Ex-cop kills romantic rival then sets him on fire after love triangle turns deadly

A St. Lucie County judge imposed the sentence after jurors convicted Otto Lenke and voted 11-1 to recommend death.

FORT PIERCE, Fla. — A former Florida police officer and firefighter has been sentenced to death for the 2021 murder of motorcycle mechanic Richard Benson, closing the trial-court phase of a case in which prosecutors said jealousy led to a carefully planned attack inside Benson’s Fort Pierce business.

Circuit Judge Michael Linn imposed the death sentence on Otto Lenke, 67, on Oct. 14, months after a St. Lucie County jury found him guilty of first-degree murder with a firearm and first-degree arson. The same jury later voted 11-1 to recommend execution. In his sentencing order, Linn concluded that aggravating circumstances established by the state outweighed the mitigating evidence presented for Lenke and said the killing reflected extensive planning. The sentence does not mean an execution is imminent. Florida death sentences are subject to automatic review by the Florida Supreme Court, giving Lenke another stage in which to challenge his conviction and punishment.

The jury found three aggravating factors during the penalty phase. Jurors determined that the killing was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel; that it was committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner; and that it occurred during another felony, the arson. Under Florida law, jurors had to recommend death by at least an 8-4 vote before the judge could impose a death sentence. They exceeded that threshold with an 11-1 recommendation on May 21. Linn was not required to choose death solely because of that vote, but after conducting an independent review, he concluded that execution was the appropriate sentence. Lenke also received a prison term for his arson conviction.

The judge’s ruling focused heavily on what happened before Lenke entered Fast Frank’s Cycle Concepts on the morning of Feb. 17, 2021. Court records described Lenke removing the license tag from a vehicle and driving about 40 minutes to the Fort Pierce business. He parked away from the storefront and waited about 20 minutes. Lenke then put on gloves and a motorcycle helmet with a tinted shield. He carried a handgun and a bag containing two containers of denatured alcohol and lighters as he approached the shop. Those preparations became central to the state’s argument that the killing was not an impulsive confrontation but the result of advance planning.

Benson, 57, had arrived to open the motorcycle business and was working near the front when Lenke entered from the rear, according to the sentencing record and evidence presented at trial. Surveillance video captured the confrontation. The record said Lenke shot Benson three times and repeatedly prevented the wounded man from reaching the front entrance. Lenke then poured the flammable liquid over Benson and started a fire before leaving. Emergency crews responding to the burning business found Benson inside, and he was pronounced dead at 9:21 a.m. Investigators recovered three spent cartridge casings and two empty containers near the front of the shop. The circumstances of Benson’s death were described in court in restrained but stark terms during both the guilt and penalty phases.

Prosecutors identified jealousy as the motive. Benson was dating a woman who had known Lenke for years and had previously had a romantic relationship with him, according to court records. The earlier relationship had ended before Benson’s death. The sentencing order described a January 2021 encounter in which Lenke delivered a boat he had built for the woman. Benson called her during that visit, and Lenke saw Benson’s name on her phone. Records said Lenke became emotional and questioned why she did not love him and whether she was seeing someone else. Prosecutors used that history to explain why Benson became Lenke’s target, while the physical evidence and surveillance footage were used to establish how the attack was carried out.

The investigation moved from the shop’s security system to people who knew the men. Benson’s girlfriend told investigators she recognized the person shown in the footage despite the helmet and covered face. She pointed to what she described as Lenke’s distinctive walk and the style of his black motorcycle helmet. Detectives also examined video showing a Pontiac Bonneville traveling toward the area and parking near the shop without a visible license tag. The vehicle was registered to Lenke and was primarily used by his daughter, according to court records. Investigators ultimately connected those observations with other evidence gathered after the fire, building a circumstantial case around footage that recorded the homicide but did not provide a clear view of the attacker’s face.

Search warrants added another layer. Evidence showed Lenke’s cellphone remained at his residence when the murder occurred, according to the sentencing record. Investigators later tracked activity associated with Lenke to his hobby shop, a canal and an area along the Indian River Lagoon near Sebastian. Authorities recovered part of a Glock firearm from the lagoon area that was consistent with the weapon used in Benson’s killing. Available records did not establish who had originally purchased the firearm secondhand, but prosecutors presented the recovered gun component along with the vehicle evidence, surveillance video and witness identification as part of the broader case against Lenke.

Lenke’s background made the prosecution notable beyond the facts of the killing. Public records and local reporting show that he served with the Melbourne Police Department from December 1980 until December 1995, when he medically retired. He later worked for Indian River County Fire Rescue for about 16 years before leaving in 2016. Assistant State Attorney Brandon White argued publicly after sentencing that Lenke’s law-enforcement experience helped him understand investigative methods and informed his preparations. The prosecution pointed to the removed license plate, concealed clothing and other steps as evidence of an effort to avoid identification. The judge’s order ultimately rested on the evidence of planning and the circumstances of the homicide rather than Lenke’s former occupations alone.

The case took more than five years to reach its final trial-court judgment. Lenke was arrested shortly after Benson’s death in February 2021 and was held without bond while the case moved through court. His jury trial began in May 2026. Prosecutors showed jurors the shop’s surveillance recording and presented evidence linking Lenke to the scene and events surrounding the homicide. The jury convicted him on May 8 of both first-degree murder and arson. A separate penalty proceeding followed, allowing prosecutors to present aggravating circumstances and the defense to offer mitigating evidence before jurors decided whether to recommend life without parole or death.

Benson’s death also left a lasting mark on people who knew him through the motorcycle shop. In reporting after the 2021 homicide, friends described him as a generous mechanic who sometimes helped customers who could not afford extensive repair bills. His business was in the 800 block of South Third Street, near the Fort Pierce Police Department. That proximity became part of the case’s unusual setting: a killing captured by cameras inside a longtime local business and carried out only a short distance from law enforcement offices. Benson’s relatives later appeared remotely during court proceedings connected with Lenke’s sentence, according to local reporting.

Lenke’s case now moves out of the St. Lucie County trial court and into Florida’s appellate process. The Florida Supreme Court must review a death sentence, including the conviction and the legal basis for the punishment. No execution date has been set. The automatic review means Linn’s Oct. 14 order is a major legal milestone but not the final proceeding in the case. Unless the conviction or sentence is disturbed on appeal, Lenke will remain under a death sentence for Benson’s murder while the required review continues.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.