In Missouri, Kourtney Aumen entered the plea weeks before a scheduled murder trial and is set to be sentenced Dec. 21.
WARSAW, Mo. — A Missouri woman accused of taking part in the fatal abuse of 4-year-old Jessica Mast pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault, ending plans for a jury trial nearly six years after deputies found the child dead at her family’s rural Benton County home.
Kourtney Aumen entered the guilty pleas Oct. 5, according to court records and local news reports. Her trial had been scheduled to begin Oct. 26 after years of criminal proceedings that included questions over her competency and an unsuccessful attempt shortly before the plea to waive a jury trial. Aumen is scheduled to be sentenced at 1:30 p.m. Dec. 21. The plea represents one of the most significant developments in a case that has produced criminal proceedings against four adults since Jessica’s death on Dec. 20, 2020.
Authorities said the investigation began when a Benton County deputy responded to a report of a possible domestic disturbance at the Mast home. Deputies found Jessica dead inside. Investigators said she had suffered extensive physical abuse before her death, including being struck and repeatedly put into a cold farm pond. Her mother and a 2-year-old boy in the household also had been badly injured, while an infant was reported unharmed. Officials later removed the surviving children from the home.
Investigators focused early on Aumen and neighbor Ethan Mast, who authorities have said was not related to Jessica’s family despite sharing their surname. James Mast, Jessica’s father, told investigators that the two neighbors were responsible for violence against members of his household. He said the parents had been threatened if they tried to interfere. Those statements became part of a wider investigation into what Benton County Sheriff Eric Knox described publicly at the time as a “religious-type episode.” Authorities said beliefs about supposed demonic influence were invoked during the abuse.
The descriptions in court records and early law enforcement accounts portrayed violence directed at several members of the family rather than a single confrontation. Investigators said Jessica was beaten and taken outside to a pond during cold December weather. The younger boy and Mary Mast, Jessica’s mother, also suffered injuries. Law enforcement officials said Jessica was already dead when deputies reached the house in the early hours of Dec. 20. Investigators documented her injuries and interviewed the adults as they sought to determine who had participated in the abuse and what each person had done.
Aumen initially faced a broader and more serious set of accusations, including a first-degree murder charge and other felony counts. The case continued for years before the October guilty plea resolved the prosecution without a trial. In September, a judge found Aumen competent to proceed after competency questions had repeatedly affected the case. Her lawyers had raised concerns about communicating with her and had previously sought treatment through the Missouri Department of Mental Health. The competency ruling meant the prosecution could move toward the scheduled October trial.
Another procedural dispute followed. Aumen sought to waive a jury and have the case decided by a judge, but Webster County Circuit Judge M. Brandon Baker declined to accept the waiver, citing the seriousness of the charges. The case had been transferred from Benton County on a change of venue, and a five-day jury trial was scheduled. Days after the judge’s decision, however, the online court docket showed a change-of-plea proceeding, and Aumen admitted guilt to second-degree murder and first-degree assault. The plea eliminated the need for jurors to hear the evidence that prosecutors had been preparing to present.
Aumen’s plea also placed her case alongside guilty pleas entered by the other adults prosecuted after Jessica’s death, although the status and procedural history of those cases differ. Ethan Mast pleaded guilty in 2022 to second-degree murder and assault. Authorities had identified him as a neighbor involved in the abuse. Jessica’s mother, Mary Mast, later pleaded guilty to endangering the welfare of a child. Jessica’s father, James Mast, pleaded guilty in 2024 to second-degree murder and first-degree assault, but subsequent reporting showed that he sought to withdraw that plea and continued challenging it after a judge denied an earlier effort to do so.
The separate cases have generated occasional conflicting descriptions in secondary reports, making the court histories important to distinguish. Ethan Mast’s plea did not resolve the prosecutions of the other adults, and Aumen remained headed toward trial for years afterward. James Mast’s later efforts concerning his own plea also mean that his legal posture should not be treated as identical to Aumen’s. What is clear from the October court record is that Aumen herself pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault and now faces sentencing rather than trial.
The case drew intense attention in Benton County soon after Jessica’s death. Knox described the scene as unusually difficult for first responders and investigators. Community members later held a vigil for Jessica, and a local effort called “Jessica’s Bears” collected stuffed animals for first responders to give children they encountered on emergency calls. The public reaction reflected the severity of the allegations, but the criminal cases proceeded separately through the courts, with each defendant entitled to an individual determination of guilt and punishment.
The nearly six-year gap between Jessica’s death and Aumen’s plea was shaped in part by the ordinary complexity of a multiple-defendant homicide prosecution and by litigation specific to Aumen. Court records reported by local media show that questions about her mental competency surfaced more than once. She had previously been found competent, later faced another evaluation and was again found competent in September 2026. Defense attorneys said before that ruling that communication problems had complicated their trial preparation. Those issues remained distinct from the question of guilt that Aumen ultimately resolved by entering her pleas.
The guilty plea changes the focus of Aumen’s case from determining criminal responsibility at trial to deciding punishment. Second-degree murder and first-degree assault are serious felony offenses, but the precise sentence will be determined through the court process. Reports on the October plea did not establish what sentence the judge will impose, and a scheduled sentencing hearing should not be treated as a predetermined outcome. The hearing also gives the court an opportunity to consider the record relevant to sentencing under Missouri law.
For the Mast family case as a whole, legal proceedings have unfolded on different schedules since the arrests that followed Jessica’s death. The prosecution of Aumen, once positioned for an October jury trial, is now the clearest case headed toward a specific next milestone. Other defendants’ proceedings have included earlier pleas, sentencing questions and post-plea litigation. Those separate histories underscore why the October development concerns Aumen’s own criminal responsibility rather than a single resolution covering everyone investigated after the child’s death.
Aumen remained in custody after entering her pleas, according to local reporting. Unless the court schedule changes, her next major proceeding is sentencing on Dec. 21 in Benton County. Until then, the length and terms of her punishment remain for the judge to decide.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more