Timothy Kuhn faces a federal charge tied to the 2004 fire that killed 8-year-old Savannah Streber after his state prosecution collapsed.
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — More than two decades after an intentionally set house fire killed 8-year-old Savannah Streber, federal prosecutors have opened a new criminal case against the man long accused of setting the blaze, reviving a prosecution that appeared to have ended when a New York judge dismissed state murder and arson charges in 2025.
Timothy Kuhn, 66, of Pensacola, Florida, is charged in federal court with arson of property used in interstate commerce resulting in death. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York announced the one-count indictment Oct. 19, saying a federal grand jury accused Kuhn of maliciously setting fire to the rental property at 17 Yates St. in Rochester on Feb. 28, 2004. The fire resulted in a death identified in the federal indictment by the initials S.S. Local authorities and news reports have identified the victim as Savannah. The charge carries a maximum penalty of life in prison. Kuhn is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
The federal indictment marks another major turn in a case that has moved from an unsolved killing to a long-delayed state prosecution, then to a constitutional dismissal and now into the federal court system. Kuhn was arrested in Florida and arraigned Oct. 19 in federal court in the Northern District of Florida, where he was ordered detained. Prosecutors said at the time that he would be returned to the Western District of New York. The federal court calendar in Rochester now lists a status conference in his case for 2 p.m. Nov. 23 before U.S. Magistrate Judge Mark W. Pedersen. The calendar does not by itself indicate what issues will be addressed at that proceeding.
The new prosecution follows the collapse of a state case just as Kuhn had been preparing for trial. He had faced charges of second-degree murder and first-degree arson in Monroe County in connection with Savannah’s death. On Oct. 7, 2025, New York State Supreme Court Justice Stephen Miller dismissed the indictment after previously undisclosed information about the early investigation came to light. Monroe County District Attorney Brian Green said the disclosure triggered Kuhn’s constitutional speedy-trial rights. Green stressed that the dismissal was not a determination that the evidence against Kuhn lacked merit, but the ruling ended the state prosecution and resulted in his release.
The disclosure centered on information that authorities learned had been provided to Rochester police years earlier. WXXI reported that a former jail cellmate testified that he told police in 2005 that Kuhn had confessed to killing Savannah. Rochester police Capt. Greg Bello later said the information had been insufficiently documented or acted upon. The timing was critical because the newly revealed account raised the question of how long authorities had possessed evidence relevant to Kuhn’s prosecution. Miller concluded that the resulting delay implicated the constitutional protection against an unreasonably delayed criminal case. The ruling came as jury selection was expected to begin, abruptly ending a prosecution that Savannah’s family had waited years to see reach court.
Green acknowledged the impact on the family after the dismissal. He said he could not imagine the frustration and pain the ruling caused and described the outcome as heartbreaking. At the same time, prosecutors said their obligation was to follow constitutional and ethical requirements even when doing so produced a result they did not want. Rochester police also said the department had changed record-keeping systems and procedures over the years so investigative documentation could be submitted electronically and tracked. The department said its Major Crimes Unit would continue working cold cases despite the setback in the Streber investigation.
The case began shortly after midnight on Feb. 28, 2004, at the Yates Street home where Savannah lived with her family. Her mother was at work. Savannah, her younger sister, a babysitter and the babysitter’s son were inside. Investigators determined that the fire began on the back porch and had been intentionally set. The babysitter’s son detected the fire, and the people in the home began getting out. The babysitter later realized Savannah was no longer with them and tried to go back inside, but authorities said the fire had become too intense. Firefighters later found Savannah in her mother’s bedroom. Police said they believed she had gone there looking for her mother.
Kuhn became a focus of the investigation early. Authorities said he had previously been in a relationship with Savannah’s mother, Lisa Routier, and that she had a no-contact order of protection against him. Rochester police later said they believed Routier was the intended target of the alleged arson. Those assertions formed part of the state investigation, but no immediate prosecution followed the fire. The case remained unresolved for years as investigators lacked enough evidence to bring charges. It was eventually revisited, and additional information gathered during the renewed investigation led authorities back to Kuhn. Allegations about his conduct have not been proven at trial.
The long-awaited break came in late 2023, when Kuhn was arrested in Florida and returned to New York. He was arraigned in Rochester in January 2024 on the state murder and arson charges and pleaded not guilty. Police Chief David Smith publicly addressed Savannah’s relatives at the time, telling them that an arrest could not bring her back but expressing hope that having a defendant face court would provide some measure of solace. Savannah’s older sister, Kelly Streber, said the family had never stopped fighting for the case and had not forgotten Savannah. For relatives who had waited nearly 20 years for an arrest, the state prosecution appeared to provide the court proceeding they had long sought.
That expectation changed with the 2025 dismissal. The ruling illustrated how evidence about the history of an investigation can affect a prosecution independently of the factual question of who committed an offense. The constitutional right to a speedy trial limits how long the government may leave criminal accusations unresolved under circumstances governed by law and court precedent. In Kuhn’s state case, prosecutors said information revealing that police had received a significant account in 2005 altered the legal timeline. The judge’s dismissal therefore did not amount to an acquittal after a jury heard the evidence. No jury reached a verdict on whether Kuhn set the fire.
The federal government is now proceeding under a different criminal charge. Rather than charging Kuhn with New York murder and arson offenses, the federal indictment alleges arson involving property used in interstate commerce that resulted in death. Federal prosecutors describe the Yates Street property as a rental property, an allegation relevant to the federal statute they have invoked. The indictment itself is an accusation, and the government will bear the burden of proving every required element beyond a reasonable doubt if the case reaches trial. The Justice Department has not announced a conviction, plea agreement or trial result, and the new charge should not be read as establishing Kuhn’s guilt.
The federal investigation was conducted by the Rochester Police Department and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Assistant U.S. Attorney Melissa M. Marangola is prosecuting the case. The federal filing effectively places the 2004 fire back before a criminal court more than a year after the state indictment was dismissed, but it does not erase the procedural history that ended the earlier case. Questions about what evidence federal prosecutors intend to present and how the defense will respond remain matters for future proceedings.
For Savannah’s family, the federal charge creates another court process after years of investigation, a state arrest and an unexpected dismissal. For prosecutors, it shifts the case into a federal system built around a separate arson statute and a new indictment. The next publicly listed proceeding is the Nov. 23 status conference in Rochester. Until the federal case is resolved, Kuhn remains accused rather than convicted, and the central allegation surrounding the fire that killed Savannah remains to be tested in court.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more