Elderly Florida man allegedly kills girlfriend after she refuses $300k house payout

Police say a Tampa couple’s breakup had become entangled with a $300,000 property dispute before an argument inside a pickup truck turned deadly.

TAMPA, Fla. — A 74-year-old man is accused of fatally shooting his longtime girlfriend as the two argued over the end of their relationship and his claim that he should receive $300,000 connected to a house held in her name, according to police and a probable-cause affidavit.

Alan Barber was arrested Oct. 3 and charged with second-degree murder in the death of 74-year-old Barbara Susdorf. Tampa police publicly described the case as a fatal shooting that followed a disagreement beginning at a restaurant, while an affidavit later reported by Law&Crime provided a more detailed account of a relationship that had lasted more than 25 years and was apparently breaking apart. The affidavit attributes many of the details about the couple’s finances and argument to statements Barber allegedly made to investigators after his arrest.

The dispute over the house appears to have been one of the central points of conflict. According to the affidavit, Barber told investigators that he and Susdorf lived in a residence that was in her name. He allegedly claimed he had put about $300,000 toward the property and believed he was entitled to recover that money if their relationship ended. The available reports do not independently establish how much Barber contributed, what those payments represented or whether he had any legal ownership interest in the home. Those claims remain part of the account attributed to him.

Barber allegedly told investigators that he and Susdorf had recently been arguing and had repeatedly discussed ending their relationship. The affidavit described the desire to separate as mutual, but the financial consequences were unresolved. Barber said Susdorf would not agree to sell the home or pay him the amount he demanded, according to the reported affidavit. Investigators said he had threatened her over the dispute before the fatal encounter. Police have not released records showing that the couple had entered into any formal agreement concerning the property or the claimed $300,000.

The immediate confrontation began away from the house. Tampa police said Barber and Susdorf went to a local restaurant on Oct. 3 before leaving together in a white Chevrolet pickup truck. The department’s public statement did not describe the subject of the restaurant disagreement. The affidavit, however, said the pair argued after Susdorf would not give Barber a dollar for a lunch tip. What may have started as a small disagreement then returned to the much larger dispute over their relationship and the house as Barber drove and Susdorf sat in the passenger seat.

According to the affidavit, Barber continued demanding that Susdorf sell the house and give him $300,000. She rejected that demand and, in the affidavit’s account, told him she was not going to pay him anything. Investigators also wrote that Susdorf threw a cup at him during the argument. Barber allegedly threatened to shoot her as the dispute escalated. Those details come from the probable-cause account and should not be read as findings that have been established at trial.

The affidavit describes a firearm becoming part of the argument before the shooting. Barber allegedly handed Susdorf a holster containing his gun while they were inside the truck. At some point Susdorf took hold of the weapon, according to investigators. Barber then allegedly took it back, removed the gun from the holster and pointed it toward her. He later told investigators that he had “snapped,” according to the reported affidavit. Police say Susdorf was then fatally shot while she was sitting in the passenger seat.

Tampa police provided a more limited account of the shooting itself. The department said the argument escalated inside the pickup and that Barber shot the woman before stopping in the parking lot of a business in the 4100 block of East Fowler Avenue. Officers responding shortly before 11:30 a.m. secured the scene, recovered the firearm and impounded the truck as evidence. Law&Crime, citing the affidavit, reported that Barber had called 911 and said he had shot his girlfriend. Susdorf was found dead in the front passenger seat.

Barber was taken into custody without incident, police said. The department initially identified the victim only as a woman in her 70s who had known Barber for more than two decades. The affidavit obtained by Law&Crime identified her as Susdorf and described the two as a couple of more than 25 years. That distinction is important because the Tampa Police Department’s public release did not contain the detailed claims about the breakup, the title to the house, the $300,000 demand or the conversation inside the vehicle.

Acting Tampa Police Chief Brett Owen condemned the use of violence to settle the dispute. “Violence is not the answer to conflict, and there is never a disagreement that should end with the tragic loss of a life,” Owen said in the department’s statement. Police said a victim advocate would work with Susdorf’s family and loved ones and connect them with available resources. The department also said investigators recovered the firearm believed to have been used and retained the pickup as evidence.

The murder charge begins a criminal process in which prosecutors would have to prove the allegations against Barber beyond a reasonable doubt. The detailed narrative contained in a probable-cause affidavit serves a different purpose: It presents information authorities say supports an arrest or charge. It is not a verdict. Barber’s reported statements to police, including his description of the couple’s financial disagreement, likewise do not independently resolve who legally owned or was entitled to money connected to the property.

Several questions about the financial dispute remain unanswered in the publicly available material. No verified property documents reviewed for this report establish the home’s value, the history of payments on it or whether Barber’s claimed $300,000 represented mortgage payments, improvements, household expenses or some other contribution. There also is no publicly verified account from Susdorf explaining her position. The most detailed version of the disagreement comes from investigators’ account of what Barber allegedly told them after she was dead and unable to respond.

The case therefore rests on two related but distinct sets of information: Police confirm that Barber and Susdorf had known each other for decades, argued after leaving a restaurant and were together in the pickup when she was fatally shot; the probable-cause affidavit adds the allegation that the violence followed weeks or more of conflict over a breakup and Barber’s demand for money from a home titled to Susdorf. Barber was booked into the Orient Road Jail after his arrest. No later disposition of the murder case was identified in the sources reviewed for this report.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.