Police say cousin strangled off duty cop at family cabin in Pennsylvania

Paden Frey’s preliminary hearing is now scheduled for December after an autopsy and witness accounts led authorities to file homicide charges.

CUMMINGS TOWNSHIP, Pa. — A 25-year-old Lycoming County man remains jailed without bail on a third-degree murder charge in the July death of off-duty Middlesex Township police Officer Michael McGeehan, with a preliminary hearing now listed for Dec. 23 after an earlier October date was continued.

The case moved from an initially unexplained death at a family cabin to a homicide prosecution nearly three months later. Lycoming Regional Police arrested Paden Edward Frey at his Cogan Station home on Oct. 7 after investigators said witness accounts and an autopsy showed that McGeehan lost consciousness while Frey pressed a forearm against his neck. Frey also faces charges of strangulation, involuntary manslaughter and recklessly endangering another person. The charges are accusations, and Frey has not been convicted.

Police and emergency medical crews were sent to a cabin at 7190 Dam Run Road in Cummings Township early July 11 after Lycoming County 911 received a report that McGeehan was not breathing. Court records described in local reports place the call at 2:38 a.m. Responders arrived about 19 minutes later and found McGeehan on the front porch. He was pronounced dead at the scene. McGeehan, 44, lived in Shippensburg and was off duty from his job with the Middlesex Township Police Department in Cumberland County.

What happened before the emergency call is described in an affidavit of probable cause built from statements by people who attended the gathering. Witnesses told investigators that McGeehan had consumed a large amount of alcohol and that several people were trying to get him to go to bed. One account said McGeehan talked about going swimming or riding a four-wheeler. The effort to stop him developed into a physical struggle on the porch, according to the affidavit, with Frey and another man restraining him.

McGeehan’s son told investigators that Frey placed his forearm across the middle of McGeehan’s neck while McGeehan was being held down, according to reports describing the affidavit. The son said his father continued to struggle and appeared to have difficulty breathing during a confrontation that lasted about 10 minutes or longer. McGeehan’s wife told investigators that Frey ordered her to move away while he was on top of McGeehan and warned that he would “put him to sleep” if he did not stop. Authorities allege the pressure continued until McGeehan lost consciousness.

The charging document also focuses on what investigators say happened once McGeehan became unresponsive. Witnesses told police that Frey left McGeehan on the porch and went inside rather than giving aid. Investigators said that account differed materially from Frey’s initial description of events. Frey told police that he and another person had been fighting with McGeehan while trying to get him to sleep and that they eventually got him to lie on the porch, where Frey said McGeehan fell asleep. Investigators allege Frey did not initially disclose that he had pressed against McGeehan’s neck until McGeehan lost consciousness.

An autopsy conducted July 13 became a central part of the investigation. According to the probable-cause affidavit and police accounts, the examination identified manual strangulation caused by forearm compression of the neck as McGeehan’s cause of death. The Lycoming County Coroner’s Office classified the manner of death as homicide. Other accounts of the autopsy referenced blunt-force head injuries and underlying or contributing health conditions, including cardiovascular disease, obesity, a history of sleep apnea and alcohol-related findings. Authorities nevertheless identified the forearm compression as the fatal mechanism supporting the homicide investigation.

That medical finding, combined with witness statements, preceded Frey’s arrest. Lycoming Regional Police said officers took him into custody without incident on Oct. 7 with assistance from the Lycoming County Sheriff’s Office. Frey was arraigned before Magisterial District Judge Denise Dieter and committed to Lycoming County Prison without bail. Later reporting based on court records said the bail decision reflected the court’s conclusion that no available condition would adequately protect the community. Frey’s original preliminary hearing was scheduled for Oct. 21 before being continued to Dec. 23. Court records cited by Daily Voice identify Williamsport attorney George Edward Lepley Jr. as his lawyer.

The third-degree murder count places the prosecution’s allegations beyond an accidental-death theory. Pennsylvania law defines first-degree murder as an intentional killing and second-degree murder as a killing committed during certain felonies. Third-degree murder covers other killings that meet the legal requirements for murder and is graded as a first-degree felony. Pennsylvania appellate courts have held that third-degree murder requires proof of malice, a legal concept that can include conduct showing an extreme and conscious disregard for the danger of death or serious bodily injury. Whether prosecutors can prove that standard in Frey’s case has not yet been decided.

The separate strangulation count is also tied directly to investigators’ description of the porch confrontation. Pennsylvania’s strangulation statute applies when a person knowingly or intentionally impedes another person’s breathing or blood circulation by applying pressure to the throat or neck or by blocking the person’s nose and mouth. Prosecutors have not yet had to prove that charge at trial. At this stage, the allegation rests on the affidavit, witness statements and medical findings cited by police.

McGeehan’s death left the Middlesex Township Police Department mourning an officer whose passing was initially announced publicly without any allegation of homicide. The department said in July that he had served there for 12 years and described him as a trusted colleague who brought professionalism, compassion and reliability to his work. After the homicide ruling and Frey’s arrest became public, Police Chief Andrew Bassler said he had been surprised to learn the death had been classified as a homicide but believed the charges followed from the information developed by investigators. McGeehan was later posthumously promoted to corporal.

McGeehan had been part of law enforcement since 2001, according to regional police. His obituary said he was a 2001 graduate of Northern High School and later graduated from HACC’s Municipal Police Academy, where he served as president of his academy class. Away from his police work, relatives and colleagues remembered him as a husband, father and youth sports coach. He is survived by his wife and five sons. A memorial fundraising campaign established after his death also highlighted the time he spent coaching track and football and supporting his children.

The prosecution remains at a preliminary stage, months after the early-morning gathering that led to McGeehan’s death. A preliminary hearing determines whether prosecutors have presented enough evidence for charges to proceed toward trial; it does not determine guilt. As of Nov. 18, the latest publicly reported docket information listed Frey’s hearing for Dec. 23. Regional police have continued to describe the homicide investigation as active, and no trial date has been reported.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.