idaho teen allegedly kills stepfather after trailer bathroom remodel dispute erupts

According to Michael Dudley, the gun fired during a struggle, while prosecutors say the fatal shooting occurred as he committed burglary.

NEW PLYMOUTH, Idaho — A 19-year-old Idaho man who says he never intended to shoot his stepfather faces first-degree murder and burglary charges in a case that may turn not only on how the gun fired, but also on why he entered the New Plymouth home and began taking property. Michael Dudley, of Nampa, was arrested after 47-year-old Howard Schofield IV was fatally shot Sept. 18 during a confrontation at the home Schofield shared with Dudley’s mother.

The murder charge puts an important legal issue at the center of a family dispute that began over an unfinished trailer renovation. Court records described in published reports say Dudley and his girlfriend had paid Schofield $2,250 to remodel their trailer, which the girlfriend said lacked a working bathroom and shower. Dudley told investigators that when the work was not completed, he planned to take property from Schofield as compensation. Prosecutors allege that decision amounted to burglary. Idaho law classifies a murder committed during the perpetration or attempted perpetration of burglary as first-degree murder, meaning the state’s theory does not necessarily depend on proving that Dudley arrived intending to kill Schofield.

The confrontation unfolded after Dudley and his girlfriend went to the New Plymouth residence, according to the probable cause affidavit cited by East Idaho News and other outlets. Dudley began gathering property, including a television and some of Schofield’s tools, the affidavit says. Schofield accused him of stealing, and the disagreement became increasingly heated. Dudley told investigators that Schofield became physical and began hitting him. What started as an argument about money, unfinished repairs and ownership of household property then became the encounter that prosecutors say produced both the burglary allegation and the fatal shooting.

Dudley gave investigators an account that disputes an intentional killing. He said Schofield got on top of him during the fight while Dudley had a firearm inside the front pocket of his sweatshirt. According to the affidavit, Dudley said Schofield grabbed at the gun and it discharged during the struggle. Dudley told investigators that he “never pulled the trigger” and “never intended on shooting” his stepfather. He characterized his conduct as self-defense. That account has not been adjudicated, and the criminal charges remain allegations that prosecutors would have to prove in court.

Investigators also obtained a statement from Dudley’s girlfriend that adds a separate question about his state of mind before the confrontation. She said she did not see the shooting itself, according to the affidavit, but heard Dudley telling Schofield not to hit him and to get off him during the fight. She also told investigators that before the pair went to the home, Dudley had talked about shooting Schofield in the foot “to make him jump and work.” The girlfriend said she did not believe Dudley would actually do it, and the affidavit says Dudley later described the idea as a “stupid idea.”

That earlier statement does not by itself establish what happened when the firearm discharged, but it is one of the facts investigators included while reconstructing the events leading to Schofield’s death. The distinction matters because Dudley’s account presents the shot as an unintended result of a physical struggle, while the girlfriend’s statement describes him discussing the possibility of using a gun before he arrived. Prosecutors have charged the case as first-degree murder and burglary. Publicly available reports reviewed for this story do not establish that a court has made findings resolving the competing descriptions of intent, self-defense or the mechanics of the shooting.

The burglary allegation is also more complicated than a simple question of whether Dudley had permission to enter the house. According to the affidavit, Dudley said he called his mother before going there and told her he needed compensation because the renovation work had not been done. He said he and his girlfriend intended to take items and that his mother agreed to the plan. Idaho’s burglary statute focuses on entering a qualifying place with the intent to commit theft or another felony. Prosecutors therefore must establish the elements of the charged offense, including the required intent, rather than merely show that property was removed during an argument.

Idaho’s murder statute separately provides that a murder committed during the perpetration or attempted perpetration of certain felonies, including burglary, is first-degree murder. That provision helps explain why Dudley can face a first-degree murder charge even though his reported statement to investigators was that he did not mean to fire the gun. It does not resolve whether the state can prove burglary, whether the shooting legally qualifies as murder under the facts ultimately established, or whether Dudley’s claim of self-defense succeeds. Those are issues for the criminal process, not conclusions established by the filing of charges.

Deputies were called to the New Plymouth home at about 7:30 p.m. Sept. 18 after a resident reported a shooting. The Payette County Sheriff’s Office said deputies, police officers from Payette and Fruitland and Payette County paramedics responded. Emergency personnel attempted lifesaving measures on Schofield, but he died at the scene. Dudley was taken into custody there. Authorities said at the time that the person who called 911 was not physically injured, no other injuries were known and there was no continuing threat to the public. The Idaho State Police Forensic Services crime lab, county prosecutor’s office and coroner’s office assisted in the response and investigation.

At an early court appearance, a judge set Dudley’s bond at $1 million. KIVI reported that prosecutors raised concerns about flight risk and possible witness tampering, noting that Dudley’s mother, who was Schofield’s wife, was an important potential witness. The high bond did not amount to a finding of guilt. Dudley, like any criminal defendant, is presumed innocent unless the state proves the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. Published reports later listed an Oct. 19 court date, but the publicly available material reviewed for this article did not establish a later disposition or final resolution of the case.

The case therefore remains defined by two linked disputes: a factual dispute over how Schofield was shot and a legal dispute over what Dudley was doing when the confrontation began. Dudley says he was defending himself and that the firearm discharged unintentionally. Prosecutors allege he was committing burglary when Schofield was killed, a theory that places Idaho’s felony-murder provision at the heart of the first-degree murder charge. No conviction or final adjudication was identified in the sources reviewed through Nov. 17.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.