Philadelphia Phillies catcher J.T. Realmuto was ejected from a spring training game against the Toronto Blue Jays on Tuesday, sparking confusion and controversy.

According to reports, Realmuto was ejected after a bizarre failed ball exchange with umpire Junior Valentine. In the fourth inning, Realmuto attempted to throw the ball back to pitcher Chase Anderson, but it slipped out of his hand and bounced on the ground before reaching Anderson. Valentine then appeared to signal that the ball had hit Realmuto’s equipment, prompting Realmuto to argue the call.

Realmuto later told reporters that he was “baffled” by the ejection, calling it a “soft way to get thrown out.” He maintained that he had not interfered with the play and that the ball had simply slipped out of his hand.

The incident has generated widespread attention and debate, with some observers questioning the umpire’s decision to eject Realmuto. Sporting News even went so far as to question whether there was any justification for the ejection at all.

The Phillies went on to lose the game 4-2, dropping their spring training record to 6-7. Despite the setback, Realmuto remains a key player for the team and is expected to be a major contributor in the upcoming season.