Sheriff visiting his mom tackles murder suspect armed with two knives

Comer McWaters was arrested after emerging from Mississippi woods, then died in Alabama custody before the murder charge could be tried.

NEW AUGUSTA, Miss. — A Mississippi sheriff visiting his mother unexpectedly crossed paths with an armed fugitive who had slipped away from deputies hours earlier, ending a search that authorities later discovered was connected to the disappearance and death of a Georgia woman. Perry County Sheriff Jacob Garner disarmed and arrested Comer McWaters, 68, on Sept. 21 after McWaters emerged from woods near the sheriff’s mother’s private driveway, according to authorities. McWaters was wanted in Alabama in the death of 49-year-old Eden Sexton of Columbus, Georgia.

The encounter brought together investigations in three states that had developed separately over several months. Sexton had been missing since February, Alabama investigators had obtained a murder warrant for McWaters, and Perry County deputies initially approached him after receiving a tip that a man from Alabama was living in the Buck Creek community under an assumed name. Local officers did not initially know the man they were seeking was wanted for murder. The case took another turn after McWaters was extradited to Alabama: He died Nov. 14 while being detained in Montgomery, leaving the murder allegation unresolved in court.

The Mississippi arrest began with information from a resident who told the Perry County Sheriff’s Office that a suspicious man had recently moved into the area and appeared to be using an alias to avoid authorities. A deputy went to the location and tried to contact McWaters, but authorities said he ran into nearby woods. Deputies searched the area for hours and alerted residents while trying to find him. Garner later said McWaters had been hiding in the woods. The search had not produced an arrest when the sheriff left the immediate operation and went to visit his mother, who also lived in the Buck Creek area.

That family visit put Garner in the path of the man deputies had been unable to find. The sheriff said he saw McWaters come out of the woods and walk toward the private drive near his mother’s home. Garner recognized him and attempted to make contact. Authorities said McWaters was carrying two large knives, became aggressive and physically resisted the sheriff. The confrontation ended after a struggle in which Garner was able to disarm him and take him into custody. No shooting was reported, and available accounts did not report that Garner suffered serious injuries during the encounter.

McWaters was booked in Mississippi on local allegations that included trespassing, disorderly conduct, assault on an officer, resisting arrest and providing false identification to law enforcement. Only after authorities confirmed his identity did the larger significance of the arrest become clear. Law enforcement records showed that McWaters, a resident of Little Texas in Macon County, Alabama, was wanted in connection with Sexton’s death. Alabama authorities had already obtained a murder warrant after an investigation by the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency’s State Bureau of Investigation.

Sexton’s disappearance had been public for nearly seven months by the time McWaters was arrested. Columbus police said she was last seen at about 11 a.m. Feb. 22 in the 4000 block of Victory Drive in Columbus. Her disappearance was reported to police Feb. 27, and the department’s Special Victims Unit initially handled the case. Police publicized her description while asking for information about where she had gone. At that stage, authorities described the matter as a missing-person investigation and had not publicly tied her disappearance to a homicide.

The investigation widened into Alabama in June. Columbus police asked the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency for assistance after McWaters had been identified as a person of interest and investigators determined that he was in Macon County, according to Alabama authorities. State Bureau of Investigation agents then opened an Alabama missing-person investigation. Officials later said agents developed evidence that led to a murder warrant for McWaters in connection with Sexton’s death. Authorities have not publicly disclosed the full evidence used to establish probable cause for that warrant.

Some details circulated publicly through Sexton’s friends and family as the investigation continued, but not all of them were confirmed by state investigators. Relatives and supporters said they believed forensic evidence connected Sexton to McWaters’ vehicle and property. Law enforcement officials, however, have not publicly released a detailed forensic account explaining what was recovered, where it was found or how it was analyzed. Authorities also have not released a motive, publicly described the precise relationship between Sexton and McWaters or provided a complete account of the circumstances of her death.

Questions also remain about the period between Sexton’s last known sighting and the September arrest. Public accounts from people close to Sexton said she had been staying at a motel around the time she disappeared and had been seen leaving with an older man. A friend also said McWaters had claimed Sexton left his vehicle after an argument. Those accounts were not presented in the initial Alabama announcement as established findings. Investigators instead said the evidence they developed was sufficient for authorities to obtain a murder warrant, without publicly detailing the chain of evidence that led to that decision.

After the Mississippi arrest, McWaters was held while authorities arranged his return to Alabama. He was subsequently extradited to Macon County and formally charged with murder, according to later reporting. Macon County Sheriff Andre Brunson said McWaters was later being detained in Montgomery so State Bureau of Investigation agents could conduct interviews with him. Because the case had not reached trial, the murder accusation remained an allegation, and there had been no judicial finding that McWaters was responsible for Sexton’s death.

The prosecution ended before a jury could hear the evidence. Macon County Coroner Hal Bentley said McWaters died early Nov. 14 at Baptist South Hospital in Montgomery. Brunson said McWaters had been taken from jail to the hospital and underwent two surgeries. Officials did not immediately announce what medical condition prompted the hospitalization or what caused his death. His body was sent to the Alabama Department of Forensic Science so a medical examiner could determine the official cause and manner of death.

McWaters’ death leaves a different set of questions for investigators and Sexton’s family. He can no longer stand trial on the murder charge, meaning evidence that prosecutors might have presented against him will not be tested through a criminal trial against him. Authorities have not announced that another person is suspected in Sexton’s death, nor have they publicly explained whether any portion of the homicide investigation remains active because of unresolved evidentiary questions. The available public record also does not establish whether investigators recovered Sexton’s remains, where her death occurred or how she died.

The unusual route to McWaters’ arrest also separates the case from a conventional fugitive capture. Mississippi deputies were not initially acting as an Alabama homicide task force when they went looking for the man reported to be using another identity. Their immediate concern was locating and identifying someone who had fled into the woods. Garner’s later encounter near his mother’s home turned that local search into an interstate arrest. Only after McWaters was secured and his identity established did the broader chain of events come fully into view for authorities in Mississippi.

The case therefore remains notable for both the unusual circumstances of McWaters’ capture and what remains unanswered afterward. A tip about a man using an alias led to a failed attempt to contact him, a search through woods and an unexpected encounter beside a sheriff’s mother’s home. That arrest connected Mississippi deputies to a months-old Georgia disappearance and an Alabama murder warrant. But McWaters’ death before trial means the criminal allegation against him will never be resolved by a verdict. The medical examiner’s findings in his custodial death and any further public disclosures in Sexton’s investigation are now among the remaining official developments.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.