Billy Buford pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter in the 2025 death of registered nurse Douglas Smitherman.
OKLAHOMA CITY, Okla. — A 60-year-old Oklahoma man has been sentenced to life in prison, with all but the first 16 years suspended, after pleading guilty to first-degree manslaughter in the killing of Douglas Smitherman, a registered nurse whose body was found at an Oklahoma City car wash in May 2025.
The sentence closes the central criminal case more than a year after police were called to the An-Son Car Wash on Northwest 122nd Street, where Smitherman, 48, had been found dead. Billy Buford pleaded guilty in May 2026 rather than proceed to trial. His plea was entered without an agreed sentence, leaving the punishment for the court to determine after a presentencing investigation. Prosecutors said Buford was sentenced in October to life imprisonment with the balance of the sentence suspended after the first 16 years. The public information released about the case does not detail every factor weighed by the judge before imposing that punishment.
The legal outcome represents a sharp change from the uncertainty surrounding the case when it began. Oklahoma City police said officers were dispatched at 12:36 p.m. May 2, 2025, to a car wash near Northwest 122nd Street and North Pennsylvania Avenue after a report of a deceased person. Officers found Smitherman with injuries that police described as consistent with homicide. At that point, investigators had no suspect in custody and released few details about what had happened. Police designated the death as the city’s 24th homicide investigation of 2025 and appealed to anyone with information to contact detectives.
As the investigation developed, authorities tied Buford to Smitherman’s death. Investigators concluded that Smitherman had been repeatedly struck in the head with a wooden 2-by-4 at the car wash. Buford was later arrested in connection with the killing, and prosecutors initially pursued a homicide case against him. Reporting on the court case indicates he was originally charged with first-degree murder before the prosecution was resolved through his guilty plea to the lesser offense of first-degree manslaughter. The guilty plea meant there would be no trial requiring prosecutors to prove the original murder accusation to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt.
The published record offers some context for the conflict between the men but does not establish a definitive motive for the fatal encounter. Authorities said Buford and Smitherman had been involved in confrontations during the days before Smitherman died, including a fight in which the men reportedly threw bricks at one another. What caused that dispute, what happened between those earlier clashes and the final encounter, and what immediately triggered the fatal assault have not been publicly explained in the information released by authorities. The absence of a fully stated motive remained one of the significant unanswered questions even after Buford admitted criminal responsibility for Smitherman’s death.
Buford’s decision to enter what is commonly described in reporting on the case as a blind plea was important to the sentencing process. Unlike a negotiated plea that specifies or recommends a particular punishment, his plea did not come with an agreed sentence. That left the court to determine the penalty after the conviction was entered. Prosecutors said a presentencing investigation was completed before the sentence was imposed. The publicly available accounts do not disclose the full contents of that investigation or identify all of the arguments presented by the prosecution and defense at sentencing, so conclusions about why the court selected the particular split between imprisonment and the suspended portion would go beyond the released record.
For Smitherman’s family, the court case followed months of grief that began before detectives had publicly identified a suspect. His mother, Barbara Smitherman, described her son in interviews as highly intelligent, stylish and professionally accomplished. Friends and relatives knew him by the nickname “DougE Fresh.” She said he had worked as a registered nurse and had served as a house supervisor at McAlester Regional for about three years. Speaking about his abilities, she called him “borderline genius,” a description that later became closely associated with coverage of his death and the criminal case.
Smitherman’s obituary describes a longer professional and academic history than the criminal proceedings alone reveal. He graduated from McAlester High School in 1995 and maintained a 4.0 grade-point average despite frequent absences during his senior year, according to the obituary. He later became a certified personal trainer and worked at a Gold’s Gym in Oklahoma City before earning his registered nursing degree from Eastern Oklahoma State College. The obituary said he finished in the top third of his nursing class and eventually worked in hospitals around Oklahoma, including as a traveling nurse. It described him as a caregiver whose patients valued the attention he gave them.
His move to Oklahoma City also gave the case a personal dimension beyond the details recorded in court and police documents. Smitherman’s mother said he had returned to the city because he wanted a fresh start. He had roots in McAlester, where his family was well known to him and where he had built part of his career, but relatives said he hoped to begin another chapter elsewhere. His death came only months after the death of his father, according to his mother’s account. She later spoke not only about the loss of her own son but also about the effect of the criminal case on Buford’s family, expressing sympathy for people on both sides who would live with its consequences.
The contrast between the first days of the investigation and the eventual sentencing shows how much changed over the roughly 17 months after Smitherman was found. In May 2025, police publicly knew enough to classify his death as a homicide but said they had little information about who was responsible or why. Investigators asked for public assistance while working through evidence surrounding the car wash. By the time the prosecution was resolved, authorities had identified Buford, linked him to the fatal beating, brought a homicide case and obtained his guilty plea to first-degree manslaughter. The sentencing then established the punishment without the need for a jury trial on the original charge.
The sentence should not be confused with a life term requiring every remaining year to be served in prison. Prosecutors described the judgment as life imprisonment with all but the first 16 years suspended. The released accounts do not provide a complete explanation of how Oklahoma correctional rules, credits or future release procedures may apply to Buford, and the sentence should therefore be described in the terms announced by prosecutors rather than converted into a specific projected release date. What is established is that the first 16 years of the life sentence were not suspended and that the rest of the sentence was.
With Buford’s guilty plea and sentence now entered, the principal criminal prosecution over Smitherman’s death has reached its sentencing stage. The available public record still leaves unanswered precisely what triggered the fatal confrontation at the car wash and does not disclose the full presentencing material considered by the court. For Smitherman’s family, the completed prosecution follows a loss they have described through memories of his nursing career, intelligence, distinctive style and effort to start over in Oklahoma City.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more