Police say the 47-year-old suspect picked a 70-year-old stranger after deciding the shopper looked connected to the 1960s.
PUNTA GORDA, Fla. — A 47-year-old Florida man is accused of attacking a 70-year-old stranger with a box cutter inside a Publix supermarket after telling police he had gone into the store intending to kill someone and selected the shopper at random, according to an arrest affidavit and local reports.
The Oct. 10 encounter at the Publix on Tamiami Trail began as an ordinary shopping trip for the older man and ended with police detaining Ramsey Thomas Lyons near the front of the store. Authorities say the victim was standing in an aisle shortly before 4 p.m. when he suddenly felt what seemed like a punch on the left side of his face. When he turned, he saw Lyons staring at him while holding a box cutter, the affidavit said. The victim then noticed blood on his hands and moved toward the customer service area to get help.
Investigators said store surveillance video helped establish the sequence. According to WWSB, the footage showed Lyons entering the Publix, walking through aisles and leaving the same aisle shortly after the victim ran toward the front of the store. Officers responding to a reported stabbing found Lyons near the entrance with his hands on his head and detained him. Police also recovered a box cutter from an aisle. The affidavit does not describe any prior interaction between the two men, and police said Lyons later told them he did not know the victim.
The victim was taken for medical treatment in Port Charlotte. Police described a cut that ran from the left cheek near the mouth down the jawline and toward the neck, along with a smaller injury to the upper chest. He received multiple stitches. News reports based on the affidavit placed the main wound at roughly four to six inches. Authorities did not report a life-threatening injury, and later coverage did not provide a detailed public update on his recovery. The man’s age, however, is significant to the criminal charge because Florida law gives added penalties when certain assaults or batteries involve a person 65 or older.
After officers advised Lyons of his Miranda rights, he agreed to speak with investigators, according to the affidavit. Police say he told them he had an undiagnosed mental illness and disliked what he called the “1960s era.” The document says Lyons told an officer that he entered the store with the intent to murder someone and chose the 70-year-old shopper because he looked as though he was from the 1960s. When Lyons used the phrase “acing him out,” police said he clarified that he meant killing the man. The statements are allegations recorded by investigators and have not been tested at trial.
Police also said Lyons described thinking about attacking someone for two days before the incident. According to the affidavit, he said he pulled the box cutter from his pocket during the encounter. Investigators wrote that Lyons said he dropped the tool after the attack because he did not want responding officers to be frightened and use a Taser or shoot him. That account, if admitted in court, would be one part of the state’s evidence along with the surveillance video, the recovered box cutter, the victim’s account and the responding officers’ observations. Prosecutors still carry the burden of proving the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.
Lyons was charged with aggravated battery on a person 65 years of age or older. Under Florida Statute 784.08, a conviction for aggravated battery against someone in that age group is treated more seriously than the same underlying offense against a younger adult. The statute provides for reclassification to a first-degree felony and sets a three-year minimum prison term upon conviction, along with other sentencing consequences. Those penalties do not mean Lyons will receive a particular sentence; sentencing would depend on a conviction and the facts and rulings in the case. The age-based provision applies whether or not the accused knew or had reason to know that the person was 65 or older, according to the statute. That makes the victim’s documented age legally important independent of the motive police attributed to Lyons.
The Publix case also drew attention because Lyons had faced a separate battery case in 2025. Court records and later reporting said he was accused of punching a 16-year-old boy outside or near a Wawa in Port Charlotte after the teenager held a door. Lyons entered a mental health court diversion program in connection with that case. Fox News reported that his probation in the earlier matter was terminated in July 2026, a little more than three months before the Publix attack. The earlier allegation is separate from the current case and does not establish guilt in the new charge.
The teen’s mother, Shawna Gentry, later criticized how the earlier matter was handled. In an interview reported by Fox News, she said she had wanted prosecutors and the court to take a tougher approach and expressed concern after learning of the Publix accusation. Her criticism added a second question to the new case: not only what happened inside the supermarket, but whether the previous diversion process had addressed the risks that family members believed were present. The State Attorney’s Office for the 20th Judicial Circuit had not publicly answered those criticisms in the reports reviewed for this article.
Mental health court programs are designed to address criminal cases in which treatment and supervision may be appropriate, but participation in such a program does not establish that a defendant has any specific diagnosis. In the Publix affidavit, the reference to an “undiagnosed mental illness” came from Lyons himself during the police interview. The available reporting does not identify a clinical diagnosis tied to the Oct. 10 case, and it would be improper to treat his statement as a medical finding or as an explanation for the alleged conduct. The criminal case will instead turn on admissible evidence, the charged offense and any defenses raised in court.
The random nature of the alleged selection is central to the public account. Police said Lyons told them he had never met the victim and chose him because of how he appeared. No dispute, robbery attempt or other interaction was described in the affidavit before the attack. That distinguishes the incident from cases in which violence follows a confrontation and is one reason the account has drawn broad attention beyond Punta Gorda. At the same time, the stated motive comes from an accused person’s reported comments during a police interview, and authorities have not identified independent evidence showing what he was thinking before entering the store.
The case now turns from the police account to the court process, where prosecutors must prove the aggravated battery allegation and Lyons may challenge the state’s evidence. Oxygen reported that he pleaded not guilty, and earlier reports said he was being held without bond. Although a Nov. 16 court appearance had been scheduled, the sources reviewed as of Nov. 19 did not establish what occurred at that proceeding. No verdict has been reached, and the accusations in the arrest affidavit remain allegations unless proven in court.
Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more