Investigators initially searched Paulsboro for a fleeing driver before medical evidence and surveillance footage shifted their focus to Maya Thomas’ home.
PAULSBORO, N.J. — Police began the early hours of Oct. 13 looking for a vehicle they had been told struck a 9-year-old girl. Within hours, investigators say, the search for a hit-and-run driver was giving way to a homicide investigation centered on the child’s own home.
Maya Thomas died later that day after being taken to Cooper University Hospital. Her mother, India Miller, 27, and stepfather, Sean Scott, 45, have been charged with first-degree murder, endangering the welfare of a child, making a fictitious report and related offenses. Authorities accuse the couple of assaulting Maya and then falsely telling police that she had been struck by a vehicle while walking the family dog. Both defendants remained jailed as the case proceeded. The charges are allegations, and neither defendant has been convicted.
The investigation began at about 1:10 a.m., when authorities received a report that Maya was not breathing. Scott told authorities the girl might have been struck by a vehicle while she was outside with the dog. Miller told investigators she had heard a noise that sounded like screeching tires before Scott found Maya near a shed on the property, according to police accounts and court records cited in local reports. Officers initially treated that explanation as a possible traffic crime and began trying to identify a driver who might have fled the area.
Dispatch records later obtained by The Philadelphia Inquirer show how quickly that search spread through the small Gloucester County borough. Officers looked for vehicles with fresh damage and tried to secure surveillance video from nearby locations, including Loudenslager Elementary School and the local fire department. Police even sought help from school officials to gain access to camera recordings in the middle of the night. The effort reflected the working theory at that point: A child had been critically injured and the driver responsible might still be somewhere nearby.
But investigators said the video did not support the story they had been given. Surveillance footage reviewed for the relevant period showed no vehicle traffic consistent with the alleged collision, according to authorities. At the same time, medical personnel were raising more serious questions. Doctors reported that Maya had extensive bruising, facial trauma and other injuries they said were inconsistent with being struck by a vehicle. The competing evidence changed the direction of the investigation from a search outside the home to scrutiny of what authorities believed had happened inside it.
Police obtained a warrant to search the residence. Authorities said investigators found wet children’s clothing with suspected blood in an upstairs bathroom, along with suspected blood on nearby tile and on cleaning equipment. Those findings did not by themselves establish who caused Maya’s injuries, but prosecutors later presented them as part of a larger body of evidence supporting their allegation that the hit-and-run account had been fabricated. Investigators also interviewed Maya’s 4-year-old sibling, who told detectives that Scott had struck Maya in the eyes and face that night, according to police.
Maya was pronounced dead at about 6:42 p.m. Oct. 13. Authorities said an autopsy documented multiple blunt-force injuries and several injuries in different stages of healing. The medical examiner ruled her death a homicide. Prosecutors have cited the older injuries as evidence supporting their allegation that the violence was not limited to a single episode. Some of the medical findings publicly described by investigators were severe, but officials have said the central forensic conclusion was that Maya’s injuries were incompatible with the vehicle collision described to police.
More details emerged during Miller’s detention hearing on Oct. 27. Gloucester County prosecutor Elizabeth Tornese told a Superior Court judge that a relative had reported Miller acknowledged she and Scott had hit Maya before the girl lost consciousness, according to The Inquirer’s account of the hearing. Tornese also said relatives had described earlier episodes of alleged mistreatment. The prosecutor argued that the evidence showed prolonged abuse and that Miller had failed to protect her daughter. Those assertions remain part of the prosecution’s case and have not been proved at trial.
Miller’s attorney, Justin Moore, offered a sharply different account of his client’s circumstances. He argued that investigative reports contained evidence that Scott had repeatedly abused Miller and that her conduct on the night Maya was found had to be viewed in that context. Moore said Miller performed CPR on her daughter at the direction of a dispatcher and suggested that Scott’s presence could help explain why Miller was not fully forthcoming with police. He asked the court to consider releasing her under strict conditions rather than keeping her in jail.
Judge Niki Arbittier rejected that request and ordered Miller detained while the case proceeds. The judge said the seriousness of the allegations and concerns about danger weighed against release. Scott had previously waived his right to a detention hearing and agreed to remain incarcerated, according to court reporting. The detention decisions determine where the defendants remain while their cases are pending; they are not findings of guilt. Prosecutors will still have to prove the criminal charges in court beyond a reasonable doubt.
The case has also drawn scrutiny beyond the criminal investigation because Maya was being homeschooled. New Jersey lawmakers began discussing whether the state should increase oversight of homeschooled children after her death, while the New Jersey Department of Children and Families opened an investigation involving allegations of abuse. Maya’s younger sibling was removed from the home and placed in emergency care, according to the department. Those developments have raised separate questions about whether warning signs could have been recognized earlier, although no final agency finding establishing such failures has been publicly reported.
What began as an urgent search for an unknown driver therefore became a case built around contradictions among the first account, the available video, medical findings and evidence inside the home. Investigators say there was no crash matching the story they were given, while prosecutors now allege that the explanation diverted police from the circumstances that caused Maya’s fatal injuries. Miller and Scott remained in custody as the prosecution continued, and the allegations against them are subject to further court proceedings.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more