Jurors found Donna Stone guilty on both charges but recommended mercy, allowing the 79-year-old to become eligible for parole after 15 years.
MADISON, W.Va. — A Boone County grandmother convicted of failing to provide necessities to her 14-year-old granddaughter before the girl died of severe malnutrition is awaiting a Dec. 8 sentencing after jurors found her guilty on both charges and then recommended that she remain eligible for parole.
Donna Stone, 79, was convicted Oct. 19 of murder by a parent, guardian or custodian by refusal or failure to provide necessities and child neglect resulting in death in connection with the April 2024 death of Kyneddi Miller. The verdict followed a five-day trial that asked jurors to decide whether Stone had an independent legal duty to act as her granddaughter’s health declined, even though Kyneddi’s mother made many of the major decisions involving the teenager. A day after the verdict, the same jury recommended mercy, meaning Stone can seek parole after serving 15 years rather than face a life sentence without that possibility.
The prosecution built its case around the argument that Kyneddi’s condition developed over a long period and could not reasonably have escaped the attention of an adult who helped care for her. Boone County Prosecuting Attorney Dan Holstein told jurors that the teenager died from severe protein-calorie malnutrition and that the physical deterioration seen after her death had developed over months or longer. Stone’s attorney, Tim Gibson, did not dispute that Kyneddi’s death was a tragedy but argued that tragedy alone did not prove criminal conduct. He urged jurors to focus on whether prosecutors had established the mental state and legal responsibility required for the charges rather than decide the case from the result alone.
Kyneddi was found dead April 17, 2024, after emergency personnel were called to a home in Morrisvale. Authorities said she was on a foam pad on a bathroom floor and described her condition as severely emaciated. Later reporting and court testimony put her weight at about 58 pounds. Investigators said she had not received medical care for years, and prosecutors maintained that her decline could be observed over time. The case did not turn on a single alleged act. Instead, the state argued that a continuing failure to obtain food, medical attention and other necessities ultimately became criminal neglect. Jurors accepted that argument as it applied to Stone.
Stone’s responsibility became one of the most contested issues of the trial because Kyneddi’s mother, Julie Miller, was the teenager’s parent and had already admitted her own criminal role. Miller pleaded guilty in November 2025 to death of a child by a parent, guardian or custodian and was sentenced in February to 15 years to life in prison. During Stone’s trial, prosecutors argued that Miller’s guilt did not erase obligations Stone assumed by helping care for Kyneddi for years. The defense countered that Miller controlled the major decisions involving her daughter and that Stone should not automatically be held criminally responsible because the family shared a home and Stone provided some care.
Testimony from Kyneddi’s father, Terry Miller, gave jurors another view of Stone’s role inside the family. He said his contact with Kyneddi became increasingly limited after 2020 and that, near the end of his daughter’s life, most of his communication with the household was through Stone. According to his testimony, Stone repeatedly reassured him that Kyneddi was healthy and simply did not want to see other people. Terry Miller said he had tried to arrange a psychological evaluation for his daughter and later consulted an attorney, but he was unable to restore regular contact. Under questioning by the defense, he acknowledged that although he had contacted child protective authorities, he did not pursue a formal custody modification through the courts.
Other relatives described a similar pattern of isolation. Family members testified that they had gone years without seeing Kyneddi in person and were told that she feared COVID-19 or did not want visitors. A relative who lived nearby said she eventually became concerned enough to ask state police to check on the teenager. Former West Virginia State Police trooper Charles Sutphin testified that he entered the home in March 2023 and saw Kyneddi after asking her to get out of bed. He said she did not appear physically malnourished at that time, although her persistent fear of COVID-19 concerned him. Sutphin testified that he later went to a local child welfare office to discuss the situation.
That contact did not become a formal abuse or neglect referral. A state Department of Human Services employee testified that such a referral needed to go through the agency’s hotline and that the department had no recorded referral concerning Kyneddi before her death. The distinction became part of a larger public examination of how concerns about the teenager moved between family members, police, schools and child welfare workers without producing sustained intervention. Testimony showed that Kyneddi had become largely removed from ordinary outside contact after she stopped attending school in person and was homeschooled during the pandemic. State officials later said a required academic assessment had not been received by the county school system.
Julie Miller’s testimony for the defense focused on the final days of Kyneddi’s life and the decisions that she, as the girl’s mother, made. Miller testified that Kyneddi had fallen several days before her death and that she realized how light her daughter had become. She said she considered taking Kyneddi to a hospital but ultimately did not do so because she believed the teenager had begun eating and drinking and appeared to improve. Miller testified that she intended to seek medical care after Kyneddi slept, but the girl did not wake up. Prosecutors used the testimony to reinforce their argument that the seriousness of Kyneddi’s condition was evident inside the home, while Stone’s defense emphasized that Miller described herself as the person making key decisions.
The case also left different legal outcomes for the three adults charged in connection with Kyneddi’s death. Miller is serving her 15-years-to-life sentence. Stone’s husband, Jerry Stone, was charged but was found incompetent to stand trial in 2025 and committed to a mental hospital. Donna Stone alone took her case to a jury. In closing arguments, prosecutors maintained that a caregiver cannot avoid responsibility by pointing to another adult when a child’s condition requires intervention. Gibson argued that Stone’s decision to call 911 when Kyneddi was found unresponsive was inconsistent with an intent to cause her death and that jurors should not turn family failures into murder without proof of the elements required by law.
The jury rejected the defense position and unanimously found Stone guilty on both counts. Its task changed the following morning when jurors returned for a separate mercy proceeding. Stone took the stand and was questioned about whether she recognized that she should have acted. She testified that she had believed Miller, as Kyneddi’s mother, held the authority to make medical decisions. When asked about a point when Kyneddi’s condition was plainly serious, Stone acknowledged that she could have called an ambulance and should have done so. The mercy verdict did not undo the convictions. It determined whether Stone could eventually ask for release.
By recommending mercy, jurors allowed Stone to become eligible for parole after 15 years on the murder conviction. Without mercy, she could have faced life in prison without parole. The separate child-neglect conviction carries an additional potential prison term under West Virginia law, with the final sentence to be imposed by Boone County Circuit Judge Stacy Nowicki-Eldridge. Stone’s age means that parole eligibility after 15 years would come when she is in her 90s. Her attorney has also publicly cited her health as part of the context surrounding the mercy decision, while prosecutors have emphasized that mercy does not erase the jury’s determination of criminal responsibility.
Sentencing is now the only unresolved stage of Stone’s prosecution. Judge Stacy Nowicki-Eldridge is scheduled to impose sentence Dec. 8, when the jury’s mercy recommendation will shape Stone’s parole eligibility but will not alter the two guilty verdicts. Her case will then move from determining criminal responsibility to administering the punishment ordered under West Virginia law.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more