ryan Mears said after sentencing that his office’s thoughts remained with Jeri Mains’ four children as the criminal proceedings ended. He said they had lost their mother to a devastating act of violence and expressed hope that they could continue to receive support as they move forward.

The fatal confrontation unfolded on Dec. 28 at the family home in the 8100 block of Meadow Bend Lane. Court documents cited by local news organizations say Cecil Mains arrived at the home, obtained a .380-caliber handgun and argued with Jeri Mains. She was shot twice, including after moving from the house toward the driveway. Officers responding to the emergency calls found her outside with gunshot wounds. She was taken to Eskenazi Hospital, where she was pronounced dead. Investigators later recovered a handgun from Cecil Mains’ vehicle after police stopped him.

The couple’s children became the first witnesses to tell authorities what had happened. According to the probable cause affidavit, multiple children called 911 during or immediately after the shooting. One child told a dispatcher that their father was shooting their mother and said they were hiding. Another reported that their father had shot their mother in the house and in the driveway. The affidavit described heavy commotion in the background of the emergency calls. The accounts placed investigators inside a rapidly unfolding family crisis before officers reached the scene.

Those calls also pointed police toward a conflict that had been developing before the shooting. One child told a dispatcher that their mother had a restraining order against Cecil Mains. The court record, however, shows that Jeri Mains had filed a petition for protection on Christmas Day and that it had not been reviewed by a judge before she was killed. The filing came during a holiday period when the relevant court office was closed. The Indianapolis Star reported that the judge’s office was closed from Dec. 24 through Dec. 28, leaving the petition awaiting judicial action.

In the petition, as described in news reports based on court records, Jeri Mains identified herself as a victim of domestic violence and described several alleged episodes involving her husband. She said he had assaulted her with kitchen tongs on Christmas Eve, leaving her with a cut and bruising. The filing also described an earlier argument in December during which he allegedly struck a computer and another confrontation in November in which she said he punched her in the face. Those accusations were made before the murder case was resolved and were separate from the murder conviction.

Investigators also documented accounts from relatives and the children about threats that allegedly preceded the shooting. Jeri Mains’ brother told police that she had discussed physical abuse and that she had made Cecil Mains leave the home after discovering that he had been unfaithful. According to the affidavit, he then stayed with his brother. One of the children also told investigators about hearing an earlier threat by Cecil Mains against family members. The protective-order petition reportedly included allegations that he had threatened the children and the family’s pets, although those claims were not separately adjudicated as part of the guilty plea.

Another confrontation occurred shortly before Christmas. Reporting based on the petition said Jeri Mains met her husband in a court parking lot after telling him she intended to seek a divorce. She said she recorded a conversation in which Cecil Mains threatened to kill himself in front of her and the children. Police were also called to the family home on Christmas Day during a domestic disturbance, WRTV reported. Court documents cited by the station said officers directed Cecil Mains to return a handgun to Jeri Mains and provide a key to a gun safe.

Three days later, the dispute turned fatal. Prosecutors and police said Cecil Mains used a handgun from the home and shot his wife while the children were present. Afterward, he left in a gray Toyota Tundra. Police located the vehicle and arrested him during a traffic stop. WRTV reported that investigators recovered a .380-caliber handgun from the truck and that evidence associated with the weapon was compared with ammunition recovered from the shooting scene. When detectives attempted to question Mains after his arrest, he asked for an attorney.

The guilty plea shifted the final court proceeding away from determining who committed the killing and toward punishment. By admitting to murder Aug. 26, Mains resolved the central criminal charge before trial. His October sentence placed him in state prison for 45 years, followed by five years on probation. The court also restricted contact with the children, according to court minutes reported by Law&Crime. Those records state that protected people may petition after reaching adulthood to have no-contact restrictions lifted, leaving any future change to a court rather than to Mains.

The case ended in court with a conviction and lengthy sentence, but the filing that preceded the killing remains an important part of the documented timeline. Jeri Mains sought judicial protection on Dec. 25, 2025; she was fatally shot Dec. 28 before the petition had been reviewed. The murder prosecution is now complete, and Cecil Mains is serving the prison portion of his sentence while the no-contact provisions and eventual probation remain part of the judgment.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.