Philadelphia woman helped boyfriend spin fake car crash story after he beat her 4-year-old son to death

Jurors rejected first-degree murder but convicted both defendants of third-degree murder and other offenses after a trial centered on abuse, surveillance footage and false accounts.

PHILADELPHIA, Penn. — A Philadelphia jury convicted Dominique Bailey and her boyfriend, Kevin Spencer, of third-degree murder in the death of Bailey’s 4-year-old son, Damari Carter, nearly three years after the boy disappeared from a West Philadelphia apartment and months after his remains were found in a duffel bag.

The verdict resolved the central question of criminal responsibility in a case that began not with a formal missing-child report, but with worried relatives challenging an account that Damari had died in a traffic accident. Jurors found Bailey and Spencer guilty of third-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal use of a communication facility, false reports to law enforcement, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse. They were acquitted of first-degree murder, according to local reporting on the verdict. Both are scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 4 before Philadelphia Common Pleas Court Judge Roxanne Covington.

Prosecutors built the case around what they described as a sustained pattern of abuse followed by an effort to make Damari disappear from the lives of relatives and investigators. The Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office said Bailey and Damari had moved from Texas to the home of Bailey’s father in West Philadelphia in 2023. Damari was developmentally delayed and nonverbal, prosecutors said. Bailey’s father, Frank Bailey, had offered to help care for him. After Dominique Bailey began seeing Spencer, however, prosecutors said she increasingly left Damari unattended and later moved with the child into Spencer’s apartment on the 3800 block of Reno Street.

The evidence presented to jurors focused heavily on the first days of December 2023. According to prosecutors, a hallway camera recorded Damari entering Spencer’s apartment on Dec. 5. It was the last time the child appeared on that camera. Audio captured on Dec. 5, 6 and 7 included the sounds of Damari crying and what prosecutors described as beatings. Investigators also recovered deleted videos from Spencer’s cellphone that showed the boy with injuries to his head and face on Dec. 7. The medical evidence later established that Damari died from what the medical examiner classified as homicidal violence.

A downstairs neighbor became an important witness in reconstructing what happened inside the apartment. She said she repeatedly heard a child crying and sounds she believed were associated with physical abuse. The neighbor began recording audio from outside the apartment and contacted Philadelphia’s Department of Human Services on Dec. 7. At a 2024 preliminary hearing, prosecutors said the agency did not intervene before Damari died. An official with the city’s Office of Children and Families said at the time that Damari was not in DHS custody and was not receiving services. State confidentiality law limited what the agency could disclose publicly about its handling of the report.

The surveillance evidence continued after Damari disappeared from view. Prosecutors said Spencer was recorded leaving the apartment with a large trash bag on Dec. 8. The next day, a camera showed him departing with a black Puma duffel bag. Months later, Damari’s remains would be recovered inside a black Puma bag. Prosecutors also said the clothes found with his body matched clothing shown in a Dec. 7 cellphone video. That sequence gave jurors a physical and digital timeline connecting the child’s last known days in the apartment with the later recovery of his remains.

Meanwhile, Damari’s family was being given a different explanation. Relatives had not seen the boy since around his fourth birthday in late November. Prosecutors said Bailey told family members that Damari had been struck and killed by a vehicle. Her relatives were not satisfied with that account. They put up missing-person posters and contacted local news organizations while trying to learn what had happened. The Philadelphia Police Department’s Special Victims Unit began investigating on Dec. 30 after receiving information about a missing child through a local news outlet.

Detectives first tested the traffic-crash story rather than assuming it was false. They checked hospitals, the medical examiner’s office and the police Crash Investigation Unit for any record of a collision involving a 4-year-old boy. Prosecutors said the checks produced no matching accident or death. Police then located Bailey on Jan. 4, 2024. She initially told investigators that she had been walking with Damari when he dropped a toy and was hit by a vehicle near 40th Street and Lancaster Avenue, according to the District Attorney’s Office. Under further questioning, she shifted the account and said Spencer had been the person walking with Damari.

Spencer initially denied knowing Damari, prosecutors said, before giving detectives a similar version of the traffic-crash story. Both defendants said an ambulance had taken Damari to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, where he died, and both claimed the hospital had then lost his body. Detectives found no evidence supporting that account. A search of the Reno Street apartment also found no sign of Damari or the child’s belongings, according to prosecutors. Investigators later assembled the neighbor’s recordings, hallway surveillance and cellphone evidence as they developed the homicide case.

Bailey and Spencer were arrested in January 2024, but investigators still did not know where Damari’s body was. That changed on March 18, when workers cleaning an area behind the 600 block of North 38th Street found a duffel bag containing a child’s remains. The body was badly decomposed, preventing immediate identification. Police later used DNA testing to establish that the child was Damari. The recovery site was only a short distance from the apartment where investigators believed the boy had spent his final days.

At trial, the defense challenged both the prosecution’s interpretation of the evidence and the degree of responsibility assigned to each defendant. Spencer’s attorney argued that no witness had actually seen Spencer or Bailey beating Damari and questioned what the downstairs neighbor could reliably determine from sounds coming through the ceiling. Bailey’s defense argued before trial that she was not present when Damari died and learned of his death afterward. Her attorney also contended that her changing statements reflected confusion rather than an intentional effort to deceive investigators. The jury ultimately rejected enough of those arguments to convict both defendants of third-degree murder and the related offenses, while declining to find either guilty of first-degree murder.

The distinction in the verdict was significant. Prosecutors had presented evidence they said showed repeated mistreatment, the concealment of Damari’s death and coordinated false statements after he was gone. But the jurors did not return first-degree murder convictions, which would have required findings associated with an intentional, premeditated killing under Pennsylvania law. Instead, their third-degree murder verdict established criminal liability for murder without accepting the prosecution’s case at the highest degree submitted for consideration. The related convictions also reflected the jury’s findings about the defendants’ conduct surrounding Damari’s treatment, disappearance and the handling of his remains.

For Damari’s relatives, the verdict came after years in which the case moved through several distinct phases: weeks of uncertainty about whether he was missing, a homicide investigation without a recovered body, the discovery of unidentified remains, DNA confirmation and finally a trial. His relatives had questioned the car-crash explanation long before investigators publicly established what had happened. Their effort to find him helped bring the disappearance to the attention of local media and, in turn, police. Prosecutors later credited witnesses and detectives who supplied the recordings, surveillance evidence and investigative work used at trial.

The convictions do not end the case. Bailey and Spencer remain scheduled to appear before Covington for sentencing on Dec. 4, 2026. Spencer’s attorney told The Philadelphia Inquirer after the verdict that his client had asked him to pursue an appeal. No sentence has yet been imposed, and any appellate proceedings would follow the trial court’s judgment. Until then, the jury’s third-degree murder verdicts and the related convictions stand as the latest court action in Damari Carter’s death.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.