A Pinellas County judge imposed five years more than the minimum sentence after a jury rejected a first-degree murder charge.
CLEARWATER, Fla. — A Florida man convicted of killing his former girlfriend’s new partner after forcing his way into a Clearwater apartment has been sentenced to 30 years in prison, ending a murder case in which prosecutors asked for life and the defense urged the judge to weigh the defendant’s own history of violent loss.
Sixth Judicial Circuit Judge Philippe Matthey sentenced Stuart Beck, 25, on Oct. 9 for the July 2022 shooting death of 20-year-old Michael Conrad. A Pinellas County jury convicted Beck of second-degree murder in July after prosecutors tried him on a first-degree murder charge. The jury’s decision meant it did not find the state had proved the premeditation required for first-degree murder. Matthey said at sentencing that he considered that distinction important. He also said state law required a prison term of at least 25 years in the case. Prosecutors and members of Conrad’s family wanted Beck imprisoned for life, while Beck’s lawyers presented evidence they said supported leniency.
The sentencing hearing brought the consequences of the case into sharper focus than the legal arguments that had dominated Beck’s weeklong trial. Members of Conrad’s family described the lasting absence created by his death. His aunt Ashley Anderson said that reading her victim-impact statement was the second-hardest thing she had endured after burying her 20-year-old nephew. Another aunt, Jessica Robertson, said she was speaking in part for Conrad’s father, Michael Conrad Sr., who was too distraught to attend. Robertson told the court that the family had lost more than a relative when Conrad died, saying Beck had taken away the laughter and ordinary moments that once filled their home.
Beck’s family asked the judge to consider a different tragedy that had shaped his life. When Beck was 15, his father was shot and killed in front of him, according to reporting on the sentencing hearing. Beck called 911 after witnessing the killing and later testified at the trial of the person accused of killing his father. His mother, Suzanne Beck, told Matthey that her son was loved by his family and that his father’s death changed him. A family friend, Dale Ward, also asked for leniency and described Beck’s actions in Conrad’s death as far outside the character of the young man he had known for years.
Matthey said the killing of Beck’s father was an unusually serious event in Beck’s life and that he considered it when choosing a sentence. But the judge also made clear that the earlier trauma did not excuse the conduct that led to Conrad’s death. Matthey said nothing the court could do would restore Conrad to his family and expressed hope that Beck had come to understand the scale of the loss during roughly four years spent in jail awaiting the outcome of the case. In announcing 30 years, the judge said he had tried to determine a fair punishment while respecting the jury’s decision to convict Beck of second-degree rather than first-degree murder.
The case began shortly after 2 a.m. on July 6, 2022, at the Bay Cove Apartments on U.S. Highway 19 North in Clearwater. Police said Beck broke down the apartment’s front door before the confrontation that ended with Conrad being shot. Conrad was taken to Morton Plant Hospital, where he died. Investigators identified Beck as the suspect and arrested him the following day in Pasco County. He was initially charged with first-degree murder. At the time, Clearwater police said Beck and Conrad had both been involved with the same woman, although investigators did not publicly establish a motive in their first statements about the killing.
At trial, the relationship history became central to the competing accounts of what happened. The woman, Kaitlyn Nash-Koehler, testified that she and Beck had ended their relationship months before the shooting, although Beck’s name remained on the apartment lease. She had begun seeing Conrad but continued to spend some time with Beck. Prosecutors said Beck knew Conrad was inside before he entered. Nash-Koehler testified that Beck had called her and indicated he knew Conrad was there after seeing Conrad’s truck outside. Beck disputed that he knew Conrad was in the apartment when he arrived. The disagreement became important because prosecutors portrayed Beck’s arrival as the beginning of an armed confrontation he chose to create.
Beck did not deny firing the shot that killed Conrad, but his explanation changed over the course of the case. Earlier accounts characterized the shooting as accidental. When Beck testified before the jury, however, he said he had meant for the gun to fire but had not intended to kill Conrad. He said a struggle developed over the firearm and that he feared Conrad would gain control of it. Beck testified that he believed firing was necessary to protect himself. His lawyers also argued that he previously had been attacked by Conrad and two other men, a circumstance the defense used to support Beck’s claim that he feared for his life during the final confrontation.
Prosecutors asked jurors to examine Beck’s actions before the physical struggle rather than viewing the shooting as an isolated instant. They emphasized evidence that he forced his way through the door while armed and confronted an unarmed Conrad. The state argued that a person who created those circumstances could not transform the encounter into lawful self-defense merely because a struggle followed. Before trial, Matthey had also rejected Beck’s request for immunity under Florida’s self-defense law. A Florida Bar summary of Tampa Bay Times reporting said the judge found Beck had moved out months earlier and did not have a legal right to force his way into the apartment even though his name remained on the lease.
The defense offered jurors a different legal conclusion. Attorney Scott Tremblay described the shooting as a heat-of-passion case arising from a tangled relationship and argued that the facts supported manslaughter at most. The prosecution sought a first-degree murder conviction, which required proving a premeditated killing. After less than two hours of deliberations, however, jurors settled on second-degree murder. Their verdict rejected both ends of the courtroom dispute: They did not accept the defense position that the shooting should be treated as self-defense or manslaughter, but they also declined to find the premeditation necessary for the state’s first-degree murder charge.
Prosecutors returned to Beck’s conduct after the shooting when arguing for a life sentence. Assistant State Attorney Nash Licona acknowledged that Beck’s experience of watching his own father die was difficult to ignore. But Licona said Beck had nevertheless caused another family to endure a comparable loss. The prosecutor pointed to evidence that Beck did not call 911 after Conrad was shot and instead left the scene. Licona told the judge that Beck carried the gun into the woods and hid it. Reporting on an earlier self-defense hearing also said Beck took an Uber to Brooksville after the shooting. Prosecutors viewed those actions as evidence weighing heavily against leniency.
Defense attorneys countered that Beck’s history, age and emotional state deserved consideration even though the jury had found him criminally responsible. Defense attorney Keith Hammond acknowledged that both families had experienced profound tragedy and argued that Beck had not been equipped to make rational decisions during the confrontation. Matthey did not adopt that argument as an excuse, but the sentence he chose stopped well short of the life term requested by prosecutors and Conrad’s relatives. It was also longer than the 25-year minimum the judge said he was required to impose, placing Beck’s punishment between the two positions presented most forcefully at the hearing.
More than four years separated the shooting from the sentence. In that time, the case moved from an initial first-degree murder arrest, through a rejected self-defense immunity claim, a jury trial and a lesser murder conviction, and finally to the punishment hearing. Conrad’s relatives left court after hearing the 30-year term. Beck’s family wept quietly as the sentence was announced. Public corrections information later listed Beck in Florida state custody for the second-degree murder conviction. The sentence closes the trial-level punishment phase of a case that began with a predawn apartment confrontation and ended with a judge trying to measure a penalty for a loss that both families told the court would continue far beyond the hearing.
Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more