Randy Thomas Zimmerman admitted killing Tabitha Trescott and Justin Reinarts after entering their Hanska home in November 2025.
NEW ULM, Minn. — A southern Minnesota man was sentenced to two consecutive life terms for killing his former girlfriend and her partner in a Hanska home, bringing the criminal case to an end nearly a year after a child inside the house called 911 to report the shootings.
Randy Thomas Zimmerman, 46, received the sentences Oct. 5 in Brown County District Court after pleading guilty in August to two counts of first-degree murder. Court records described the convictions differently for each victim: Zimmerman admitted intentionally killing Justin Reinarts while committing burglary, and intentionally killing Tabitha Trescott after a past pattern of domestic abuse. Prosecutors agreed to dismiss the remaining charges, including premeditated first-degree murder counts, as part of the plea agreement. The distinction matters because the convictions still require life sentences but preserve the possibility of release under Minnesota law after the applicable minimum prison terms are served.
The sentencing decision resolved the question that had remained after the guilty pleas: whether the two life terms would run at the same time or one after the other. Trescott’s family had publicly asked for consecutive sentences, saying a concurrent sentence could leave open a much earlier path to possible release. By imposing consecutive terms, the judge gave the family the outcome it had sought. Local station KEYC reported that Zimmerman received credit for 345 days already served and that the sentences would be served through the Minnesota correctional system. Zimmerman told the court, “I truly am sorry,” while expressing hope that the proceeding would bring some closure.
The case began before dawn on Nov. 2, 2025, in Hanska, a Brown County community of about 400 people west of Mankato. Authorities said a 13-year-old son of Trescott called 911 at about 4:20 a.m. after waking to an argument and then hearing a gunshot. According to the criminal complaint, the boy told investigators that Zimmerman had entered the home and that he encountered Zimmerman in a hallway holding a long gun. The complaint said Zimmerman pointed the weapon toward the child and ordered him back into his room. Deputies arrived and found Trescott, 32, and Reinarts, 50, dead inside the home.
Zimmerman’s later guilty plea supplied the most important legal admissions about what happened. Court documents filed with the plea said he entered Reinarts’ home without consent while armed with a dangerous weapon and intentionally shot Reinarts, establishing first-degree murder committed during a burglary. Zimmerman also admitted intentionally killing Trescott, with whom he had previously been in a romantic relationship, under a first-degree murder provision involving a past pattern of domestic abuse. Those admissions replaced the need for prosecutors to prove the case to a jury and spared the family a trial in which witnesses, including Trescott’s son, could have been called to recount the events.
Before the plea, the prosecution had built a broader case. Zimmerman was initially charged with second-degree murder after his arrest. Later in November 2025, a Brown County grand jury returned a nine-count indictment that included two counts of first-degree premeditated murder, two first-degree felony-murder counts, a first-degree murder count tied to a pattern of domestic abuse, two second-degree intentional murder counts, first-degree burglary and second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon. The Minnesota Attorney General’s Office assisted the Brown County Attorney’s Office with the prosecution. Under the plea agreement, prosecutors moved away from the premeditated counts, which carried the potential for life imprisonment without release.
The domestic-abuse history became legally significant because one of the two convictions specifically rested on a past pattern of abuse involving Trescott. KEYC reported from court records that Zimmerman had misdemeanor domestic assault convictions involving her from December 2023 and December 2024. The same report said he faced pending felony stalking charges stemming from a July 2025 incident in which Trescott was the alleged victim. Those earlier matters were not simply background offered after the fact; prosecutors relied on the relationship history as part of the legal theory supporting the first-degree murder count to which Zimmerman ultimately pleaded guilty.
After the killings, authorities launched a multistate search. Zimmerman drove south into Iowa, where law enforcement agencies in several counties became involved in locating him. Officials said a deputy tried to stop his vehicle and that Zimmerman fired a shot backward from the moving vehicle during the pursuit. The deputy was not injured. Officers ultimately forced Zimmerman’s vehicle off the road, and he was taken into custody after a foot chase in Louisa County. The arrest came roughly 12 hours after the first emergency call in Hanska, ending a search that had moved more than 300 miles from the crime scene.
The people killed were remembered in the region for lives that extended far beyond the court file. Reinarts was a volunteer firefighter and a longtime Brown County resident. Local reporting described him as someone deeply connected to Hanska and its fire service. Trescott was the mother of two sons. Violence Free Minnesota later identified her as a confirmed victim of intimate partner homicide in 2025 and said she had recently moved in with Reinarts. Family members described her publicly as energetic and compassionate. Both victims left children behind, and relatives said the guilty plea reduced the chance that those children would have to testify at a murder trial.
The families’ reactions at sentencing reflected relief about the legal result without suggesting that the punishment could repair what had happened. Trescott’s mother, Terri Smith, had told KEYC before sentencing that she wanted the life terms to be consecutive. After the judge imposed that structure, she said the result lifted a burden from the family and made them feel that accountability had been achieved. Members of Reinarts’ family likewise said the outcome was the best available result in court while acknowledging that it did not change their loss. They said they planned to focus on healing with relatives and the communities around Hanska and New Ulm.
Minnesota law makes first-degree murder punishable by life imprisonment. The state’s sentencing statutes also distinguish between life sentences that allow eventual supervised release consideration and life without release. For certain first-degree murder convictions, an inmate cannot be considered for supervised release until at least 30 years have been served. The premeditated-murder counts that were dismissed under Zimmerman’s plea agreement could have exposed him to life without release if convicted under the applicable provision. Because Zimmerman instead pleaded guilty to the two counts covered by the agreement, his sentences retain a possibility of release, although the consecutive structure substantially changes how the terms operate compared with concurrent life sentences.
The court also left a limited post-sentencing matter open. KEYC reported that Brown County provided a 30-day period to finalize restitution for the victims’ families. Restitution is separate from the prison punishment and addresses qualifying financial losses connected to a crime. No later public report reviewed for this story provided a final restitution amount. The central criminal judgment, however, is no longer unresolved: Zimmerman stands convicted of two first-degree murders, and the court ordered the life sentences to be served consecutively.
As of Nov. 17, Zimmerman’s sentencing remains the latest reported major development in the Brown County case. The surviving families have shifted publicly from waiting for a trial or sentencing decision to remembering Trescott and Reinarts and dealing with the long-term effects on their children and community. The record now closes on the question that dominated the final stage of the prosecution — not whether Zimmerman would receive life sentences, which his pleas required, but whether those life terms would run together. The court’s answer was that they would not.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more