New York mon hid ex-girlfriend’s severed head after saying she played him for a fool

Damon Foy admitted to second-degree murder more than two years after Dale’s family asked authorities to find her.

KINGSTON, N.Y. — A New York man has pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the 2024 killing of his former girlfriend, Alberta Dale, closing the central question of criminal responsibility in a case that began as a family-requested welfare check and developed into a homicide investigation across several Ulster County communities.

Damon Foy, 50, of Kerhonkson entered the plea Oct. 7 in Ulster County Court before Judge Bryan E. Rounds, according to the Ulster County District Attorney’s Office. Prosecutors said Foy killed Dale, 44, of Pennsylvania, sometime between March 31 and April 1, 2024, after she had recently ended their relationship. Authorities said he dismembered her body and was disposing of her remains when investigators intervened. His sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 16, making the hearing the next major step in a case that has been pending for more than two years.

The guilty plea marks a substantial change from the case’s early stage, when Foy faced an eight-count indictment and prosecutors still had to prove their allegations at trial. The 2024 indictment included second-degree murder as well as charges involving concealment of a human corpse, criminal contempt, assault, obstruction of breathing or blood circulation, criminal mischief and weapons possession. By pleading guilty to murder, Foy formally admitted responsibility for Dale’s death rather than requiring prosecutors to present their homicide case to a jury. Law&Crime reported, citing prosecutors, that the plea agreement is expected to result in a sentence of 23 years to life in state prison.

The case began April 1, 2024, when Dale’s family members in Pennsylvania contacted authorities because they were worried about her. The Ulster County Sheriff’s Office conducted a welfare check at Foy’s residence and soon opened a formal missing-person investigation. Investigators knew Dale had recently been with Foy, and her vehicle was found at his property. Dale herself was not found during the initial visit. The search intensified the next day after a member of the public discovered property belonging to Dale along a road in the town of Wawarsing and turned it over to law enforcement.

That discovery helped move the investigation from a search for a missing person toward a possible homicide inquiry. Investigators returned to Foy’s residence, sought search warrants and began collecting evidence. A 2024 sheriff’s briefing said officers executing a warrant on April 3 found human remains later identified as Dale’s and that additional remains were subsequently located in the town of Marlboro. The district attorney’s 2026 plea announcement described Dale’s remains as having been ultimately located on April 2. The official accounts therefore differ by one day on when the remains were located, but both describe the discovery as occurring during the fast-moving investigation that followed her family’s request for help.

Later court records reviewed by Law&Crime offered a more detailed account of what investigators encountered inside Foy’s residence. According to that reporting, officers discovered a suitcase in a closet while looking for Dale. After investigators obtained authority to search it, they found some of Dale’s remains inside. The records described blood evidence and other material in the apartment. The reporting also said some portions of her remains were not found during that particular search. Authorities later said the investigation expanded beyond the apartment and that additional remains were recovered elsewhere. The details were central to the prosecution but are not necessary to describe graphically to establish what investigators found.

Court filings also described statements Foy made while officers were at the residence. Law&Crime reported that he told detectives, “I killed her,” and indicated that Dale was inside. During a later interview, according to the court records, Foy discussed the end of the relationship and complained that Dale had “play[ed] me like a fool” and “like a sucker.” Those statements reflected Foy’s account of his grievances; they do not lessen his responsibility for the killing he has now admitted. Prosecutors have characterized the case as an act of domestic violence following the end of an intimate relationship.

The relationship had already drawn law enforcement attention before Dale’s death. Court records cited in later reporting described earlier domestic violence involving Foy and Dale, including an incident involving a gun, and said a stay-away order of protection was in effect. Dale had also reportedly warned a crime victims unit that if she disappeared, Foy would be responsible for killing her. At the time of Foy’s 2024 arraignment, authorities said he had been out on bail in a prior domestic violence case. Those facts gave the murder prosecution a broader history than the evidence discovered during the missing-person investigation alone.

The investigation involved the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office, New York State Police and the Ulster County District Attorney’s Office, along with forensic investigators and the county medical examiner. Prosecutors said law enforcement worked for more than two years to prepare the case. Chief Assistant District Attorney Elizabeth Culmone-Mills, who was assigned to the matter from its beginning, credited Dale’s relatives with maintaining their trust in investigators and prosecutors while the case moved through court. She and Senior Assistant District Attorney Luba Reznikova of the Special Victims Bureau are listed by the district attorney’s office as the prosecutors handling the case.

District Attorney Emmanuel C. Nneji has repeatedly framed Dale’s killing as a domestic violence case rather than simply an unusually disturbing homicide. After the plea, he said the killing reflected a disregard for another person’s life and dignity and argued that domestic violence laws and procedures must provide meaningful protection to people facing targeted threats. His comments echoed remarks from the case’s 2024 prosecution, when officials also focused on the history between Dale and Foy and the protections that had been in place before her death.

Dale’s family has remained an important part of the prosecution’s handling of the case. Law&Crime reported that Culmone-Mills said the family supported the plea arrangement and that the prosecution would not have made its sentencing recommendation without that support. That decision avoided a murder trial, which would have required relatives and investigators to revisit the evidence in open court while leaving the ultimate punishment to be imposed by the judge within the terms allowed by law and the plea agreement.

Foy’s guilty plea does not end the proceeding entirely. The court must still impose sentence, and the Dec. 16 hearing is expected to be the first time the punishment resulting from his admission is formally entered. The district attorney’s office has set the hearing for 1:30 p.m. in Ulster County Court. Until then, the case remains before Rounds for sentencing, with the guilty plea establishing Foy’s criminal responsibility for Dale’s 2024 murder.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.