Police say a 911 call, witnesses, surveillance footage and a recovered handgun quickly focused their investigation on Jaymon Trey Gilreath.
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — Eight minutes separated the first reports of a fatal shooting on Bloomington’s northwest side from the arrest of the man now accused of killing 24-year-old Noah Slinkard. Police say Jaymon Trey Gilreath, 23, was found nearby after witnesses reported a gunman walking away from a North Illinois Street residence on the evening of Oct. 8.
The unusually compressed timeline forms the backbone of a murder case that investigators say was supported almost immediately by several different sources of evidence. Officers received reports of a shooting at about 8:15 p.m., found Slinkard critically wounded near the front of an apartment and began searching for a suspect seen heading east on West 13th Street. At 8:23 p.m., officers located Gilreath and took him into custody without incident. A probable-cause affidavit filed days later added witness accounts, a 911 call attributed to Gilreath, nearby camera footage and a handgun recovered along the route police say he traveled after leaving the residence.
The investigation began when several callers alerted authorities to the shooting in the 1000 block of North Illinois Street. Responding officers found Slinkard near the front doorway or porch area of the residence with a gunshot wound to the head, according to police and court records. An ambulance took him to IU Health Bloomington Hospital. He was pronounced dead at 9:49 p.m. The Monroe County Coroner’s Office later publicly identified him as Noah Slinkard, 24, of Bloomington. The circumstances described by police left investigators with both a seriously wounded victim and reports that the person believed responsible had left on foot.
Police said the man who had been sitting with Slinkard on the porch became a central eyewitness. According to investigators, he reported seeing Gilreath approach on foot, pull a handgun from his waist and shoot Slinkard before walking away. Police have treated that account as part of the evidence supporting the murder charge, but the allegations have not been tested at trial. Gilreath has pleaded not guilty, and the criminal charge against him remains an accusation. The state would have to prove the charge in court beyond a reasonable doubt.
Even as officers were responding, investigators say another significant piece of evidence was developing through the emergency communications system. Court-related reporting says Gilreath called 911 and told dispatchers he had just shot someone. That reported call did not end the investigation or determine criminal responsibility, but it gave police information they could compare with what witnesses had described at the residence. Officers searching the neighborhood located Gilreath only minutes after the original reports and took him into custody without a struggle, according to the Bloomington Police Department.
The physical search of the area continued after the arrest. Officers retraced the route police said Gilreath had taken after leaving North Illinois Street and found a 9 mm handgun in a holster near a park bench in the 1300 block of West 13th Street, next to Crestmont Park. Investigators said they believed the handgun was the weapon used in the shooting and seized it as evidence. Court reporting later said Gilreath told investigators where he had discarded the gun. Authorities have not publicly released a complete forensic analysis of the weapon in the reports reviewed for this article, so the state’s full scientific evidence remains unclear from the available record.
The probable-cause affidavit also described what investigators say happened before Gilreath reached the porch. Gilreath told detectives that he had a child with a woman with whom he had been in a relationship and that the two had planned to spend time together earlier that day, according to accounts of the filing. He said she did not arrive and did not respond to calls or messages. Later, while riding in a vehicle with friends, he reportedly noticed her vehicle near her mother’s home and saw Slinkard sitting outside. Gilreath told investigators he had a “gut feeling” that the woman was involved with Slinkard.
Three people who had been riding with Gilreath gave investigators another account of the minutes before the shooting, according to the affidavit. They said Gilreath wanted to leave the vehicle after seeing Slinkard and indicated that he intended to fight him. The witnesses also reported that Gilreath said words to the effect that they should leave if they heard a gunshot. They then heard a shot, according to the filing. Those statements are important to the prosecution’s account because they describe Gilreath’s conduct shortly before the shooting, although jurors, if the case reaches trial, would ultimately determine what weight to give those accounts.
Gilreath’s own description of the shooting contained a gap. He reportedly told detectives that he did not specifically remember what he did after approaching the residence. According to the affidavit, he recalled leaving and realizing that he was holding his gun, with its safety off, and then realizing that he had shot Slinkard. Investigators said cameras in the area captured the shooting and Gilreath leaving afterward. The available public reporting does not provide the full video or a detailed account of everything it shows, and no trial testimony has yet established how prosecutors and the defense will interpret the footage.
After investigators interviewed Gilreath, police took him for a medical evaluation and then to the Monroe County Jail. He was accused of murder, which Indiana law defines as knowingly or intentionally killing another human being. At an Oct. 12 preliminary hearing, Gilreath entered a not-guilty plea. Indiana Public Media reported that he asked whether he could be released to stay with his mother and children and referred to his lack of prior felonies. Court Commissioner Bret Raper told him he was not eligible for release on bond at that stage of the murder case. A public defender was present as Gilreath was advised of his rights.
The case illustrates how quickly an initial emergency response can develop into a criminal prosecution without resolving the central legal question of guilt. Police say they moved from multiple 911 reports to an arrest in eight minutes, and investigators soon cited an eyewitness, Gilreath’s own reported call to dispatchers, statements from the people who had been riding with him, a recovered handgun and camera footage. Those materials supported the filing of a murder charge, but probable cause is not the same standard required for a conviction. The defense remains entitled to challenge witness accounts, statements, recordings, physical evidence and the state’s interpretation of the events.
Early reports listed a bond review for Oct. 27 and a pretrial conference for Nov. 18. Those dates have now passed, but no reliable publicly indexed report reviewed for this update established the outcome of those proceedings or a later trial date. Gilreath’s last independently confirmed plea in the available reporting is not guilty. No conviction or other final disposition was located. The prosecution therefore remains a pending criminal case based on allegations that must be proved in court.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more