Pregnant Florida woman allegedly crashes car on purpose after boyfriend texts another woman

Jurors found Leigha Mumby guilty after hearing evidence that her SUV was traveling about 94 mph before it left Interstate 95.

BUNNELL, Fla. — A Florida woman faces up to 20 years in prison after a Flagler County jury convicted her of vehicular homicide and reckless driving causing serious bodily injury in a high-speed Interstate 95 crash that left her boyfriend critically injured and ultimately led to his death months later.

Leigha Catherine Marie Mumby, 25, was found guilty Oct. 14 in the death of Daniel Waterman, 22. The six-member jury deliberated for about 71 minutes after a two-day trial before returning guilty verdicts on both counts. Circuit Judge Dawn Nichols revoked Mumby’s bond after the verdict, and she was taken into custody. Her sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 2. The case turned less on whether prosecutors could prove that Mumby deliberately intended to kill or injure Waterman than on whether the way she drove that night was so reckless that it met Florida’s standard for vehicular homicide.

The crash happened Feb. 9, 2025, as Mumby drove a white 2019 Honda Passport north on Interstate 95 in Flagler County after she and Waterman left a Super Bowl gathering. Prosecutors said the couple had been arguing and that Mumby was angry after learning earlier that day that she was pregnant and after discovering that Waterman had been exchanging messages with another woman. Investigators and trial witnesses reconstructed the final seconds before the SUV left the roadway. Evidence presented in court showed the vehicle traveling about 94 mph before a sharp steering movement sent it toward the wooded roadside near mile marker 291.

That electronic and reconstruction evidence became central because one of the most dramatic accounts of the crash never reached the jury. Waterman woke from a coma months after the collision and spoke with a Florida Highway Patrol investigator on May 15, 2025. Because he could not speak normally, reporting on the investigation said he communicated with help from a letter board. He told investigators that Mumby had been driving recklessly during their argument and accused her of intentionally causing the crash. He also attributed a threatening statement to her shortly before the SUV left the interstate. Before trial, however, Nichols ruled that Waterman’s statements were inadmissible hearsay, meaning jurors could not consider them as evidence.

The exclusion changed the prosecution’s path to conviction. Prosecutors had initially accused Mumby of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon, a charge tied more closely to an allegation of intentional conduct. That count was dropped before trial after the ruling that kept Waterman’s account from the jury. What remained were the reckless-driving and vehicular-homicide charges. Under that theory, prosecutors did not have to convince jurors that Mumby wanted the crash to happen. They instead focused on the speed of the SUV, her steering, the circumstances inside the vehicle and whether those actions demonstrated a reckless disregard for human safety.

Assistant State Attorney Melissa Clark told jurors during closing arguments that Mumby had been driving at extreme speeds and aggressively. Prosecutors argued that her emotional state and the vehicle data fit together: she was upset during an argument, the Honda was moving at roughly highway-racing speeds, and a sudden steering input occurred before it left the roadway. Local reporting on the trial said an accident reconstructionist described a roughly 45-degree steering movement to the left. The defense emphasized that another steering movement followed and argued that it could represent an effort to avoid the collision rather than an attempt to cause one.

Mumby’s attorney, Reid Hart, urged jurors to view the crash as an accident that unfolded after something unexpected happened inside the Honda. The defense argued that her reaction after the initial steering input was inconsistent with a plan to crash and pointed to evidence that she tried to correct the vehicle’s path. The defense also stressed that Mumby herself was in the SUV and had learned that day that she was pregnant, arguing that deliberately steering into danger would have endangered her and her unborn child as well as Waterman. Mumby had told investigators that she could not remember what caused the collision.

Jurors rejected the defense’s explanation. Prosecutors did not need to establish a specific desire to kill Waterman to win the vehicular-homicide count. Instead, they argued that driving at about 94 mph during an escalating dispute and making the steering movements documented by the vehicle data amounted to reckless operation likely to cause death or great bodily harm. The State Attorney’s Office later said the Florida Highway Patrol investigation involved complicated technical evidence. State Attorney R.J. Larizza said the conviction reflected his office’s willingness to pursue cases involving difficult reconstruction evidence and credited Clark with trying the case.

The consequences of the crash unfolded over eight months. Waterman suffered devastating injuries, including a broken neck, and was left paralyzed from the neck down, according to trial reporting and the State Attorney’s Office. He spent months receiving medical care and at one point emerged from a coma. He died Oct. 8, 2025, after developing pneumonia. His death transformed what had begun as a serious-injury prosecution into a homicide case. Prosecutors amended the charges later that month to include vehicular homicide, and Mumby turned herself in on the added charge before being released on a higher bond while the case moved toward trial.

The case also drew attention because the account Waterman gave before his death became publicly known even though it was ultimately withheld from jurors. According to the criminal complaint cited by news organizations, Waterman said the couple exchanged angry words and that Mumby slowed the Honda before accelerating again when he tried to leave the vehicle. He told investigators that shortly before the crash she said, “I don’t care what happens, you’ll get what you deserve.” The judge’s pretrial ruling meant prosecutors could not use that statement to prove their case, creating an unusual divide between the material reported publicly and the narrower body of evidence the jury was legally permitted to consider.

The jury’s verdict therefore rested on a case rebuilt around conduct rather than Waterman’s accusation. The prosecution used speed, steering data, testimony about events before the crash and expert interpretation of the vehicle’s movements. The defense tried to turn those same seconds into evidence of loss of control and attempted correction. After deliberating a little more than an hour, jurors sided with the state and found that Mumby’s driving met the standard for both reckless driving causing serious bodily injury and vehicular homicide.

Mumby was taken into custody immediately after the verdict and remains subject to sentencing by Nichols. FlaglerLive reported that the judge set sentencing for Dec. 2 and that Mumby faces a combined maximum of up to 20 years in prison on the convictions. The sentence will determine the next major stage of a case that began with a nighttime crash, grew into a homicide prosecution after Waterman’s death and ended at trial with jurors deciding the case largely through physical and electronic evidence rather than his final account of what happened inside the SUV.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.