Cynthia Denise Dear faces three aggravated battery charges after a friend was injured during an Oct. 11 confrontation in Decatur.
DECATUR, Ill. — A brief comment between friends about a piece of fuzz in one woman’s hair turned into a violent confrontation in which the other woman was struck, sprayed with pepper spray and stabbed in the chest, according to police and court records cited by local news organizations. Cynthia Denise Dear, 44, was arrested after the Oct. 11 incident and charged with three felony counts of aggravated battery.
The charges describe three different aspects of the same alleged attack: prosecutors accuse Dear of using a deadly weapon, causing great bodily harm and committing aggravated battery in a public place. The confrontation happened near Pearl and Illinois streets in Decatur, according to court documents reported by WCIA and Decatur Radio. Dear appeared in court Oct. 13, where she was arraigned and denied pretrial release. The accusations remain allegations, and the available reporting does not establish that Dear has been convicted of any crime in connection with the incident.
Police said the encounter began with an ordinary observation. The victim, who was described in the records as Dear’s friend, told Dear that she had fuzz in her hair. A witness told investigators that the comment was not delivered as an insult or an attempt to provoke a fight. The victim likewise told officers that she had simply made the remark. According to the sworn police account reported by WCIA, however, Dear became upset and began yelling from a truck after hearing it.
The victim told police that Dear made a threatening statement during the argument, saying words to the effect that she would give the woman the “dirty south treatment.” Rather than continue the dispute, the victim began walking toward her mobile home, according to the police account. Investigators said Dear then got out of the truck and struck the woman before returning to the vehicle. The victim continued walking away, but police allege the confrontation did not end there.
As the woman moved away from the truck, Dear allegedly approached her again and sprayed pepper spray at the back of her head, according to investigators. Police said Dear then jumped onto the woman’s back. During the struggle, the victim told officers that she saw Dear holding a can of pepper spray and a silver knife with a black handle. The victim managed to force Dear off her back and then got on top of her, holding Dear’s hands down because she was concerned about the knife, the police account says.
Only after gaining control of the struggle did the victim realize she had been stabbed, investigators said. A witness noticed blood on the woman’s upper chest and went to a nearby Burger King for help. When police arrived, an officer documented a fresh injury on the victim’s left upper chest. Paramedics took her from the restaurant area to Decatur Memorial Hospital, where the wound was closed with stitches. Decatur Radio reported that the injury was not considered life-threatening.
The account is significant because the stabbing was not described by investigators as a single sudden act at the start of the disagreement. Police instead outlined a sequence in which the victim tried to leave, was allegedly hit, continued walking, was then sprayed with pepper spray and became involved in another physical struggle. That sequence appears in the sworn police statement cited by WCIA and provides the basis for the allegations now before the court. Whether prosecutors can prove those allegations remains a matter for the judicial process.
Police later located Dear sitting in the truck on Pearl Street, according to the local report. Investigators said they found a knife with blood on it on the passenger-side floorboard. A can of pepper spray was found in a bag outside the truck, police said. Those items were described in the police account as evidence recovered after the confrontation. Publicly available reporting reviewed for this story does not establish whether laboratory testing was performed on the knife or whether any forensic results have been filed in court.
At Decatur Police Department headquarters, Dear asked for a lawyer and said she did not want to make a statement, according to the sworn account. Police said that before an officer left the interview room, Dear asked whether the injured woman was all right and then said words to the effect that she had not intended to stab her and that it had been a mistake. The statement was included in the police narrative reported by WCIA. No broader explanation from Dear or a defense attorney was included in the reports reviewed for this article.
The case produced three aggravated battery counts rather than three separate reported attacks. One count alleges the use of a deadly weapon. Another alleges that the victim suffered great bodily harm. The third concerns the allegation that the battery occurred in a public place. Decatur Radio reported that the charges were filed after the Sunday morning confrontation and that Dear made her first court appearance two days later. A judge ordered that she remain in custody rather than be released before trial.
The victim’s reported injuries were serious enough to require hospital treatment but were not described as life-threatening. That distinction is important because early accounts of violent incidents can sometimes leave the extent of an injury unclear. In this case, the local reporting specifically said the woman received stitches at Decatur Memorial Hospital. The reports reviewed did not disclose her name, and there was no later public medical update establishing complications or a longer hospitalization. Her identity is therefore being withheld here.
The unusual origin of the dispute has drawn attention, but the court case is focused on the alleged conduct that followed the remark rather than the remark itself. Investigators attributed the escalation to Dear after the friend commented on her hair, while the victim and a witness told police the statement was not meant to provoke her. The available records do not offer an independent explanation for why the comment allegedly caused such a strong reaction, and no motive beyond the reported argument has been established publicly.
Dear had been scheduled for a preliminary hearing on Oct. 28 after being denied pretrial release. That date has now passed. The publicly accessible reports reviewed for this article did not establish the outcome of that hearing or provide a verified later disposition of the case. As of the latest information that could be confirmed from the cited reporting, Dear was facing three felony aggravated battery charges stemming from the Oct. 11 confrontation and was presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more