Indianapolis man allegedly hacked at stepdad with shovel then stabbed mom before stripping to underwear

Court records describe a neighbor’s attempt to intervene and growing family concern about David White’s behavior before the killings.

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — An Indianapolis man has been formally charged with two counts of murder after his 75-year-old mother and 80-year-old stepfather were killed at their north-side home, where police say a neighbor witnessed part of the attack and tried to stop it. David White, 38, also faces one count of attempted battery by means of a deadly weapon.

The charges followed an Oct. 11 confrontation at the home of Cynthia Pottle and Robert Pottle Jr. on Lakeshire Lane. Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department officers were sent to the area shortly after 12:20 p.m. after a 911 caller reported an attack in progress. Cynthia Pottle was found inside the house with fatal injuries and was pronounced dead at the scene. Robert Pottle was found outside with severe injuries and was taken to a hospital, where he died about an hour later. White, Cynthia Pottle’s son and Robert Pottle’s stepson, was taken into custody at the home. The charges are allegations, and the criminal case remains pending.

Investigators said the sequence unfolded in view of at least one neighbor, whose account became a major part of the probable-cause narrative. According to court records summarized by local news organizations, the witness heard an unusual sound outside and saw White striking Robert Pottle with a shovel. The witness ran toward the confrontation, causing White to retreat into the house. The neighbor then encountered Cynthia Pottle briefly and called 911. Police say White later emerged again with a shovel and a kitchen knife. The witness was able to gain control of the shovel, but investigators allege White continued attacking Robert Pottle with the knife before returning to the residence.

Officers arriving at the property found evidence both outside and inside the home, according to accounts of the court filings. A knife and shovel were recovered near Robert Pottle, along with an open container of bleach. Inside, investigators reported finding a small garden shovel and garden shears with what appeared to be blood on them near Cynthia Pottle. Authorities have not publicly established in court which object caused each injury, and the evidence described in the charging documents has not yet been tested at trial. The descriptions in the filings represent the prosecution’s account of the evidence gathered during the initial investigation.

Police found White inside the home after the attacks, according to the court records. Reports based on those records said he was in a bathroom, wet and wearing only his underwear when officers detained him. He was arrested without further violence. Detectives later tried to interview him, but authorities said he declined to discuss what had happened. According to police accounts, White claimed that his mother and stepfather had been keeping him at the house against his will. Public records cited by local media listed the Lakeshire Lane property as his residence. Investigators have not publicly described any independent evidence supporting his claim that he was being held there.

The investigation also turned to the family’s concerns before the deaths. White’s half-sister told detectives that relatives had become increasingly worried about his behavior in the preceding months, according to court records. Investigators were told that White had stopped taking prescribed medication and had not completed a mental health evaluation that had been ordered in a separate Hamilton County court matter. Police also said family members described increasing aggression toward Cynthia and Robert Pottle. Authorities reported that White believed, among other things, that he was being poisoned through a new heating and air-conditioning system installed at the home. Those assertions were attributed to White in court records and have not been established as factual.

The Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department had previous contact with White before the fatal incident. Department spokesperson Tommy Thompson said the agency’s Mobile Crisis Assistance Team had previously responded to the home regarding mental health concerns. The specialized team works with health professionals during situations involving people who may be experiencing a behavioral health crisis. Police did not initially provide a complete public timeline of every earlier response or detail what actions followed those contacts. The prior calls have become part of the background to the case, but authorities have not said that any specific diagnosis or mental health condition caused the killings. Criminal responsibility and mental competency are separate legal questions that would have to be addressed through the court process if raised.

One of the final communications recovered by investigators added another piece to the timeline. Court records described a text message Cynthia Pottle sent to her husband around noon on Oct. 11, asking him to return home because she was concerned about White. The message came shortly before the emergency call that brought police to the property. Investigators also learned that Cynthia Pottle had been seeking help because she no longer believed it was safe for White to remain at the residence, according to the records. Those details indicate that the family’s concerns had intensified before the deaths, although the available filings do not establish that anyone knew a fatal confrontation was imminent.

The deaths shook a neighborhood where the Pottles had lived for years. Neighbors described the couple warmly in interviews after the killings, while Indianapolis City-County Councilor Leroy Robinson issued condolences to their relatives and nearby residents. Robinson said the loss affected more than one household and called attention to the challenges families can face when trying to get help during serious behavioral health situations. Police initially described the episode as an isolated event and did not report an ongoing threat to the surrounding neighborhood. The witness who intervened was not reported killed or seriously injured, but prosecutors’ decision to include an attempted deadly-weapon battery charge indicates that authorities allege another person was placed at risk during the confrontation.

White was initially detained on preliminary murder allegations while detectives and prosecutors reviewed the evidence. The Marion County Prosecutor’s Office later filed two formal murder counts and the attempted battery count. He appeared for an initial hearing after the charges were filed and remained in the Marion County Jail without bond, according to court reporting. The filing of charges moves the case from the investigative stage into criminal proceedings, where prosecutors must prove the allegations and the defense may challenge witness accounts, physical evidence, statements and other parts of the state’s case. No conviction has occurred, and White is presumed innocent unless proved guilty in court.

The case is now centered on the court process rather than the preliminary arrest allegations that emerged immediately after the deaths. Reporting following White’s initial hearing identified Dec. 17 as his next scheduled court date. No trial result has been reported, and the allegations surrounding the deaths of Cynthia and Robert Pottle remain unproven. White continued to be held without bond as the murder case proceeded.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.