Florida man kills fiancee’s ex after child custody fight erupts at middle school student awards ceremony

Jurors rejected Roderick Kelvin Watson Jr.’s self-defense claim in the 2024 killing of Joseph James Juarez Coles.

OCALA, Fla. — A Florida man was sentenced to life in prison after a Marion County jury convicted him of premeditated first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of his fiancée’s former partner outside a middle school where families had gathered for a student awards ceremony.

Roderick Kelvin Watson Jr., 36, was convicted Oct. 8 in the May 22, 2024, killing of 32-year-old Joseph James Juarez Coles outside North Marion Middle School in Citra. Circuit Judge Barbara Kissner-Kwatkosky imposed the life sentence after the verdict. The decision ended a trial centered on a sharply disputed question: whether Watson opened fire because he reasonably feared for his life, as the defense argued, or deliberately killed an unarmed man who was trying to leave the confrontation, as prosecutors maintained.

The shooting followed a disagreement involving Coles and the mother of his children over where the children would go after the school’s awards program. Authorities said Watson, who was engaged to the woman, intervened in the dispute. Investigators and witnesses described the conflict as unfolding in a parking lot while students, parents and school employees were at the campus for the end-of-year event. What began as a family disagreement ended with Coles mortally wounded and Watson remaining at the school until deputies arrived.

Witness accounts became central to the prosecution’s case. The Fifth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office said witnesses reported that Coles turned to walk away when Watson intervened. Watson then shot Coles multiple times, prosecutors said. After Coles fell, witnesses said Watson struck him repeatedly and kicked him before walking away. Early investigators also reported recovering six spent 9 mm cartridge cases from the parking lot and a handgun from Watson’s vehicle. Coles was taken to a hospital and pronounced dead.

Watson never disputed that he fired the shots. His defense instead focused on why he did so. Watson told law enforcement that he acted in self-defense and later testified at his trial. On the witness stand, he said he believed Coles presented a threat and told jurors that he fired because he wanted to live. Watson said he had been told Coles was a boxer, and the defense argued that the circumstances gave him reason to fear that the confrontation could turn deadly.

Prosecutors presented the same encounter very differently. Assistant State Attorney Toby Hunt argued that Coles was unarmed and that Watson chose to arm himself and enter a dispute even though he did not need to do so. According to trial reporting, Hunt told jurors that Watson became the aggressor and continued firing as Coles attempted to get away. Prosecutors relied on eyewitness testimony, physical evidence collected at the school and Watson’s actions before and after the shooting to argue that the killing was intentional rather than a legally justified use of force.

Defense attorney Julia Williamson urged jurors to view the encounter from Watson’s perspective at the moment he acted. The defense maintained that Watson intervened because he believed others needed protection and that his fear of Coles was reasonable. Williamson also pointed to Watson’s conduct after the shooting, including the fact that he did not flee the school. Deputies found him nearby, and early reports said he identified himself as the person who had fired the gun and surrendered without resistance.

The jury was not persuaded by the self-defense argument. After receiving final instructions on Oct. 8, the 12 jurors began deliberating in the afternoon. Trial reporting said they notified court personnel less than two hours later that they had reached a decision. The guilty verdict for premeditated first-degree murder was read in court shortly after 5 p.m., and Watson was taken into custody following the finding. Kissner-Kwatkosky then imposed the life sentence.

The conviction marked a significant change from the charge Watson faced immediately after the killing. Marion County sheriff’s detectives initially arrested him on a second-degree murder charge. A grand jury later returned an indictment charging first-degree murder in June 2024, moving the case into a category that exposed Watson to the most severe penalties available for homicide under Florida law. The case proceeded for more than two years before reaching a jury in October 2026.

The location of the shooting remained a major part of how local authorities described the crime. State Attorney Bill Gladson said a school campus should be a place for children to learn and celebrate their achievements, not a setting for deadly violence. He said Watson’s actions took a man’s life while exposing students, relatives and school employees to violence during what was supposed to be a ceremonial event. Sheriff Billy Woods expressed similar concern after the 2024 arrest, emphasizing that students were on campus to be recognized for their accomplishments. Authorities said no students were physically injured in the shooting.

Coles’ death also left four children without their father, according to relatives and an obituary cited in reporting about the case. Family members described him as a devoted father and publicly called for justice after the shooting. The family said some of the children were present during the incident, adding another consequence to a confrontation that authorities said stemmed from a disagreement over the children’s plans following the school event.

The case also illustrated how the initial account of a shooting can change as investigators, prosecutors and jurors evaluate the evidence. Watson was first booked on a second-degree murder charge and said from the outset that he acted to defend himself. Investigators said witness statements did not support that account. A grand jury later authorized a first-degree murder prosecution, and at trial Watson personally explained his fear to jurors. Their verdict represented a rejection of that justification and a finding that the killing was premeditated.

The verdict leaves little unresolved at the trial-court level: jurors found that Watson deliberately killed Coles and rejected the claim that the gunfire was a lawful response to an immediate threat. The life sentence imposed after that finding closes the central criminal proceeding while fixing the case’s legal outcome around premeditation, not self-defense.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.