GEORGETOWN, TX – A Texas man admitted to killing his parents, a respected retired judge, and a longtime teacher, ending a case that has left a community in mourning. Seth B. Carnes, 47, pleaded guilty to capital murder on Monday for the January slayings of his parents, Alfred “Burt” Carnes and Susan H. Carnes, both 74.
The guilty plea from the younger Carnes, who was scheduled to face trial next month, ensures he will spend the rest of his life in prison. District Attorney Shawn Dick stated that the plea brings a semblance of justice and closure to a case that has deeply affected many in the community. The Carnes family, well-regarded in their local area, leaves behind a legacy of service and commitment.
The Williamson County Sheriff’s Office reported that on January 8, deputies responded to a shooting around 11:45 p.m. and discovered Seth Carnes exiting the family home. He reportedly confessed on site to killing his parents. Inside, authorities found both victims dead from gunshot wounds.
An investigation suggested a disagreement escalated into violence. According to a probable cause affidavit, Seth Carnes allegedly shot his mother due to a belief she was attempting to drug him. His explanation for the shooting of his father was reportedly vague, implying a completion of unfinished business.
Carnes was found in possession of a Remington 870 shotgun, his weapon of choice, as taken from the affidavit. Authorities located his mother in the garage apartment where Carnes resided, whereas his father was discovered near a recliner in the main living room.
Sheriff’s Office Commander John Foster remarked on the impact of the incident, noting the profound loss of Judge Burt Carnes, whose service as a former District Judge had earned him much respect. Sheriff Mike Gleason described the community’s shock and sorrow, highlighting Burt Carnes’ dedication to justice and fair treatment in his judicial career, which spanned 24 years before his 2013 retirement.
Susan Carnes had devoted nearly 30 years of her life to teaching in various Texas schools. Those who knew her described her as compassionate and dedicated, with a tenacious spirit tied to her Czech and German roots.
The couple’s commitment to their community and each other is remembered fondly, as they had been married for over five decades. Their tragic end has left a lasting void, echoing beyond the confines of their immediate family.