Illinois woman shoots ex-boyfriend from 100 feet away

Tara Anderson said she meant only to fire a warning shot, but prosecutors argued the evidence showed a deliberate act of violence.

EDWARDSVILLE, Ill. — An Illinois woman convicted of killing her ex-boyfriend with a single shot fired through a wooden privacy fence has been sentenced to 55 years in prison, closing a criminal case in which jurors rejected her claim that she meant only to frighten him away. Circuit Judge Amy Maher imposed the sentence Oct. 6 on Tara A. Anderson for the 2023 killing of Phillip Armstrong in Granite City.

The sentence consists of 30 years for first-degree murder and an additional 25 years because Anderson used a firearm in the crime. Local court reporting said Anderson must serve the full sentence. A Madison County jury convicted her in May after a trial centered not on who fired the fatal shot, but on what Anderson intended when she pulled the trigger. Armstrong, 39, had gone to Anderson’s home at her request to retrieve a vehicle when the confrontation occurred. Prosecutors said he was about 100 feet away and in the roadway when Anderson fired the shot that passed through the fence and struck him.

The shooting happened on the evening of Sept. 24, 2023, in the 1400 block of Madison Avenue in Granite City. Police responding to the scene found Armstrong dead in the roadway. Investigators said one witness had been with Armstrong when Anderson came outside and began yelling at him. According to police accounts presented before trial, Anderson then went back toward her home. The witness heard one gunshot. Another witness told investigators that Anderson had emerged with a gun and had said she was going to kill Armstrong. Investigators later recovered a .45-caliber shell casing from Anderson’s porch and a handgun from her basement.

At trial, Assistant State’s Attorneys Morgan Hudson and Lauren Maricle presented evidence that Armstrong had been trying to load a vehicle onto a trailer when Anderson confronted him. He had come to the property because Anderson had asked him to pick up the vehicle, prosecutors said. Anderson then went back inside, returned with a .45-caliber handgun and fired toward him. The bullet traveled through the wooden fence before striking Armstrong. That sequence became central to the prosecution’s argument because Armstrong was not portrayed as someone unexpectedly approaching Anderson’s property. He was carrying out the task that had brought him there at Anderson’s request.

Anderson did not deny firing the shot. Her defense was that she intended it as a warning and wanted only to scare Armstrong away. She testified that she did not mean to hit him. Defense attorney David Fahrenkamp continued that argument at sentencing, telling the judge that Anderson had not intended to shoot Armstrong and seeking the lowest sentence he said was available, 45 years. But prosecutors argued that describing the shot as a warning did not fit the physical circumstances or the other evidence jurors heard, including testimony about Anderson’s statements before the shooting.

Hudson told jurors during closing arguments that Anderson had expressed a desire to see Armstrong dead on more than one occasion. Prosecutors said that only minutes before the shooting, Anderson told a person inside her home that she was going to kill him. Hudson characterized those statements as more than angry talk and argued that the shooting showed Anderson had acted on them. Madison County State’s Attorney Tom Haine later said the evidence showed Anderson was angry and armed when she fired into an area where she knew Armstrong was standing. The jury deliberated for a little more than three hours before finding Anderson guilty of first-degree murder on May 14.

The sentencing hearing shifted attention from the disputed meaning of the gunshot to its consequences for Armstrong’s family. His identical twin brother, Patrick Armstrong, submitted a victim-impact statement describing Phillip Armstrong as kind and loving. Armstrong’s daughter, who was 10 when her father died and 13 by the time of sentencing, also addressed the court. She described the loss as something that would follow her through future milestones and said the killing had permanently changed her life. Her statement underscored the three years that passed between the shooting and Anderson’s sentence, a period in which the criminal case moved from arrest and investigation to trial and punishment.

Prosecutors also urged Maher to consider Anderson’s prior record and history of conflict involving firearms. Hudson told the court that Anderson had two felony drug convictions as well as numerous battery charges and protection orders in her background. The prosecutor said Anderson previously fired a gun at Armstrong on another occasion and had also fired at a different former boyfriend. Those allegations were raised at sentencing as part of the prosecution’s argument for a lengthy prison term. Hudson asked the judge for more than 55 years, arguing that Anderson’s conduct showed a repeated willingness to turn to a firearm during angry confrontations.

Fahrenkamp asked for substantially less. He argued that even a 45-year sentence would leave Anderson an elderly woman if she lived long enough to complete it. He also told the court that she had experienced a difficult upbringing and said she suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder and other problems. The defense presented those circumstances as reasons for the judge not to extend the punishment beyond what Fahrenkamp described as the minimum available sentence. Before Maher announced the sentence, Anderson apologized, saying she had never intended for the events to unfold as they did and acknowledging that she had made bad choices.

Maher had already rejected a defense request for a new trial before turning to punishment. The 55-year term ultimately fell above the sentence sought by the defense but below the punishment requested by prosecutors. Thirty years were imposed for the murder conviction, followed by the mandatory firearm-related addition of 25 years reported by local media. The structure of the sentence means the gun used in the killing accounted for nearly half of Anderson’s total prison term. The punishment also resolved the central question left after the jury’s May verdict: how many years Anderson would receive for a killing in which the defense insisted the fatal shot was never meant to hit anyone.

The case began as a domestic shooting investigation. In September 2023, authorities initially described Anderson and Armstrong as being in a dating relationship and called the killing an isolated domestic incident. Anderson was arrested and faced murder and firearm-related allegations. By the time of trial nearly three years later, prosecutors had assembled witness statements, firearm evidence and testimony about the events before the shot. Jurors were asked to decide whether Anderson’s warning-shot explanation created reasonable doubt about murder. Their guilty verdict showed they concluded the prosecution had met its burden despite that defense.

Haine said after sentencing that no prison term could reverse the loss suffered by Armstrong’s family, but he said the 55-year sentence provided accountability for the killing. The prosecution also credited Granite City police and other investigators with building the case that ultimately went to the jury. With Maher’s denial of the new-trial motion and imposition of sentence, Anderson has now moved from a convicted defendant awaiting punishment to a prisoner serving a decades-long term. No later change to the sentence was identified in the reports reviewed for this article.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.