Ohio woman follows mom and 3-year-old son from grocery store before stabbing boy to death in shopping cart

The court rejected challenges involving the insanity defense, a prosecutor’s closing argument and the performance of Ellis’ trial attorneys.

CLEVELAND, Ohio — An Ohio appeals court has upheld the convictions of Bionca Ellis, who is serving life in prison without parole for killing 3-year-old Julian Wood and attacking his mother outside a North Olmsted grocery store, rejecting three arguments that sought to undo the 2025 jury verdict.

The Eighth District Court of Appeals affirmed Ellis’ convictions in an opinion released Oct. 8, 2026. The three-judge panel examined the central issue that had defined her trial: whether Ellis’ schizophrenia made her legally insane when she attacked Julian and his mother, Margot Wood, on June 3, 2024. Ellis’ lawyers argued on appeal that the jury received a distorted explanation of Ohio’s insanity standard, that prosecutors improperly framed a guilty verdict as the only way to hold her accountable and that her trial attorneys did not provide constitutionally effective representation. The appellate court rejected all three claims and left the judgment against her in place.

The appeal turned first on what Ohio law requires before a defendant may be found not guilty by reason of insanity. Under the standard cited by the appellate court, a defendant must show that, because of a severe mental disease or defect, the person did not know the wrongfulness of the acts at the time of the offense. The burden rests with the defendant. At Ellis’ trial, both sides agreed that she had schizophrenia, but their psychiatric experts reached different conclusions about whether the illness prevented her from understanding that her conduct was wrong. That distinction, rather than the identity of the attacker, was the principal dispute presented to jurors.

Defense psychiatrist Dr. Sara West testified that Ellis was experiencing symptoms associated with schizophrenia and that the illness caused her not to understand the wrongfulness of what she was doing. The state’s expert, Dr. Stephen Noffsinger, reached the opposite conclusion. He told jurors that Ellis had schizophrenia but that the illness did not cause her to lose an understanding of the wrongfulness of the attack. On appeal, Ellis argued that Noffsinger repeatedly suggested a narrower test — that a person would have to believe the conduct was right or justified to qualify as legally insane. The appellate judges found that characterization incomplete. They said Noffsinger repeatedly stated the statutory standard correctly while describing examples of how legal insanity can appear in practice.

The court also emphasized that the trial judge gave jurors the legal standard directly before deliberations. The judge instructed them that Ellis had to prove, by the greater weight of the evidence, that she had a severe mental disease or defect and that, because of it, she did not know the wrongfulness of her actions. The appeals court said jurors are presumed to follow a judge’s instructions. Because Ellis’ trial lawyers had not objected to Noffsinger’s testimony on the grounds later raised on appeal, the judges reviewed the issue for plain error, a demanding standard that requires an obvious error affecting substantial rights. They concluded no such error occurred.

A second appellate argument focused on the prosecution’s repeated use of the idea of accountability during closing arguments. Prosecutors told jurors that Ellis knew what she was doing and asked them to hold her accountable for what she had done to Julian and his mother. Ellis’ appellate lawyers argued that those statements could have left jurors with the false impression that a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict would allow Ellis to walk free. They contended the trial judge should have given a corrective instruction explaining that an insanity acquittal can lead to court-supervised commitment rather than immediate release. The appeals court disagreed, finding that the prosecutor never told jurors Ellis would be released if they accepted the insanity defense.

The judges noted that the trial court separately instructed jurors not to consider punishment when deciding guilt or innocence. The appellate panel concluded that the prosecutor’s accountability language was tied to the state’s argument that Ellis knew her conduct was wrong, not to a claim about what would happen to her after the verdict. Because the defense had not objected to those remarks or requested a corrective instruction at trial, that issue also was examined under the plain-error standard. The court found no basis for reversal and said the remarks did not create the kind of substantial prejudice required to disturb the verdict.

The third challenge accused Ellis’ trial lawyers of ineffective assistance. Her appellate attorneys argued that counsel should have objected to portions of Noffsinger’s testimony, challenged prosecutors’ statements about the insanity standard and accountability, and questioned prospective jurors more extensively about their attitudes toward mental illness. The appellate court did identify one imprecise statement by the prosecution: during closing argument, a prosecutor summarized Noffsinger as saying Ellis had to prove that she thought what she did was right. The court said that was not an accurate summary of his testimony. It nevertheless concluded that the lack of an objection did not amount to constitutionally ineffective representation because jurors had repeatedly heard the correct legal standard from the expert and the judge.

The court also refused to second-guess the defense’s approach to jury selection. The record showed that Ellis’ attorneys discussed depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and post-traumatic stress disorder with prospective jurors and asked how personal experiences with mental illness shaped their views. The appellate judges said decisions about the wording and extent of voir dire questions generally fall within trial strategy. To overturn a conviction for ineffective assistance, a defendant must show both deficient performance and a reasonable probability that the outcome would have been different without counsel’s errors. The panel concluded Ellis had not met that test.

The prosecution evidence described the events leading to the attack through surveillance video, witness testimony and police accounts. According to the appellate opinion, Ellis had been arrested for shoplifting at a North Olmsted Walmart on May 29, 2024, and was released two days later. On June 3, she returned to the North Olmsted Police Department asking about money she believed had not been returned after that arrest. After leaving the station, she went to a nearby Volunteers of America thrift store and took two knives without paying. She dropped one knife as she walked toward the neighboring Giant Eagle and entered the grocery store carrying the other.

Inside Giant Eagle, surveillance footage showed Ellis observe Margot Wood and her 3-year-old son. The mother and child left the store, with Julian seated in the child section of a shopping cart, and Ellis followed them into the parking lot. A witness testified that as Wood opened the rear of her vehicle, Ellis approached with the knife and attacked the child and his mother. Wood tried to protect and remove her son from the cart. Julian was taken to a hospital, where he died. His mother was also taken for treatment. A North Olmsted officer responding to the stabbing located Ellis walking toward Dover Center Road while still carrying a knife. She discarded it after the officer drew his weapon and ordered her to the ground, and she was taken into custody.

Ellis was initially found incompetent to stand trial after a court-ordered psychiatric evaluation in 2024 and was sent for inpatient competency restoration. In February 2025, the parties stipulated to a report finding her competency had been restored. That finding addressed whether she could understand the proceedings and assist in her defense; it did not decide the separate question of whether she was legally insane at the time of the attack. She later entered a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity. After a trial in October 2025, jurors found her guilty of aggravated murder, two murder counts, two attempted murder counts, two felonious assault counts, child endangering and misdemeanor theft. A tampering-with-evidence charge had been dismissed by the judge before deliberations.

Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge John Russo sentenced Ellis on Oct. 27, 2025, to an aggregate term of life in prison without the possibility of parole. The sentence followed the jury’s rejection of the insanity defense. Prosecutor Michael O’Malley called the killing one of the most heartbreaking acts of violence he had encountered and said the sentence was warranted. Ellis’ defense attorneys announced that they would appeal, leading to the arguments decided by the Eighth District nearly a year later.

The Oct. 8 appellate ruling leaves Ellis’ convictions and life-without-parole sentence in force. The court ordered the case returned to the trial court for execution of the sentence and said any bail pending appeal was terminated. The public records and reporting reviewed for this article did not show a later Ohio Supreme Court decision in the case as of Nov. 19, 2026.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.