Tammra Straughter was convicted of murder and child endangerment after 5-month-old Kashan Crawford-Chatman suffered fatal head injuries in her care.
COLUMBUS, Ohio — An Ohio woman who operated an in-home daycare was sentenced to life in prison after a jury found her guilty of murder and child endangerment in the death of a 5-month-old boy who became critically ill while in her care nearly three years earlier.
Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Bill Sperlazza sentenced 54-year-old Tammra R. Straughter on Oct. 7, 2026, in the death of Kashan Roman Crawford-Chatman. Straughter will be eligible for parole after serving at least 15 years, and the court credited her with 54 days already served. A Franklin County jury had convicted her Aug. 20 following a case that centered on Kashan’s sudden deterioration at Straughter’s Reynoldsburg home, medical findings of severe head trauma and evidence investigators recovered from inside the house and from Straughter’s phone.
The case began on Oct. 9, 2023, when Kashan and his twin brother were dropped off at Straughter’s home daycare. Kashan’s mother, Stacia Crawford, had returned to work after the twins, who were born prematurely on April 25, 2023, spent several weeks receiving neonatal care. Prosecutors later said Straughter was alone that day with Kashan, his twin and six other children. During the afternoon, emergency responders were called to the home after Kashan stopped breathing. He was breathing again when medics arrived, according to an affidavit described in local news reports, and he was released to his mother.
Crawford then took Kashan for additional medical care. His condition worsened at an urgent care facility, and he was transferred by ambulance for hospital treatment. Court records say the ambulance diverted to Mount Carmel East after the infant went into cardiac arrest and required prolonged resuscitation. He was later transferred to Nationwide Children’s Hospital, where doctors found injuries that authorities said were consistent with physical abuse and abusive head trauma. Kashan died on Oct. 13, four days after the emergency call from Straughter’s home. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office ruled the death a homicide caused by a closed head injury consistent with shaken baby syndrome.
Straughter gave investigators a different explanation for how the emergency began. According to an affidavit, she said Kashan had been smiling and appeared healthy when he arrived that morning but became increasingly fussy during the day. She said she placed him on his back while she tended to another child and returned to find that he had spit up and appeared to be having trouble breathing. Straughter told investigators she tried to clear his airway, patted his back, gave rescue breaths and called 911. A civil lawsuit filed by Kashan’s mother similarly described Straughter saying that she had struck the baby on the back after he appeared to choke on formula.
Investigators focused not only on Straughter’s account but also on what could be reconstructed from the house and her electronic records. At a 2024 court hearing, a prosecutor said video recovered from inside the home showed Kashan appearing normal earlier on Oct. 9 before his condition changed in the afternoon. Prosecutors said Straughter initially told authorities there was no camera recording inside the house, but investigators later obtained footage. The evidence did not include video showing the fatal abuse itself, according to later reporting about the trial, leaving jurors to consider the medical findings, the timeline, Straughter’s statements and other evidence together.
Straughter’s phone became another part of the prosecution’s case. After she allowed a detective to examine the device, investigators found deleted text messages indicating that she had complained about the fussiness of the twins, according to an affidavit. The messages drew attention because Straughter had also told investigators that Kashan became fussy as the day progressed. Prosecutors used that evidence as part of the broader timeline they presented to establish what happened while Kashan was in Straughter’s care. The reports reviewed do not establish that the text messages themselves described an assault, and the jury’s verdict rested on the full body of evidence presented at trial.
The medical evidence was central from the beginning of the criminal case. At Straughter’s February 2024 arraignment, prosecuting attorney Scott Sugarman told the court that a deputy coroner regarded the degree of swelling in Kashan’s brain as exceptionally severe and believed it strongly indicated abusive head trauma from violent shaking. Hospital personnel also documented bruising and other injuries and contacted Franklin County Children Services. The civil lawsuit filed by Crawford said the agency later substantiated physical-abuse allegations involving Straughter while allegations involving Kashan’s parents were found to be unsubstantiated. Those agency findings were separate from the later criminal conviction.
Straughter was indicted in February 2024 on murder and child-endangerment charges, months after Kashan’s death. Prosecutors alleged that she caused serious physical harm while the infant was under her supervision. The case remained pending for more than two years before reaching a jury in August 2026. Jurors returned guilty verdicts on Aug. 20. The sentencing six weeks later converted those verdicts into a life term, with 15 years required before Straughter can first become eligible for parole. Parole eligibility does not mean release is automatic at that point.
Kashan’s parents addressed the court before the sentence was imposed. His father, Jontue Chatman, spoke about the trust the family had placed in Straughter to care for their children. Crawford focused her remarks on her son and the years of grief that followed his death. She told the court she had carried anger, heartbreak and unanswered questions, but said she did not want her statement to be centered on Straughter. Her comments returned attention to Kashan, who was 5 months and 18 days old when he died and is survived by his twin brother and other family members.
The setting of the case also drew attention to the rules governing small home-based child care operations. Ohio guidance distinguishes licensed family child care homes from smaller arrangements that can operate without a license under specified limits. Current state guidance says a person may provide care in a home for no more than six children without a license, with no more than three of those children under age 2. Prosecutors said Straughter was caring for Kashan, his twin and six other children on the day he was injured. The criminal reports reviewed do not show that Straughter was prosecuted for a child-care licensing offense, however, and her murder conviction turned on Kashan’s death rather than a separate regulatory charge.
The sentence marks the end of the trial-court phase that began with Straughter’s 2024 indictment. One report published on the day of sentencing said the defense had 30 days to pursue an appeal. A search of subsequently published material through Nov. 18 did not produce a reliable report confirming the filing or outcome of an appeal. Unless the conviction or sentence is changed through further court proceedings, Straughter’s judgment calls for life imprisonment with her first opportunity for parole after the mandatory minimum period.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 18, 2026.









Lord Abbett High Yield Fund Q4 2025 Commentary: What Investors Need to Know for a Profitable Future!
Jersey City, New Jersey—In the closing quarters of 2025, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund navigated a challenging investment landscape, marked by evolving interest rates and shifting economic indicators. Analysts noted that despite initial obstacles, investors were encouraged by the fund’s strategic allocation and management decisions, which positioned it favorably amidst market uncertainty. The fund’s performance during the fourth quarter reflected a cautious but calculated approach to high-yield debt. With inflationary pressures beginning to stabilize, the fund’s managers focused on identifying opportunities in sectors that showed ... Read more