Orlando doctor allegedly watched 7-year-old drown during playdate

Police say surveillance footage recorded critical minutes between Khushil Bandi’s struggle in the water and another adult finally pulling him out.

ORLANDO, Fla. — A surveillance camera at an Orlando community pool has become the central evidence in a criminal case against Louisiana physician Sukanthini “Suki” Subbiah, who is accused of failing to act for several minutes while 7-year-old Khushil Bandi struggled and then remained underwater before another adult rescued him.

The April 10 drowning was initially treated as an accident, but investigators later concluded that the recorded timeline showed something more serious, according to an arrest report cited by Orlando police. Subbiah, 48, has been charged with aggravated manslaughter of a child. Police allege she was the adult responsible for Khushil when he entered the pool, that she had repeated opportunities to intervene and that her response was so delayed that it amounted to culpable negligence. Subbiah has pleaded not guilty, and her attorney says the death was a tragic accident that should not result in criminal liability.

The events began as a neighborhood play date. Subbiah was visiting family in Orlando with her 7-year-old son, who had become friendly with Khushil and Khushil’s twin sister, according to investigators. Police said the twins’ mother gave Subbiah permission to take the children to the community pool. Khushil’s sister wore a life vest. Khushil did not. Subbiah later told detectives that she assumed the boy could swim because he was not wearing a flotation device. Her mother also accompanied the group to the pool, but Subbiah told investigators that her mother could not swim.

According to the police reconstruction, the children entered the water shortly after 6:19 p.m. Surveillance footage showed Khushil moving toward the middle of the pool before abruptly changing direction. Investigators described him as turning and splashing vigorously. Police concluded that he was in distress by about 6:20 p.m. The video, as described in the arrest report, is important because it gave detectives a fixed record of the sequence rather than requiring them to rely only on memories from adults and children who witnessed a fast-moving emergency.

Police said Khushil continued struggling for more than a minute before going beneath the surface around 6:21 p.m. During part of that period, investigators said, Subbiah walked near the edge of the pool and at one point made a shushing gesture. Her son asked for his goggles, and she went to get them. Detectives said that after Khushil disappeared underwater, Subbiah was seen looking toward the area where he had submerged. The arrest report does not accuse her of causing him to enter distress. Instead, the criminal allegation focuses on what police say she failed to do once the danger should have been apparent.

Minutes continued to pass. By about 6:23 p.m., investigators said the other children were questioning what had happened to Khushil. Their comments, along with the surveillance footage, became part of the police reconstruction. The children apparently did not immediately understand that he was drowning. Their descriptions reflected the confusion of young witnesses trying to interpret why another child was motionless at the bottom of the pool. Police later interviewed them as part of the investigation but relied heavily on the video to establish the timing of the emergency.

Subbiah did not enter the water until about 6:26 p.m., according to investigators. Police said she stepped into the pool but stopped when the water was roughly knee-high even though Khushil was farther away in deeper water. By then, according to the arrest report, the boy had been submerged for about five minutes. Rather than immediately retrieving him herself, investigators allege Subbiah initially directed the other 7-year-old children to try to reach him. They could not do so. Police described that decision as a major part of the conduct underlying the criminal charge.

Another adult was eventually asked to help. Police said a man who had been sitting on the pool deck entered the water and brought Khushil up after the boy had been submerged for more than seven minutes. Subbiah then performed CPR and called for emergency assistance, according to the accounts reviewed by investigators. Khushil was taken to a hospital in critical condition and later died. The police case does not dispute that Subbiah participated in resuscitation efforts after he was removed from the water; investigators instead focus on the minutes before the rescue occurred.

That timeline differed sharply from Subbiah’s early account to detectives. She initially said she believed Khushil had been underwater for roughly 45 seconds before she recognized the problem and sought help, according to the arrest report. In a later interview, she estimated that he could have been submerged for about two minutes. She told investigators that she froze during the emergency and felt unable to act. Police said those estimates and explanations did not match what investigators saw on the surveillance recording.

Detectives also emphasized Subbiah’s medical background. They said her training meant she understood that a person can suffer grave consequences after being unable to breathe underwater for an extended period. According to police, Subbiah acknowledged during questioning that it would be unrealistic for a 7-year-old to intentionally remain underwater for two minutes. Investigators argued that her professional knowledge, combined with her responsibility for the children and her proximity to the pool, strengthened their conclusion that the delay was not merely an ordinary lapse in supervision.

Florida law makes aggravated manslaughter of a child a first-degree felony when a person causes the death of someone under 18 through culpable negligence. The charge does not itself establish guilt. Prosecutors would have to prove the elements of the offense in court, and the defense may challenge how police interpreted the video, what Subbiah perceived as the emergency unfolded and whether her conduct legally rises to the level required for criminal responsibility. The surveillance recording may therefore serve not only as a chronology but as evidence both sides use differently when arguing what Subbiah knew and when she knew it.

Subbiah’s attorney, Rajan Joshi, has disputed the police theory. He said she voluntarily surrendered, cooperated with investigators and intends to fight the charge. Joshi has characterized Khushil’s death as an accident and has said the defense does not believe the circumstances create criminal liability. He also pointed to Subbiah’s career caring for patients and said she had no prior trouble with the law. He did not publicly provide a detailed rebuttal to every point in the police timeline when the arrest was announced, leaving the interpretation of those recorded minutes as a central issue for later court proceedings.

The case developed months after the drowning rather than immediately at the pool. Police first approached the death as an accidental drowning, then reviewed the video, compared it with witness statements and conducted additional interviews before seeking the aggravated manslaughter charge. That transition is significant because the prosecution theory rests on alleged inaction during a narrow span of time rather than an accusation that Subbiah intentionally harmed the boy. Investigators contend that an earlier response could have changed the outcome; the defense disputes that the tragedy should be treated as a crime.

As of Nov. 17, no later publicly reported court development located in a review of available sources had displaced Subbiah’s not-guilty position. The case remains an allegation to be resolved through the criminal process. The surveillance footage, the competing accounts of how long Khushil was underwater and the legal meaning of Subbiah’s response are expected to remain central as the case proceeds.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.