Illinois man grabs gun after pizza fight and kills bar stranger

Jurors rejected Michael Freund’s self-defense claim after hearing how an early-morning bar encounter with stranger Dexter Perkins ended in a fatal shooting.

WHEATON, Ill. — An Illinois man has been convicted of first-degree murder nearly three years after an argument involving pizza and a bar tab escalated into the fatal shooting of a stranger outside a suburban Chicago bar.

A DuPage County jury found Michael Freund guilty Oct. 9 in the December 2023 killing of 37-year-old Dexter Perkins at Rosie O’Reilly’s in unincorporated Wheaton. Prosecutors said Freund, who arrived at the bar with two co-workers after finishing a night shift, retrieved a handgun from his truck as tensions grew, returned with the weapon and later shot Perkins on the bar’s porch. Freund maintained at trial that he acted in self-defense. Jurors rejected that argument after a three-day trial and deliberated for less than an hour before returning the first-degree murder verdict.

The confrontation began during an early-morning stop that initially appeared social. Freund and two co-workers arrived at Rosie O’Reilly’s at about 7:20 a.m. Dec. 22, 2023, according to the DuPage County State’s Attorney’s Office. Perkins, who did not know the three men, was already inside. Prosecutors said the four men talked, drank and shared food. Trial reporting described security video showing them interacting at the bar, and Perkins bought a round of shots for the other men. Nothing in the available record indicated that Perkins and Freund had a prior relationship or an existing dispute before that morning.

The atmosphere changed after another pizza arrived. Prosecutors said Perkins gave Freund and one of his co-workers one slice each, then kept the rest of the pizza, apparently intending to take the leftovers with him. An argument developed involving the food and the bar bill. Testimony described during the trial indicated that the bartender offered to remove the pizza from Freund’s tab. The disagreement nevertheless continued. That seemingly minor dispute later became one of the details that drew public attention to the case, but prosecutors presented it as only the beginning of a longer sequence leading to Perkins’ death.

At a critical point, Freund went outside to his pickup truck. Prosecutors said he retrieved a 9 mm Glock handgun and returned to the bar with it. Trial reporting also said the state presented evidence that Freund offered another handgun to one of his co-workers, who declined to take it. The prosecution used Freund’s trip to the truck to argue that the fatal encounter was not an instantaneous response to an unavoidable threat. Instead, prosecutors asked jurors to consider the decisions Freund made as the disagreement developed and before the final confrontation moved outside.

The men eventually went onto the front porch or deck. There, Perkins and one of Freund’s co-workers became involved in a physical encounter. Prosecutors described the interaction as a brief scuffle and presented cellphone video showing the men in close contact. Some trial accounts described moments that appeared to show a bear hug or dancing. Freund’s defense challenged that interpretation. Defense attorney Dave Carlson argued that the confrontation was more threatening than prosecutors suggested and that Freund believed he needed to intervene to protect against what he viewed as a dangerous situation.

Prosecutors said Freund pulled the handgun from his clothing and fired two shots into the air while the confrontation was unfolding. Perkins later went to the ground during the encounter, according to evidence discussed at trial. He then got back up and moved toward the other man. Freund fired from the other side of a wooden railing, prosecutors said. Perkins was struck multiple times and died at the scene. Authorities said Perkins was unarmed. Those circumstances became central to the prosecution’s argument that Freund’s use of deadly force was not legally justified.

The defense asked jurors to concentrate on the danger Freund said he perceived in the final moments before the shooting. Carlson argued that Perkins’ death was a tragedy but disputed that Freund possessed the intent necessary for first-degree murder. The defense also challenged the state’s characterization of the encounter outside as relatively harmless before the gunfire. That dispute placed self-defense at the center of the trial and required jurors to decide not only what happened on the porch but whether Freund’s response was legally justified under the circumstances presented in court.

Prosecutors took a broader view of the encounter. They emphasized events leading up to the shooting, including Freund’s departure from the immediate dispute, his trip to the truck and his return with a firearm. Assistant State’s Attorney Lee Roupas argued that Freund’s actions were without legal justification. The state also emphasized that Perkins did not have a weapon. By presenting the full chronology, prosecutors sought to show jurors that the shooting could not be viewed only as a split-second decision made during the physical encounter outside.

After the shooting, Freund returned the handgun to the center console of his truck, where investigators later recovered it, according to prosecutors. DuPage County sheriff’s deputies responded to the bar at about 8:40 a.m. after receiving a report of shots fired. They found Perkins dead at the scene. Freund remained at the establishment and was taken into custody without incident. Prosecutors charged him with first-degree murder, and a judge granted the state’s request to keep him in custody pending trial.

The charges remained allegations while the case moved through the court system. Freund was entitled to the presumption of innocence until prosecutors proved the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. Nearly three years later, the case reached a jury. Over three days, jurors heard testimony, viewed evidence and considered the competing descriptions of what happened between the men. The prosecution portrayed the shooting as murder. The defense maintained that Freund acted in response to a perceived threat and should not be convicted of first-degree murder.

The jury deliberated for less than an hour before finding Freund guilty. The verdict meant jurors had accepted the prosecution’s first-degree murder case beyond a reasonable doubt and rejected the defense theory that Freund’s use of deadly force was legally justified. The decision changed Freund’s status from an accused defendant to a convicted defendant and moved the case into its post-trial phase.

DuPage County State’s Attorney Bob Berlin focused on the effect of Perkins’ death after the verdict. Perkins was the father of two daughters, according to prosecutors and published accounts. Berlin said the conviction could not return Perkins to his family but expressed hope that the verdict would provide some measure of solace and accountability. The killing occurred just days before Christmas 2023, adding another painful element to the timing of the family’s loss.

The unusual dispute over pizza has remained one of the most widely reported details of the case, but the trial record showed a more complicated progression. The men had not known each other before that morning. They first socialized together, then argued over food and the bill. Freund left for his truck, returned armed and later joined the others outside, where a separate physical confrontation developed. Jurors ultimately had to evaluate that entire sequence rather than decide the case based solely on the argument that first drew attention to it.

With the jury’s finding now entered, the criminal case has moved beyond the question of guilt and into post-trial proceedings. Prosecutors had said Freund was due back in court Nov. 9 for a presentence report and motions filed after trial. The sources reviewed for this story did not provide a verified final sentencing result from that stage, leaving his first-degree murder conviction as the latest confirmed outcome.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.