Police say witness evidence, an audio recording and a homicide ruling preceded the 2026 arrest of former caregiver Jimmy Alexis.
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — More than three years after 26-year-old Jason Similien died following an overnight shift at a Fort Lauderdale group home, police arrested a former employee they say repeatedly choked the disabled resident until he lost consciousness, including after Similien got out of bed looking for a cookie.
Jimmy Bertram Alexis, 43, was arrested Oct. 6, 2026, on a charge of aggravated manslaughter of a disabled adult in connection with Similien’s June 30, 2023, death at Genuine Love and Care Group Home. The arrest followed a lengthy investigation in which another employee told detectives she witnessed two choking incidents, recorded audio during one of them and later participated in a controlled phone call with Alexis. A medical examiner had ruled Similien’s death a homicide in November 2023. Alexis has denied the allegations, and the criminal charge has not been proven in court.
The case began as an emergency response early on June 30, 2023. Police said rescue crews were called after Similien was found unresponsive at the facility. He was taken to a hospital and pronounced dead at 7:42 a.m. Investigators initially had to sort through competing explanations for what happened during the night. Facility representatives told police that Similien had autism and experienced anxiety and psychosis, and that he was known to engage in self-injurious behavior, including banging his head on surfaces. Alexis acknowledged physically restraining Similien but told officers he had not choked him.
That account came under greater scrutiny after officers spoke with another employee who had been working at the home. Police records described the woman as visibly shaken when investigators first encountered her. Authorities said she later waited outside and asked to speak with officers away from the facility. She told investigators that she had seen Alexis choke Similien until he became unconscious. According to police, she said she warned Alexis during an earlier encounter that he was hurting the resident and told him to stop. She then described a second incident later in the same shift.
Investigators said the first confrontation occurred around 1 a.m., when Similien was awake and moving through the home. According to the witness account cited in the arrest documents, Alexis told him to return to bed. When Similien did not comply, the employee said Alexis put an arm around his neck while Similien was sitting on a blue foam mat. The witness said Similien eventually lost consciousness. That allegation differed sharply from Alexis’ description of his actions. He told investigators that he sometimes had to restrain Similien because the resident moved around the home and could make noises that disturbed other residents.
About two hours later, according to the witness, Similien regained consciousness and went to a snack closet looking for a cookie. Police said the employee described Alexis as becoming frustrated. She alleged that Alexis again placed Similien in a hold around the neck and continued until the resident lost consciousness. The witness said she recorded audio during that encounter because she had already objected to what she saw earlier. Investigators who reviewed the recording said Similien could be heard moaning. Authorities have not publicly released the full recording, and its contents beyond what investigators described have not been independently verified.
Alexis gave police a different account of the physical contact. According to the arrest affidavit, he said he used what he called “vertical immobilization” four or five times during the overnight shift. He said Similien was making noises that could disrupt other residents and maintained that his actions were restraint rather than choking. Alexis also told investigators that Similien went to bed on his own around 5 a.m. and appeared to fall asleep. He said that when he tried to wake Similien at about 6:45 a.m., the resident did not respond. Those statements became part of the evidence examined during the death investigation.
Police also arranged a controlled telephone call between the witness and Alexis. Investigators said Alexis discussed what he planned to tell police and encouraged the other employee to give a similar account in her own words. According to the arrest record, he also told her not to discuss the facility’s logbook or the mat on which Similien had been lying, and cautioned against saying too much that could lead officers to ask additional questions. Those statements are allegations summarized by police in court records and have not yet been tested at trial.
The medical examiner’s homicide ruling came months after Similien’s death, but an arrest did not immediately follow. Local reporting said Fort Lauderdale police continued working with the Broward State Attorney’s Office before obtaining the warrant that led to Alexis’ arrest in October 2026. Police said the department’s Fugitive Unit located him. The more than three-year interval between the death and arrest became an issue almost immediately in court. An attorney representing Alexis questioned why authorities were bringing the case so long after the 2023 death and said the allegations appeared to have emerged unexpectedly. Alexis’ defense has said he denies wrongdoing.
Similien’s family is also pursuing a separate civil case concerning his care. Attorney Adam Finkel, who represents the family, described Similien as a kind and caring young man and said relatives believe the death followed failures at a facility that was supposed to understand and respond safely to his needs. Finkel has said other employees previously raised concerns about Alexis’ conduct and that he was not fired in response to those complaints. Those assertions are part of the family’s position and are separate from the criminal allegations. NBC 6 reported that it sought comment from representatives of the facility and their attorneys but had not received a response at the time of its report.
The arrest documents place the alleged overnight encounters at the center of the prosecution, but important questions remain unresolved publicly. The medical examiner classified the death as a homicide, while the specific cause was redacted from the arrest form described by Local 10. The witness account and recording support the police theory of the case, while Alexis has disputed that he choked Similien and characterized his actions as restraint. Prosecutors will have to establish the elements of the aggravated manslaughter charge in court, and Alexis is entitled to contest the evidence and the witnesses against him.
The case now moves forward with a gap of more than three years between Similien’s death and Alexis’ arrest likely to remain part of the defense’s challenge to the prosecution. Alexis has posted bond and denies the allegations. Public reporting reviewed through Nov. 18 does not show that the aggravated manslaughter charge has reached a final resolution.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more