Deputies responding to an early-morning emergency call found one son dead and another critically wounded inside a Waxahachie home.
WAXAHACHIE, Texas — A 42-year-old Texas woman is charged with two counts of capital murder after authorities said her two sons, ages 21 and 15, were fatally shot inside a Waxahachie home early Oct. 1, beginning with a 911 call that gave dispatchers little information about what deputies would find when they arrived.
The Ellis County Sheriff’s Office said deputies were sent about 4:13 a.m. to a residence in the 900 block of Big Sky Drive after emergency communications personnel received a call reporting an unknown emergency. Inside the home, deputies found Christopher Scott Pitre, 21, suffering from gunshot wounds and pronounced him dead at the scene. His 15-year-old brother was also found wounded and was taken to a local hospital in critical condition. He later died. Their mother, Colleen Nichole Lemmon, was at the residence and was eventually arrested, authorities said.
The first public descriptions of the case offered few details about the emergency call. Later reporting based on a probable cause narrative provided a clearer account. Dispatchers initially received a 911 hang-up call and were able to reconnect with a female caller, according to NBC 5. The caller reportedly told dispatchers that all available units were needed but did not explain the nature of the emergency before the connection ended again. Deputies were sent to the house without knowing that they were about to encounter two mortally wounded brothers and an injured woman inside.
According to the probable cause account reported by local news organizations, deputies arriving at the residence heard a woman calling for additional units. Officers could see that she appeared to have blood on her hands. Authorities identified the woman as Lemmon. The Sheriff’s Office said she had injuries that were not considered life-threatening. Deputies then entered the home and located the two brothers in separate areas of the residence. The agency has not publicly described a confrontation between the deputies and Lemmon, and its initial statement did not identify a motive for the shootings.
Investigators said evidence collected during the inquiry gave them probable cause to believe Lemmon had shot both sons. FOX 4, citing an arrest affidavit, reported that deputies found Lemmon with a firearm nearby and that she allegedly told deputies, “I shot both my kids.” The same document described injuries to Lemmon that appeared to have been self-inflicted. Those details are allegations contained in the probable cause record and have not been tested at trial. Lemmon is charged with the killings, but the charges do not constitute a finding of guilt.
Authorities took Lemmon into custody and transported her to a hospital for treatment of her injuries. After she was released from medical care, she was booked into the Wayne McCollum Detention Center on two counts of capital murder. Early reports said a bond decision was pending arraignment. Subsequent jail-record reporting placed her bond at $2.5 million. No reliable later report reviewed for this story indicated that the charges had been resolved, and no publicly reported trial or final disposition had occurred as of Nov. 16.
The Sheriff’s Office publicly identified the older son as Christopher Scott Pitre of Waxahachie. The agency initially withheld the name of his 15-year-old brother because he was a juvenile. NBC 5 later reported that the family identified the younger boy as Brian Pitre. The official handling of his identity reflected a distinction common in the early hours of cases involving juvenile victims: family members may decide to speak publicly even when law enforcement initially limits identifying information. Both brothers were described by authorities as the sons of Lemmon.
Scott Pitre, the boys’ father, later spoke publicly about the deaths. NBC 5 reported that he said the younger boy had recently celebrated his 15th birthday and that the family had been together at a lake only days before the shooting. He said he wanted justice for his sons. His account added a family perspective to a case that initially emerged almost entirely through law enforcement statements, booking information and the probable cause narrative describing what deputies encountered inside the home.
The sequence described by authorities shows how quickly the response changed from an undefined emergency to a double-homicide investigation. Deputies were dispatched because of a call that did not clearly explain the danger. By the time they entered the residence, one young man was dead, his brother required emergency medical care and investigators were beginning to secure evidence that they later said connected Lemmon to both shootings. The Sheriff’s Office has not publicly announced that another person is suspected of taking part in the killings.
Even as investigators described evidence supporting the arrest, they left one of the central questions unanswered: why the two brothers were shot. The Sheriff’s Office did not announce a suspected motive in its initial statement, and later local reporting likewise said the circumstances leading to the violence remained unclear. No verified account reviewed for this story established an argument, financial dispute, custody issue or other event that investigators believe precipitated the shootings. Authorities have therefore described what they believe happened without publicly explaining why they believe it happened.
The distinction is important because the probable cause needed to make an arrest is not the same as proof required for a criminal conviction. The Sheriff’s Office said investigators recovered corroborating evidence and developed probable cause to identify Lemmon as the person responsible. Media reports have also cited statements attributed to her in the arrest documentation. Those allegations will remain subject to the criminal court process, including any challenges to evidence or statements that may be raised by the defense. Public reports reviewed for this article did not identify a plea from Lemmon or a final ruling on the charges.
The shooting also drew an immediate reaction from people living near the Big Sky Drive residence. FOX 4 reported that a neighbor described the deaths as heartbreaking and said she was praying for the family. The comments reflected the shock surrounding an incident in which two brothers were killed inside a home before dawn. Authorities did not report a continuing threat to the surrounding neighborhood, and the public information released by the Sheriff’s Office centered on the investigation at the residence and Lemmon’s arrest.
Ellis County Sheriff Brad Norman expressed sympathy to the victims’ father and other relatives after the deaths were confirmed. In the agency’s public statement, Norman said his “deepest sympathies” were with the family and loved ones. The message came as investigators were still processing a case in which the younger victim had first been hospitalized in critical condition before authorities announced that he, too, had died. The two deaths turned the initial emergency response into an investigation involving two capital murder allegations.
The investigation began with an undefined emergency call and ended, within hours, with two brothers dead and their mother in custody. What comes next will unfold through the criminal courts, where prosecutors will have to establish the allegations supporting the two capital murder charges. Authorities have not publicly identified a motive, leaving the legal case more developed than the explanation for what happened inside the Big Sky Drive home.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more