Cops say 39-year-old New York man stabbed mother then hid her body under frozen food

Joseph Petrella has pleaded not guilty to murder after deputies investigating a neighboring break-in discovered his mother dead inside their home.

ROCHESTER, N.Y. — A routine burglary call in a Penfield mobile home community became a homicide investigation after Monroe County sheriff’s deputies followed their inquiry to a neighboring residence and found 60-year-old Amy Hogan dead inside. Her son, Joseph Petrella, 39, was later charged with second-degree murder, second-degree burglary and petit larceny and has pleaded not guilty.

The case began about 3 p.m. Sept. 13, when deputies were sent to Ewald Drive after a resident reported a burglary. According to authorities and court-related reporting, the neighbor said a vehicle had been ransacked and property was missing from the home. Investigators reviewed security footage and focused their attention on Petrella, who lived nearby. What began as an investigation into missing property soon led deputies into the home Petrella shared with Hogan and to a far more serious discovery. Authorities allege Hogan had been killed sometime between the night of Sept. 12 and the following day.

Monroe County Chief Deputy Michael Fowler said deputies spoke with Petrella as they worked the burglary complaint. Petrella allowed a deputy into his residence, according to the sheriff’s office. Fowler later said the deputy noticed circumstances inside that appeared unusual and raised concern. Petrella was detained while investigators continued working to determine what had happened. Deputies then discovered Hogan dead in the residence. The sheriff’s office secured the scene, summoned its Major Crimes Unit and evidence technicians, and obtained a search warrant as the investigation shifted from the reported neighborhood burglary to Hogan’s death.

A felony complaint later provided investigators’ account of what they believe happened inside the residence. Prosecutors allege Petrella stabbed and cut Hogan multiple times with a sharp object during a confrontation. Her body was found in a bathtub, wrapped in a plastic shower curtain. The complaint said frozen items had been placed around her body in what an investigator described as an apparent attempt to conceal it. Authorities have not publicly identified a clear motive for the alleged killing, and the details contained in the complaint remain allegations that prosecutors would have to prove in court.

The sheriff’s office arrested Petrella after the discovery and initially brought the case through local arraignment court. He was charged with second-degree murder, a felony, along with second-degree burglary and petit larceny in connection with the investigation that first brought deputies to the neighborhood. The sheriff’s office said Petrella was remanded to the Monroe County Jail without bail. The burglary and larceny charges stem from conduct separate from the alleged killing, although the burglary inquiry was the chain of events that ultimately brought deputies to Hogan’s residence and led them to discover her body.

The case moved to Monroe County Court on Oct. 7, when Petrella appeared for arraignment and pleaded not guilty to the charges. His plea means he is contesting the allegations, and no court has found him guilty. Assistant District Attorney Ellie Laloudakis said after the appearance that investigators may never know every detail of what happened between Hogan and her son or what led to the confrontation. Prosecutors nevertheless contend that Petrella killed Hogan during the period between Sept. 12 and Sept. 13 and left her body inside the home until deputies arrived while investigating the neighboring burglary.

The prosecution’s public account also leaves important questions unresolved. Authorities have not announced a motive, and the available records do not establish what started the confrontation prosecutors describe. Laloudakis said the circumstances surrounding Hogan’s death may never be fully known. Petrella’s attorney declined to comment after the October court appearance, according to local reporting. The public record therefore contains an allegation about the manner of Hogan’s death and the condition in which deputies found her, but it does not provide a complete account of the events immediately before the alleged attack or any explanation from Petrella.

The sequence of the investigation is central to the case because deputies were not originally sent to Hogan’s home to investigate a missing person, welfare concern or reported assault. The sheriff’s office said they were answering a burglary complaint at another Ewald Drive residence. As investigators gathered information, their attention turned toward Petrella. His decision to permit a deputy to enter his residence gave investigators access to the home, where the deputy noticed signs that prompted further concern. The discovery of Hogan then led to the involvement of major-crimes investigators, evidence technicians and other sheriff’s personnel. A crime victim’s advocate also responded to assist Hogan’s family.

Hogan’s family described a life that extended well beyond the circumstances of her death. An obituary published by J.H. Cameron Funeral Home says Hogan was born May 3, 1966, in Rochester and was a mother of four and a grandmother. It remembered her as deeply creative, with interests that ranged from painting and crocheting to pottery, sewing, gardening and cooking. Family members wrote that she frequently had several projects underway and enjoyed making food, decorations and crafts for people close to her. They also described her garden, her love of books and the time she spent creating holiday traditions and other experiences for her children and grandchildren.

The obituary placed particular emphasis on Hogan’s relationship with her grandchildren, Clementine and Benedict, describing grandmotherhood as the role that gave her the greatest joy. It recalled sleepovers, cooking, art, games and time outdoors, as well as her close relationships with friends and relatives. Hogan was survived by her mother, siblings, four children and grandchildren. Those details provide a different portrait from the court allegations that have defined public reporting about her death, identifying her not simply as the victim in a criminal case but as a mother, grandmother, daughter, sister and friend whose family was preparing to mourn her while investigators built their case.

Authorities have also been careful to distinguish the evidence gathered by investigators from facts that have been established at trial. The sheriff’s office announced the arrest and charges after evidence technicians processed the residence and members of the Major Crimes Unit took over the investigation. Prosecutors later supplied additional allegations through the felony complaint and at Petrella’s county court appearance. But the case remains pending, and the state would bear the burden of proving the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. The available reporting does not indicate that Petrella has admitted killing Hogan, and his not-guilty plea formally disputes the criminal accusations against him.

The next test of the case will come in Monroe County Court, where Petrella was scheduled to return Dec. 4. Until then, prosecutors have left several central questions unanswered, including what they believe prompted the confrontation with Hogan. Petrella remains held without bail and continues to contest the murder, burglary and larceny charges through his not-guilty plea.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.