Texas man kills ex-girlfriend with car jack then strangles her

Jurors convicted Karl Andrew Stanley of capital murder after prosecutors tied the deadly home invasion to Paola Becvar’s stalking reports.

McKINNEY, Texas — A Collin County judge sentenced Karl Andrew Stanley to life in prison without parole after a jury convicted him of capital murder in the 2024 killing of his former girlfriend, Paola Becvar, ending a case prosecutors said grew out of weeks of stalking and harassment.

The sentence followed a verdict against Stanley, 55, for the Nov. 25, 2024, killing at Becvar’s home in the Mustang Lakes area of Celina, north of Dallas. Stanley pleaded not guilty. Prosecutors said he entered the home armed with a car jack, attacked Becvar and later strangled her after a worker inside the house intervened. The Collin County District Attorney’s Office said Texas law required life without parole after the capital murder conviction, and Judge Richard Davis imposed that punishment. Jurors deliberated for less than an hour before returning their verdict.

The prosecution’s case centered on what happened inside the house and on the events that came before Stanley arrived there. A carpenter working at the residence told authorities that Stanley broke into the home carrying a car jack and began striking Becvar. The worker wrestled the tool away from Stanley, according to trial evidence described by prosecutors. The intervention did not end the attack. Stanley followed Becvar farther into the residence and strangled her, prosecutors said. The worker’s account gave investigators an eyewitness description of the entry, the weapon and the sequence of the assault.

Celina police responded after the worker called for help. Officers found Stanley still inside the home, only feet from Becvar, according to the district attorney’s office. Becvar, 51, died at the scene. Early police reporting described officers responding to a burglary call on Seattle Slew Drive during the afternoon. Stanley was taken into custody at the residence. The arrest meant investigators did not have to search for an unidentified suspect, but detectives still had to establish what occurred, document the physical evidence and determine how the killing related to the reports Becvar had already made to police.

Investigators recovered the car jack outside the home in a location consistent with the eyewitness account, prosecutors said. Detective Joseph Shires obtained warrants to search the residence, collect Stanley’s DNA and examine his vehicle. Testing later confirmed that Becvar’s blood was on Stanley’s hands, according to the district attorney’s office. Police also found what prosecutors described as a document titled “grudge list” inside Stanley’s vehicle, with Becvar’s name listed first. Prosecutors presented those findings alongside the eyewitness testimony as evidence connecting Stanley to the attack and supporting their account of what motivated it.

The evidence about motive reached back to early November 2024. Detective Frank Alegre testified that Becvar had reported Stanley’s harassing and stalking behavior to the Celina Police Department beginning that month. Police had issued a criminal trespass warning barring Stanley from her property, prosecutors said. He was later arrested for violating that warning shortly before the killing. Those earlier contacts with law enforcement became a central part of the capital murder case because prosecutors argued that the fatal attack was retaliation for Becvar’s decision to report Stanley’s conduct.

The timing became even more significant on the day Becvar was killed. Alegre testified that he had obtained an arrest warrant for Stanley on a stalking charge about two hours before the attack. The warrant had been secured, but Stanley had not been taken into custody on it before he reached Becvar’s home. Prosecutors used that sequence to show how the harassment complaints, trespass enforcement and stalking investigation directly preceded the fatal home invasion. The district attorney’s office described the murder as retaliation for the reports Becvar had made to Celina police.

Stanley’s recent contact with police also formed part of the trial chronology. Authorities said he had been arrested for violating the trespass warning in the days before the killing and had been released before the Nov. 25 attack. Initial reporting after Becvar’s death noted that Stanley faced both a capital murder charge and a stalking charge. By the time the case reached trial, the prosecution presented evidence from the worker, responding officers and detectives, as well as the physical and DNA evidence gathered from the scene, Stanley and his vehicle.

The jury ultimately found Stanley guilty of capital murder. The district attorney’s office said the conviction carried an automatic punishment of life in prison without the possibility of parole. Prosecutors did not have to persuade the jury to choose a term of years after the verdict. Davis formally imposed the sentence required by the conviction. District Attorney Greg Willis said Stanley had killed Becvar because she reported his stalking to police and said the punishment meant Stanley would spend the rest of his life in prison.

The verdict also brought renewed attention to Becvar beyond the details of the crime. Funeral information published after her death said Paola Cecilia Becvar was born April 26, 1973, in Trujillo, Peru, and was 51 when she died. She was survived by her daughter, her parents, a sister, a brother and other relatives. A friend quoted after the verdict said Becvar should be remembered for the person she was rather than only for the circumstances of her death, describing the love, faith and laughter she brought to people around her.

That distinction was important to those who knew her because much of the court record necessarily focused on Stanley’s conduct: the stalking reports, trespass warning, arrest warrant, home invasion, physical evidence and prosecution. The sentencing closed the trial phase of the criminal case, but it did not change the loss described by Becvar’s family and friends. Willis acknowledged that contrast after the verdict, saying Stanley would live with the prison sentence while Becvar’s family would continue living with her absence.

Stanley is now sentenced to spend the remainder of his life in prison without the possibility of parole under the judgment imposed by Davis. The conviction resolved the central criminal charge arising from the Nov. 25, 2024, killing. Public reporting reviewed for this story did not identify any further trial proceeding that could alter the mandatory sentence already imposed.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.