Pennsylvania Man stalks ex-girlfriend then kills her on way to work

The sentence followed a court process in which Brian Kuchinka admitted causing K-Leigh Hill-Nelson’s death but disputed that the killing was premeditated.

SMETHPORT, Pa. — A Pennsylvania man who admitted killing his former girlfriend but contested whether he acted intentionally has been sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after a judge concluded that the February 2025 shooting amounted to first-degree murder.

Brian Kuchinka, 29, received the mandatory life sentence Oct. 5 at the McKean County Courthouse for the killing of K-Leigh Hill-Nelson, a Port Allegany woman who disappeared after she failed to arrive for a nursing-home shift in Smethport. McKean County Court President Judge John Pavlock had found Kuchinka guilty of first-degree murder in August after hearing evidence about Hill-Nelson’s final trip to work, Kuchinka’s repeated efforts to follow her and digital records prosecutors said documented his attention to her in the days before her death. The judge also imposed a consecutive period of incarceration for abuse of a corpse.

The sentence brought to a close the central question that remained after Kuchinka entered a guilty plea to criminal homicide and abuse of a corpse in September 2025. Under that plea, he accepted responsibility for causing Hill-Nelson’s death but did not agree that the killing was intentional and premeditated. That distinction was critical because criminal homicide under Pennsylvania law includes different grades of unlawful killing. The court still had to determine whether the evidence supported first-degree murder, another degree of murder or a form of manslaughter. After a later proceeding before the judge, the court found the prosecution had established the intent and premeditation required for first-degree murder.

The prosecution’s case was built around what investigators reconstructed from witnesses, surveillance recordings, cellphone information and social-media records. Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Whitney Boshart, the lead investigator, testified that Hill-Nelson was reported missing after she did not arrive for the start of her 10 p.m. shift Feb. 21, 2025. Family members and coworkers tried unsuccessfully to reach her. Residents in Smethport reported seeing a distressed woman and hearing yelling and vehicle horns in the Water Street area around 9:30 p.m. Two people called 911, according to the district attorney’s account of the court evidence.

Investigators later gathered video from private homes and businesses in Smethport, Port Allegany and Turtlepoint. The recordings helped authorities trace the movement of Hill-Nelson’s vehicle and a vehicle associated with Kuchinka. Prosecutors said cellphone records also placed the two phones on converging routes. Hill-Nelson appeared to be traveling along her normal route toward work when Kuchinka drove in her direction. Once his phone reached the area of hers, prosecutors said, both devices moved in close proximity. Video evidence showed Kuchinka driving behind Hill-Nelson into Smethport before passing her and leaving his own vehicle behind on Water Street.

According to testimony summarized by the district attorney, Kuchinka followed Hill-Nelson and cut off her vehicle as she traveled toward work. When she tried to get the attention of other motorists, prosecutors said Kuchinka approached them first and told them there was no problem. Hill-Nelson was able to continue driving, but the encounter did not end there. Prosecutors said Kuchinka knew the route she normally took to work, reached another street and intercepted her again. He then entered her vehicle. Residents near the nursing home later testified that they heard what they believed was a gunshot at about 9:57 p.m.

The shooting occurred about a block from Hill-Nelson’s workplace, according to the district attorney. Witnesses saw a vehicle speed away and provided investigators with a photograph that appeared to show Hill-Nelson’s vehicle. Authorities later found that vehicle in the parking lot of a closed Port Allegany restaurant. Investigators reported finding blood on its seats, floor and steering wheel. Surveillance evidence later placed Kuchinka in Hill-Nelson’s vehicle and showed him transporting her body into the motel where police would find her the following day.

The evidence about events before the shooting also became important to the judge’s determination of intent. Prosecutors said Hill-Nelson had ended her relationship with Kuchinka and that she and family members had recently succeeded in getting him to leave her residence after he initially refused to go. Court testimony showed that she planned to seek a protection-from-abuse order the following week. Just hours before she was killed, she changed the password to a social-media account and removed Kuchinka as a connection, according to records described by investigators.

Digital evidence provided another part of the prosecution’s case. Boshart testified that Facebook and Snapchat records showed Kuchinka searched for Hill-Nelson on Facebook more than 300 times over several days. Investigators also found searches for a man with whom Hill-Nelson had recently reconnected. Witnesses told the court that Kuchinka had previously accessed Hill-Nelson’s accounts without permission, and records showed his phone had been used to log in to her Facebook account repeatedly in the days before the killing. The account was accessed again after Hill-Nelson’s death, according to the district attorney’s office.

The investigation shifted to the Midtown Motel in Port Allegany after officers following up on the missing-person case came to believe Hill-Nelson could be in a room Kuchinka had rented after leaving her home. When officers received no response and opened a window, they heard a gunshot from inside, authorities said. Police established a perimeter and made telephone contact with Kuchinka. During that contact, according to testimony, he denied that Hill-Nelson was with him and told officers she should be all right.

After several hours, Kuchinka came out of the room. Troopers said they found a firearm in his back pocket with a round in the chamber. He had suffered a gunshot wound to the head that authorities described as self-inflicted and not life-threatening. After securing the room, state police found Hill-Nelson dead beneath a bed. Investigators determined that she had died from a gunshot wound to the head. Video from the motel area showed Kuchinka carrying her body from her vehicle into the room hours after she was supposed to have arrived for work.

That conduct after Hill-Nelson’s death was treated separately at sentencing. Prosecutors asked the judge not to allow the abuse-of-a-corpse conviction to be absorbed into the punishment for murder. The district attorney pointed to evidence that Kuchinka moved Hill-Nelson’s body in her vehicle, removed her clothing and concealed her beneath the motel bed. Pavlock imposed a consecutive period of incarceration for that offense, finding that the handling and concealment of the body constituted a distinct crime deserving separate punishment. Public reports reviewed for this article did not specify the length of that consecutive term.

Family members addressed the court before the sentence was imposed, describing the effect of Hill-Nelson’s death on her father, siblings, aunts and young son. Kuchinka did not make a statement at the hearing. District Attorney Stephanie Vettenburg-Shaffer said the life-without-parole term was the required sentence for first-degree murder in this case. She also said the circumstances did not establish one of the statutory aggravating factors needed for Pennsylvania’s death penalty, making the life term the controlling punishment once the first-degree murder finding was entered.

With the Oct. 5 sentencing, the court completed the central criminal proceedings that began with Hill-Nelson’s death in February 2025. Kuchinka’s first-degree murder conviction carries life imprisonment without parole, while the separate abuse-of-a-corpse sentence runs consecutively. No further court proceeding was identified in the public case information reviewed for this report.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.