Chisholm’s Comeback: Will This Yankees Star Become Their New Go-To Third Baseman?

Somerset, New Jersey – Jazz Chisholm Jr. returned to the field Tuesday, beginning a rehabilitation stint with Double-A Somerset after nursing a right oblique strain that sidelined him for nearly a month. The former All-Star infielder, known for his switch-hitting ability, took the field at third base and played five innings, having four chances at the plate before being lifted for a planned substitution.

The transition to third base has raised some eyebrows, particularly since manager Aaron Boone indicated the team is considering this as Chisholm’s new primary position upon his return. Chisholm himself affirmed this possibility, stating, “That’s what I’ve heard so far,” when asked about his role. He expressed his willingness to embrace the change for the sake of the team’s success, saying, “I’m here to win a ring. I’m not here to fight over positions.”

Previously, Chisholm primarily played second base this season, starting 29 games at the position. His absence coincided with DJ LeMahieu being on the injured list, which led Oswaldo Cabrera to take over third base duties. However, recent developments saw LeMahieu come back to second, while Cabrera unfortunately suffered a severe ankle injury that is likely to end his season. Consequently, Oswald Peraza and Jorbit Vivas have filled the gap at third, though neither has delivered substantial offensive contributions.

Before his injury, Chisholm’s batting average was .181, but he had managed to hit seven home runs and maintain a solid walk rate of 12%. With LeMahieu struggling to produce at the plate this season and currently batting .184/.244/.263, the Yankees might see Chisholm as a strong upgrade when he returns to the lineup.

This shift in Chisholm’s position is not new; he has previously played third base for the Yankees after last year’s trade, moving from second to accommodate Gleyber Torres. Although he faced challenges, committing seven errors in over 400 innings, Statcast recognized him for making significant defensive contributions.

Chisholm’s return could influence the Yankees’ strategies leading into the trade deadline. If LeMahieu does not improve, management may consider seeking additional infield help. Chisholm could revert to second base if a new third baseman joins the team, but the club might also look to upgrade directly at the second base position.

With mid-season adjustments in mind, potential trade candidates such as Brandon Lowe, Luis Urías, and former Yankee Thairo Estrada are circulating talks as options to bolster the infield. The Yankees front office faces decisions that could significantly reshape their roster as they aim to compete for a title in the upcoming months.